Game Day Collingwood (2010) v Collingwood (2016)

[jmac70]

Collingwood (2010)

B: Maxwell N Brown Toovey
HB: O'Brien Reid Shaw
C: Wellingham Swan Johnson
HF: Didak Cloke Ball
F: Beams Dawes L Brown
R: Jolly Pendlebury Thomas
Int: Davis Sidebottom Macaffer Blair

Collingwood (2016)

B: Williams N Brown Toovey
HB: Langdon Reid Maynard
C: Varcoe Treloar Sidebottom
HF: Elliott Cloke Crisp
F: Fasolo Moore Swan
R: Grundy Pendlebury Adams
Int: De Goey Howe Aish Greenwood

Who wins and by how much?

 

[boxy99]

2010 by 10 goals

 

[sirlothie]

2010 comfortably...

 

[Baird]

2010 because Malthouse was coach.

 

[Collingwood pro]

Pendlebury, Swan, Thomas, Reid, O'Brien, Shaw, Toovey, Maxwell, Johnson, Dawes, Davis all at the top of their respective games. So 2010 by a long shot.

 

[WalterBlaknWhte]

2010 8 to 10 goals


(The jumpers would confuse me)

 

[Laurie Holden]

I think that side as they were would be down the bottom of the ladder in today's landscape. The amount of changes in the game in the 5 years make me believe that the current side would win quite easily.

 

[jmac70]

I think that side as they were would be down the bottom of the ladder in today's landscape. The amount of changes in the game in the 5 years make me believe that the current side would win quite easily.

Interesting take. The 2010 team played with an intensity and cohesion that the current side cannot yet reach. On talent I reckon the sides are pretty equal.

 

[left at home]

2010 team would win, vastly more experience team. though not as much as people think on the score board

 

[popin]

Collingwood (2010)

B: Maxwell N Brown Toovey
HB: O'Brien Reid Shaw
C: Wellingham Swan Johnson
HF: Didak Cloke Ball
F: Beams Dawes L Brown
R: Jolly Pendlebury Thomas
Int: Davis Sidebottom Macaffer Blair

Collingwood (2016)

B: Williams N Brown Rama
HB: Langdon Reid Maynard
C: Varcoe Treloar Sidebottom
HF: Elliott Cloke Crisp
F: Fasolo Moore Swan
R: Grundy Pendlebury Adams
Int: De Goey Howe Aish Greenwood Broomhead

Who wins and by how much?

I dropped tooves, the kids win.

 

[Laurie Holden]

I'd actually say there would be 10-12 sides now that could beat that team. As they were, fitness, game plan, the works. The game has seriously evolved a massive amount in the last five years.

 

[anshell]

Both are bad kicking sides.So the 2010 side would win 10 21 81 to the 2016 side 6 17 53.

 

[Bard]

2010 by a landslide. Didak and Thomas would just tear us to shreds all over the ground.

 

[jmac70]

Both are bad kicking sides.So the 2010 side would win 10 21 81 to the 2016 side 6 17 53.

That first quarter against Geelong in the 2010 preliminary, the disposal was amazing.

 

[SApies]

What channel is this on? Can't find it on foxtel.

 

[boxy99]

That first quarter against Geelong in the 2010 preliminary, the disposal was amazing.

We were about 3rd last in 2010 for goal kicking accuracy

 

[jmac70]

What channel is this on? Can't find it on foxtel.

It was on earlier in the week.

 

[Rusty22]

2010 just imo.

 

[Pera]

2010 side would maul the 2016 version.

On another note, Ben Reid used to move very nicely for a man he's size. Certainly didn't move like that when he came back late last year. He's one I'm sort of worried about.

 

[Gambit78]

Cloke's kicking for goal will be the difference...

 

[mike123]

I reckon it will be close, midfield is just about even.

Our forward line right now has more fire-power IMO.

But I think the run from half back from the 2010 ten side would comfortably put them on top.

On top of that I think the 2010 side would exploit are out the back weakness fair easy.

 

[jmac70]

I reckon it will be close, midfield is just about even.

Our forward line right now has more fire-power IMO.

But I think the run from half back from the 2010 ten side would comfortably put them on top.

On top of that I think the 2010 side would exploit are out the back weakness fair easy.

Jolly in the ruck would probably give Grundy a bit of a lesson too.

 

[mike123]

Jolly in the ruck would probably give Grundy a bit of a lesson too.

True but Grundy is better when the ball hits the deck. On a good day he could hold his own. Jolly pushing forward on Grundy is what I'd be more worried about.

 

[jmac70]

True but Grundy is better when the ball hits the deck. On a good day he could hold his own. Jolly pushing forward on Grundy is what I'd be more worried about.

Me too. Jolly was a beast in 2010.

 

[loki04]

The 2008 squad is closer to the mark with 2008 form and experience. Poll that if people don't go off players 2010 form things may even up a fair bit.