Unofficial Preview Rd 4 Changes and Preview Thread Vs Freo

[roos_fanatic08]

Out:

Garner (injured hamstring)
Thomas
Swallow
Atley

In:
Wood
Nahas
Dumont
Mckenzie/Clarke/Mountford

You can't have a game Like that and not have changes.

Swallow needs to go get some touch in the VFL I've never seen someone miss so many tackles and fumble the football so much

Thomas' pressure is non existent. His spoil was excellent in the final twenty seconds but that doesn't give him a reprieve for the rest of the game.

Atley, dunno what to do with him.

Garner sat out the last quarter with an injured hammy. Hopefully nothing serious considering his history.

If Jacobs isn't going to tag then he shouldn't be in the side. I'm not sure why they removed his tag from Jones because he was doing quite well.

Wright needs to pull his finger out as well. If we had another half back in form he'd be out as well.

 

[Flawed Genius]

I pretty much agree with this. Lock thread.

 

[tenderwarrior]

I pretty much agree with this. Lock thread.

Garner..

 

[trooroo4life]

Lets be real, Swallow isnt getting dropped/omitted.

Out:
Garner (injured or dropped)
Atley (poor, needs to go back and work his way up)
Thomas (efforts were shit all day apart so the crunch at the end that saved the game)

In:
Wood
Nahas
Mountford or McKenzie

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Jacobs has no business being in the team if he isn't tagging.

 

[Fish Sticks]

Out: Garner
In: Wood/Nahas

Take it to the bank... Scott doesn't have the balls to make the changes he should!!

Swallow, LT should be dropped... Ats & Wright very close as well...

 

[The Nostradamus]

definetly Thomas out for starters

 

[Johnny99]

I would drop Brown and bring in Wood. You cant have Petrie, Waite, Brown and Wood in the same FL at Etihad.

 

[year of the roo]

Jacobs has no business being in the team if he isn't tagging.

They release the tag and we start winning the midfield battle.

Nahas for Garner will be the only change but bringing in wood is very tempting.

I don't believe for a second that Swallow or Thomas will be dropped, certainly not Wright or Atley - we just don't have the depth down back.

 

[NMFCARSENAL98]

Out: Brown, Garner, Wright
In: Wood, Mountford, Mckenzie

 

[naturally north]

Out: Swallow, Brown Thomas, Garner (inj)

In : Dumont, Wood, Nahas and one of Mountford or McKenzie.

It won't happen though. A huge fan of Lindsay, but shit just isn't clicking for him ATM.

 

[r_boy]

We should be rotating some players.

Not only were there some poor performances but we have the depth and should be rotating players on a management principle over the course of a long season.

 

[Shinboner roo]

Isn't it funny i posted a few days ago about thomas needs to be droped to the vfl for not playing to his strengths trying to take hangers over the keys n playing for free kicks instead of doing the team thing front n square of packs ect n got machined guned at the post.. but what would i know

 

[year of the roo]

Isn't it funny i posted a few days ago about thomas needs to be droped to the vfl for not playing to his strengths trying to take hangers over the keys n playing for free kicks instead of doing the team thing front n square of packs ect n got machined guned at the post.. but what would i know

You played VFL. Your posting is VFL level.

 

[longyroos]

What does dropping the Captain accomplish? The bloke needs time to get right, his best form will come.

Thomas out, Nahas in.
Wood for Garner if injured

 

[Shinboner roo]

You played VFL. Your posting is VFL level.

So you saw L.T game today

 

[year of the roo]

So you saw L.T game today

You saw Garner get injured today? We're not kicking 2 small forwards out of the side when it's entirely the midfield's fault today that we didn't cruise to a 6-8 goal win.

 

[Mr. Blonde]

Not sure about the calls for Brown to be dropped.

 

[year of the roo]

Not sure about the calls for Brown to be dropped.

Yeah why didn't that guy get more hitouts/clearances? What a dick.

 

[Shinboner roo]

You saw Garner get injured today? We're not kicking 2 small forwards out of the side when it's entirely the midfield's fault today that we didn't cruise to a 6-8 goal win.

Champ i rekon you secretly support richmond. Accepting mediocrity with players that are struggling

 

[Deep Wells]

Out: Garner, Thomas, Brown, Swallow, Jacobs
In: Nahas, Wood, Clarke, Mountford, Dumont

 

[scooby1279]

Out: Garner injured but if not should be dropped anyway. dal santo
In: Wood and either Clarke or Dumont.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Dal looks pretty average as well.

 

[Reginald0]

You saw Garner get injured today? We're not kicking 2 small forwards out of the side when it's entirely the midfield's fault today that we didn't cruise to a 6-8 goal win.

Come on
Defence is avg at best
Freo Probly too experienced to bring mountford in
Wright playing bad and Spuds last qtr OMG
Clarke for Jacobs wood for garner or possibly Nahas

 

[year of the roo]

Champ i rekon you secretly support richmond. Accepting mediocrity with players that are struggling

I'm accepting that there are not better players in the VFL right now.

BTW Richmond supporters advocate wholesale changes every week. Seeing the bigger picture and being a bit more discerning is what separates us. Champ.