Coach John Longmire

[miggs]

Yes or No

 

[SilentHunter_]

Yes.

 

[Dan87]

F*ck me.

It could be
But probably not

See Hanners, Parker, Smith,Jack and Grundy

 

[BarneyBent]

No, not yet. Coaches go through rough patches. He has credits, but he's burning through them quickly and he won't be safe forever.

 

[scaryness]

I vote no but not for the reason in the *original* poll...

 

[Membling]

Needs to make some tactical tweaks about 4 yeara ago

 

[The King!]

No but not for the reason listed

 

[miggs]

yeah i cant edit that part out.... Mods please do that

 

[scaryness]

yeah i cant edit that part out.... Mods please do that

better?

 

[The King!]

yeah i cant edit that part out.... Mods please do that

I think he should be reviewed end of the year like the whole club should, any year really. but he has been coach a long time, even the best need to move on

But mid year sacking, nah no point imo

 

[miggs]

better?

ever the optimist, Must be nice up there in your ivory tower. Sitting in MY SEAT FFS

 

[Swansujelly]

Has he lost the players? If he has, no tweaks in the world will turn things around.

 

[Superstar swan]

Has to go. The aliir decision was absolutely ridiculous. He has shown no ability to adapt over the years. far too one dimensional and to me it looks like he has lost the players

 

[miggs]

I think he should be reviewed end of the year like the whole club should, any year really. but he has been coach a long time, even the best need to move on

But mid year sacking, nah no point imo

Yeah coz it didnt work out well with Roosy in 02

 

[The King!]

Yeah coz it didnt work out well with Roosy in 02

Yep thats the only time a coach went mid year too, its worked every time, forgot that sorry

 

[MF]

5 games out from getting us into a GF. Tad early for me.

 

[GoTheSwannies]

Sometimes the coaches performance is dictated by the players he has at his disposal. We were a gf team 6 games ago, with a team that was quite inexperienced.

Let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater.

We definitely need to tweak the game plan though. We seem slow and a little behind in terms of style, but I back horse to make the necessary changes.

I think the injuries to hanners and Parker have carried into 2017, along with the loss of Mitchell, JPK has been carrying too big a load to manage.

Get macca back and we can move Jones into the midfield and we become a much more dangerous team.

The next 4 games will instil confidence in the team and I think we'll come out the other side a much more confident team.

I have faith

 

[cinderella man]

Yeah he can **** off have had enough of his inability to be able to change his game style to take advantage of the talent he has had at his disposal and a complete waste of the $10,000,000 that is Buddy the best forward to play the game in this era. Also his and his coaching staff's failure to be able to improve the lists basic football skills is deplorable. **** him. Blow the whole thing up get rid of some highly rated overrated so called midfield guns and stick with some of the exciting young talent we have coming through and build a side around Mills & Heeney. Our top end are finished and the decline has been rapid. It does not help when 2 so called stars who should be at the peak of their powers are dead set bludging.
Oh and if Longmire goes lets hope he takes ******* Tippett with him. An absoloute embarrassment who has had every excuse in the book used for his ineptness. Pathetic.

 

[Olian]

Ross Lyon made some changes three backs and turned the season around. Does Longmire have it in him to make the changes?

 

[swansfan51]

The entire club only has $2m of balance sheet assets and it would cost that amount to pay him out of his contract.

So no.

 

[miggs]

Yep thats the only time a coach went mid year too, its worked every time, forgot that sorry

its all good my 2 headed friend, its not the 1st time you have been wrong and wont be the last

 

[The King!]

Also how much say does Horse get in list management anyway?

 

[The King!]

its all good my 2 headed friend, its not the 1st time you have been wrong and wont be the last

offering as much as your mate Sinclair on here still then.

 

[Troystenvic]

Horse inherited a good list. Done **** all with it. Players talent and drive won the 12 flag. Horse been riding off their coat tails ever since. He is not a coaches flog hole. Give me Clarko anyday

 

[miggs]

offering as much as your mate Sinclair on here still then.

yeah its hard to come up with witty 1 liners with only 1 brain