- Banned
- #26
My lifetime
Scarlett
Rance
Cox, Ablett Jr
Franklin
Fevola
Scarlett
Rance
Cox, Ablett Jr
Franklin
Fevola
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Langford
Mew
Mitchell
Buddy
Dunstall
Madden, Matthews
Weve never had a BIS ruckman so I had to look elsewhere for that one.
I think it would be tough to beat 2 eras.
Michael
Leppitsch
Voss
Black
Brown
Lynch
Keating
Akermanis bloody stiff to miss.
Or Hawks Circa 86
Langford
Mew
Platten
Dipper
Brereton
Dunstall
Dear
The 85 side would have had Matthews in it although it lost to Essendon.
Both had dual Brownlow medallists hawks probably pip them with Dunstall being arguably the greatest FF of all time.
I thought the premise was the team with the best spine? Not just the best players ever in their position lumped together to make a spine that never actually played together? If it's the former then I'd have no idea because my knowledge of footy extends back to about 2005/06 due to my age and most of the greats played well before that
If you were trying to win a GF it would be Dermie every day of the weekIf the team actually had to play a game then I'd prefer Dermott over Buddy at CHF. Controversial, I know but I think he plays better and has more value around other elite talent. In an average team, i'd take Buddy over Dermott. Also, Dermott was more of a traditional spine player than Buddy.
Langford
Mew
Mitchell
Buddy
Dunstall
Madden, Matthews
Weve never had a BIS ruckman so I had to look elsewhere for that one.
Salmon
..
agree but I just cant go total Essendon its yukHe was great when we got him but he was past his best. And his best was never as good as Madden's.
Brereton over Buddy absolutely. Could take a contested mark unlike Franklin and IMHO had more presence.If the team actually had to play a game then I'd prefer Dermott over Buddy at CHF. Controversial, I know but I think he plays better and has more value around other elite talent. In an average team, i'd take Buddy over Dermott. Also, Dermott was more of a traditional spine player than Buddy.
agree but I just cant go total Essendon its yuk
From my era....
Dench
Mew
G.Williams
Carey
Lockett
S.Madden
additional mids - Ablett Jnr, Matthews
Is Scott a forgotten man at Hawthorn?Salmon
..
All time
Hudson
Carey
Ebert
Nash
Dench
Farmer
Skilton
Matthews