Phantom Draft Bishop's 2017 Draft Thread

[footy24seven]

Won't get another game to showcase unfortunately.

Any idea Hedge or Bishop, when All Star line up is unveiled?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[LemmingMaster]

They'd probably wait until 2022 when, hopefully, Max has played three AFL seasons....and then do a fair comparative analysis.

Or you could potentially look back at to what JD was doing in his draft year? Just a wild concept.

 

[HedgeFund]

Or you could potentially look back at to what JD was doing in his draft year? Just a wild concept.

That's an option - but who has 20/20 vision or any real knowledge of his attributes when looking way back to 2011 (being Joe's bottom age year)?

 

[the big lebowski]

They'd probably wait until 2022 when, hopefully, Max has played three AFL seasons....and then do a fair comparative analysis.

Yes. Please stop all speculation in this thread until after the draft.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Who do you think North will target with 21, Bishop?

 

[crispy creme]

Any idea Hedge or Bishop, when All Star line up is unveiled?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Clubs were advised today, so I would imagine they'll be made public in the next day or two.

 

[footy24seven]

Clubs were advised today, so I would imagine they'll be made public in the next day or two.

Cheers


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Bishop]

Pick 14 fair for O'Brien? Perfect fit for our needs I reckon.

Maybe a touch early - think he's likely to be a 2nd rounder.

Any idea Hedge or Bishop, when All Star line up is unveiled?


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Few clubs have known for week or so - expecting announcement this week.

Who do you think North will target with 21, Bishop?

Hard to say at the moment - think some speed & class would appeal like a Matt Ling/Ryley Stoddart/Lochie O'Brien type.

 

[SA_Tiger11]

Bishop, a little off topic but I watched Jack Lukosius play on the weekend in his debut league game In the SANFL. He touched up one of my mates in the first half.

Will he be a likely top 5 pick next year at this stage?

 

[the big lebowski]

Bishop, a little off topic but I watched Jack Lukosius play on the weekend in his debut league game In the SANFL. He touched up one of my mates in the first half.

Will he be a likely top 5 pick next year at this stage?

If not it will be the strongest draft of all time

 

[Bishop]

Bishop, a little off topic but I watched Jack Lukosius play on the weekend in his debut league game In the SANFL. He touched up one of my mates in the first half.

Will he be a likely top 5 pick next year at this stage?

Clear No.1 for me.

 

[aussierulesrules]

Hey Bish, did you see much of Darcy Tucker in his junior years and if so, or even just based on what he's done at AFL level, how would you compare him to Lochie O'Brien?

Both have similar attributes, both talked up as good chances to go top 5 leading into their draft year, both underwhelmed, and Darcy obviously slipped to the mid/late 20's. Do you see one as being better than the other?

Any others feel free to give your views as well, eg Hedge, who presumably sees a lot of DT.

 

[SA_Tiger11]

Clear No.1 for me.

Good to hear. I'll enjoy watching his progress this year. Up the Tigers!

 

[Soups]

Bishop, a little off topic but I watched Jack Lukosius play on the weekend in his debut league game In the SANFL. He touched up one of my mates in the first half.

Will he be a likely top 5 pick next year at this stage?

He'd go number 1 this year imo.

 

[Scottie65]

Yep - but it wouldn't surprise me to see him fall in the 20s.



20m SPRINT:
1 Jack Petruccelle – Northern – 2.820s
2 Dave Smith – Murray – 2.838
3 Josh Bateman – Dandenong – 2.864
4 Troy Brimble – Sandringham – 2.877
5 Jack Evans – Calder – 2.882
6 Ed Richards – Oakleigh – 2.890
7 Ethan Penrith – Northern – 2.891
8 Nicholas Coffield – Northern – 2.892
9 Will Leslie – Gippsland – 2.898
10 Ben Paton – Murray – 2.903

stephensons posted a 2.91 before...hes quick also

 

[LemmingMaster]

stephensons posted a 2.91 before...hes quick also

Some players show their speed in games while others you see their testing results and get shocked. I remember Conner Blakely had quick testing results but you often did not see him breaking away from packs while playing.

 

[triggering bro]

Bishop if North as rumoured pick Stephenson at 4 what is the likelihood that 1 of the big 4 (Rayner, LDU, Cera, Dow) slide to StK at pick 7/8? I'm thinking Freo & Coll are a decent chance to go tall at 6/7 (Naughton/Brander).

 

[Bishop]

Hey Bish, did you see much of Darcy Tucker in his junior years and if so, or even just based on what he's done at AFL level, how would you compare him to Lochie O'Brien?

Both have similar attributes, both talked up as good chances to go top 5 leading into their draft year, both underwhelmed, and Darcy obviously slipped to the mid/late 20's. Do you see one as being better than the other?

Any others feel free to give your views as well, eg Hedge, who presumably sees a lot of DT.

They're pretty similar, both had some good athletic traits mixed with nice kicks. Reckon LOB more of a Wingman long term, whereas I've always liked DT across half back. Would think LOB ends up in the 20s, so they'll be similar in a sense.

Bishop if North as rumoured pick Stephenson at 4 what is the likelihood that 1 of the big 4 (Rayner, LDU, Cera, Dow) slide to StK at pick 7/8? I'm thinking Freo & Coll are a decent chance to go tall at 6/7 (Naughton/Brander).

I've said for a while that I think Fremantle/Collingwood could/will trade back in the trade period. While if they don't - I'd put a lot of money on the Dockers taking Brander, I can't see Collingwood taking Naughton (or even Brander - who I think they don't have ranked that highly).

Not sure where all the Stephenson talk has come from (to North) - from the things I hear, Nick Coffield's just as big as a chance to be considered at No.4 as Stephenson is.

St Kilda might end up with whoever 'slides' / remains out of the rest, but I don't see them drafting talls & Nick Coffield is one that'll be high on their list from what I can tell.

 

[triggering bro]

Bishop

Cheers. If the Pies keep their pick who do you see them going for if not Naughton/Brander (I notice your current mock has them taking Brander).

 

[Bishop]

Bishop

Cheers. If the Pies keep their pick who do you see them going for if not Naughton/Brander (I notice your current mock has them taking Brander).

Nathan Murphy or maybe Nick Coffield. We'll see. Might go for a classy ball user on the outside, opting to slide back a bit.

 

[Newatthis]

stephensons posted a 2.91 before...hes quick also

Brookes posted a 2.70 as a 16 year old after sprint training

 

[HedgeFund]

Brookes posted a 2.70 as a 16 year old after sprint training

He should be training for the 2020 Olympic sprint team then.

That's his go IMO.

 

[CaptainMurphy]

Nathan Murphy or maybe Nick Coffield. We'll see. Might go for a classy ball user on the outside, opting to slide back a bit.

Nathan Murphy? At pick 6?

 

[HedgeFund]

Nathan Murphy? At pick 6?

He's been tipped in recruiting circles to be the highest Dragon selected......

If true, he will go higher than 6.

Remember what happened in 2016.

 

[Arr0w]

Bishop I still struggle to see Coffield and Stephenson in the top 10. Are there clubs that have been link to these players inside that mark?