Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Pick 1... is Cam Rayner

So who do we take at Pick 1?


  • Total voters
    328

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

its like picking between a mars bar a crunchy and a cherry ripe ! bloody hard to go the right way
 
If Dow is backed by the Clug and the Berry, go with him, we have to draft differently to other sides.

I'm a bit surprised at the strength of feeling for this rationale.

I don't want to sound like a smartarse but since when do we let our players tell us who we should draft? It's not a popularity contest.
 
after watching those i thought it might be good to see what a star looks like in their draft video

Dangerfield (really could see the talent)

After watching those... Rayner. Dow and LDU dont look anything special
Yep, that Dangerfield highlight package was top drawer stuff and exactly how he plays now, how the hell did he get through to pick 10 in his draft year with Chris Masten, Cale Morton, Jarrad Grant and Rhys Palmer going before him.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I'm a bit surprised at the strength of feeling for this rationale.

I don't want to sound like a smartarse but since when do we let our players tell us who we should draft? It's not a popularity contest.

Experts aren't picking stayers so why not give the teammates who played with them, have moved successfully to afl level, know what it takes to step up and managed the move away from home successfully a go. Probably can't do worse.
 
Yep, that Dangerfield highlight package was top drawer stuff and exactly how he plays now, how the hell did he get through to pick 10 in his draft year with Chris Masten, Cale Morton, Jarrad Grant and Rhys Palmer going before him.
Watching that then dow and ldu... a little bit disappointing. Rayner looks better
 
Yep, that Dangerfield highlight package was top drawer stuff and exactly how he plays now, how the hell did he get through to pick 10 in his draft year with Chris Masten, Cale Morton, Jarrad Grant and Rhys Palmer going before him.

Because he was underage. Spent his first year still at home finishing school, IIRC.

As to this year, I have changed my vote 3 times.:huh: All this love for Dow because McL and Berry endorse him is over rated tho - it was just a throw away comment to answer a question that was thrust on them. no big deal.
 
I couldn't separate Rayner and LDU so I flipped a coin and it came up LDU.

But Rayner is very impressive. Got a skill set better than both LDU and Dow including aerial markng and goalsense.

I have no problem if they take him #1.

He's says he's happy to come here much like Ainsworth did last year and no-one seemed to doubt what Ainsworth said.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Is Stephenson really a Lions supporter?? Then pick him at one if he is in the conversation even if he isn’t the best, we can’t afford to keep losing our high draft picks.
I AM SURE SUPPORTERS CAN GET HOMESICK
 
I thought that from those highlights,
Dow looked the most Danger like, prepared to take on tacklers and explode from a pack. Disposal not as good though.

I think Dangerfield's "disposals" are overrated

Dangerfield, for all his explosions and tearaway speed from congestion, often absolutely butchers his disposals by foot
 
Last edited:
I think Dangerfield's "dsiposals" are overrated

Dangerfield, for all his explosions and tearaway speed from congestion, often absolutely butchers his disposals by foot
Oh he does! I just meant in the video his disposal was pristine. But it is only a very small sample.
 
Yep, that Dangerfield highlight package was top drawer stuff and exactly how he plays now, how the hell did he get through to pick 10 in his draft year with Chris Masten, Cale Morton, Jarrad Grant and Rhys Palmer going before him.
Hey, sorry for the intrusion. If i recall correctly danger sat the whole year out in his first year which clubs knew was going to happen. I think thats how he slid. Pretty sure he had to finish school or something.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Bit unfair to compare a video that only shows highlights of one game for Dow, LDU and Rayner against a video that shows a whole season of highlights for Dangerfield.
 
Highlights videos favour players that do spectacular things, even if they’re butchering the ball or shirking defensive running for 3/4 of each game. They dont pick up the value of players who do the right thing consistently.

Given where we are as a club right now, I’d take the solid citizen. LDU for me.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion Pick 1... is Cam Rayner

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top