List Mgmt. 2017 Draft - Pick 10 - Poll Added

[Psychochook]

And Pies are supposedly mad on Coffield too, though I'm not as sure about that given their trade for Sam Murray.

If it does pan out that way though, we're going to land one of Brayshaw, Bonar or D.Fogarty at #10.

My mail on this is pretty reliable too. Apparently he's pushing hard for Collingwood, as he is a mad supporter. Almost telling Freo to not draft him.

He's a great fit for either.

 

[Stamos]

My mail on this is pretty reliable too. Apparently he's pushing hard for Collingwood, as he is a mad supporter. Almost telling Freo to not draft him.

He's a great fit for either.

Naughton or Coffield?

 

[TerryWallet]

My mail on this is pretty reliable too. Apparently he's pushing hard for Collingwood, as he is a mad supporter. Almost telling Freo to not draft him.

He's a great fit for either.

I've also heard that Naughton would love to come to Melbourne to play, and in fact would prefer it. And Freo should take 2 mids ahead of another young KPD.

Surely Collingwood take either Naughton, Fogarty or maybe Brander and pass on Coffield or another mid. I'm going with Naughton ahead of Fogarty for the Pies. Fogarty maybe a tad more tantalising but Naughton a better fit as a high quality KPD surety.

Coffield feels right at StKilda or Doggies at 7-9 to me.

 

[ferrisb]

Why no love for Clark?

Is he related to Plowman?

 

[Robbo's my hero]

Haven't seen alot of under 18s footy. Is Higgins more a forward pocket type?

Picture a Josh Green type who is actually good.

 

[Lawrence Angwin]

Mick Ablett had the following with SYD going for Hayes, PTA T.Kelly but then had D.Fogarty as his #1 in Fox

1 Dow
2 LDU
3 Raynor
4 Stephenson
5 Naughton
6 Cerra
7 Bonar
8 Brayshaw
9 D. Fogarty
10 Coffield
11 Ed Richards
12 Brander
13 Allen

https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/th...t/news-story/902308a16014848da1a42698830471c1


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[LanceRomance]

It's unlikely we will go for a ruck at this pick, SOS/Brodie like Scott Jones who could be available at 73. Plus we already have three others on the list.

I think we should get a ruck

Need to get them young and develop

 

[Navara79]

Picture a Josh Green type who is actually good.

But you wouldn't use pick 10 on them though..... Would you?

 

[Robbo's my hero]

But you wouldn't use pick 10 on them though..... Would you?

I’ll leave that up to the people who know. By good I meant he gets his own ball, is not greedy, can take a mark and likes to kick a goal.

 

[Jimmae]

I've also heard that Naughton would love to come to Melbourne to play, and in fact would prefer it. And Freo should take 2 mids ahead of another young KPD.

Surely Collingwood take either Naughton, Fogarty or maybe Brander and pass on Coffield or another mid. I'm going with Naughton ahead of Fogarty for the Pies. Fogarty maybe a tad more tantalising but Naughton a better fit as a high quality KPD surety.

Coffield feels right at StKilda or Doggies at 7-9 to me.

Yup, sounds like the Saints and Freo stand between us and an LDU/Bonar double.

I think we should get a ruck

Need to get them young and develop

Better top 10 ruck next year.

 

[Mr Blonde]

For those who’ve seen a bit of the junior footy, is there scope for Coffield to push into the midfield or play on a wing or is he purely a defender?

Also, has Fogarty actually played a good game this year? His stats are fairly underwhelming.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Jimmae]

For those who’ve seen a bit of the junior footy, is there scope for Coffield to push into the midfield or play on a wing or is he purely a defender?

Some scope, but it's patchy. Some might see him as a Pendlebury type, but I'm not even sure that type works in midfield at the moment.

Also, has Fogarty actually played a good game this year? His stats are fairly underwhelming.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

He's been battling fitness all year, but played 4 reserve games and 1 seniors game for Glenelg. The rest of his games were trial matches and the championships.

 

[The Grover]

For those who’ve seen a bit of the junior footy, is there scope for Coffield to push into the midfield or play on a wing or is he purely a defender?

Also, has Fogarty actually played a good game this year? His stats are fairly underwhelming.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Coffield is versatile, was moved forward in Rd 1 & kicked 4 goals.

I think he could play wing, midfield. Played some midfield in the Allies match.

You would love him kicking inside 50.

 

[TheKITC]

I'm no guru but purely going on posters like Knightmare, media tid-bits and some highlights; Coffield does seem like a type SOS and Bolts would jump at the chance to get at 10 if he's there (seems 50-50). A composed, highly skillful, good decision making utility who is athletic, a play maker and 190cm sounds pretty good doesn't it? Hoping LDU gets to us at 3 and wouldn't mind Coffield at 10. If not him, I would be pretty chuffed with Balta personally.

 

[Psychochook]

Naughton or Coffield?

Naughton

 

[Neadsy83]

I think we should get a ruck

Need to get them young and develop

I agree we need a young ruck, but not at 10 with endurance issues. Jones is only 22 and did a 20.2 yo yo and 3.04 sprint. Averaged 31 hit outs in the wafl when playing first ruck.

 

[Nori]

And Pies are supposedly mad on Coffield too, though I'm not as sure about that given their trade for Sam Murray.

If it does pan out that way though, we're going to land one of Brayshaw, Bonar or D.Fogarty at #10.

Surely the Saints won’t go past Brayshaw

 

[Jimmae]

Surely the Saints won’t go past Brayshaw

I didn't say which one...

 

[LemmingMaster]

If Brayshaw gets to pick 10, there is something wrong with the recruiters.

 

[Iamcarlton]

What has D Fogarty shown this year for anyone/many to rate him so highly ?

 

[Funk]

Could we do the (almost) unthinkable and pull the trigger on Hayes here? With the recruitment of Lobbe we now have a two-year window where we could give a young ruckman time to develop.

I honestly have no idea what to make of Hayes though. He doesn't looks like he should be effective, but it seems he is.

FWIW of top 8 teams this year only EFC and Swans had rucks they drafted.

All other top 8 teams traded in their rucks.

I reckon we can learn from this - I wouldn't use pick 10 on a ruck.

 

[LanceRomance]

I think the saints will take brayshaw

 

[CJMB]

I think the saints will take brayshaw

They very well could. My gut feel says they might try and go for kids with some x-factor. Sonething to try and fill the apparent void of the classy player they tried to recruit kelly, Martin, Fyfe, etc. Brayshaw feels like a much safer bet than many others but he perhaps doesn’t appear to have as high a ceiling. That being said they do have two picks so they might go risky with one and safe with the other. Bonar and Brayshaw or something. I’m no scout so take everything I say with a grain f salt...

I’d love for him to slip to 10. Combined with whichever of the ‘top 4’ that we get at 3 would feel like a great score.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Blue and Silver]

What has D Fogarty shown this year for anyone/many to rate him so highly ?

It's more what he showed last year.

He is one of those players who does 1 or 2 things a game that scream "star" but hasn't done much more.

At least imo

Sent from my SM-G920I using Tapatalk

 

[Neadsy83]

FWIW of top 8 teams this year only EFC and Swans had rucks they drafted.

All other top 8 teams traded in their rucks.

I reckon we can learn from this - I wouldn't use pick 10 on a ruck.

And voth rucks were taken with late selections. Bellchambers was PSD and Naismith a rookie. I would be gutted if we burnt a top 10 pick on a ruckman this year!