2017 Draft rumours

[HumanMeatball]

No it doesn't. If you take three picks inside the top 25 and a bid for Naish comes after that stage, it means you have 3 x top 25 selections.

Naish is a top 30 talent in this draft.

 

[Kangas_11]

Naish is rated higher but estimated to be bid on later due to Father sons having a later pick due to teams looking after each other with these selections

sosos was expected to be a 35-45 selection and went much later as do most FS kids

Why would any team want to "look after" Richmond?

Naish is rated where he is rated, a team will bid on him if they view him as the best available at that point. As simple as that.

 

[Dysfunctional]

Sounds as though North and Pies are the two we are still unclear about.

North I suspect would be Cerra or Brayshaw. Whichever one is there. Could be Fogarty but I don’t see it. Collingwood could be one of a heap of players though. That’s where it gets hard. They could take Naughton/Coffield/Richards/Murphy/Fogarty. Gets extremely hard at pick 6

 

[Taylor]

The draft is very clinical, if a player is taken in the top five then they are rated a top five talent.

A player being talked about a lot due to the academy and father son qualifications lifts their expected position but their actual position will be determined by the draft.

Pre-draft talk means nothing in terms of a players standing, if a club rates them as top 5, top 10, top 20 etc they will get taken.

 

[THE_GUN]

Why would any team want to "look after" Richmond?

Naish is rated where he is rated, a team will bid on him if they view him as the best available at that point. As simple as that.

Looks like your new

 

[Pykie]

Naish is rated higher but estimated to be bid on later due to Father sons having a later pick due to teams looking after each other with these selections

sosos was expected to be a 35-45 selection and went much later as do most FS kids

Errr what?

Naish averages under 30% CP.

It’s the death zone for midfielders.

 

[Toadvine]

Errr what?

Naish averages under 30% CP.

It’s the death zone for midfielders.

Errr

 

[THE_GUN]

Errr what?

Naish averages under 30% CP.

It’s the death zone for midfielders.

Good to see you have listened to the Champion Data guys as well

Dude seriously 80% of the people who watch juniors rate this kid top 25-30
Bukkennara rated him #7-10
Twomey been saying top 15 all year
Shifter Sheehan saying mid 1st round
Wallace saying around pick 15


Go argue with these guys who know nothing about football compared to you and your 2 minute listening to SEN

 

[Taylor]

The people who are hired and fired for choosing talent will decide where Naish is rated.

 

[TradeDraft]

Richards not for me. Don’t like that at all

and Collingwood Fans would hate him to play for the Arch Rival

 

[Dysfunctional]

and Collingwood Fans would hate him to play for the Arch Rival

He’ll probably be a gun. I just don’t think we need more backline players. Need pure mids

 

[Nutjob]

Good to see you have listened to the Champion Data guys as well

Dude seriously 80% of the people who watch juniors rate this kid top 25-30
Bukkennara rated him #7-10
Twomey been saying top 15 all year
Shifter Sheehan saying mid 1st round
Wallace saying around pick 15


Go argue with these guys who know nothing about football compared to you and your 2 minute listening to SEN

Wallace lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[hilly]

If you said hello to a recruiting officer they'd probably think about it and then say hello back. I don't buy that journos are that in the know regarding team plans.

 

[Feerits Elf]

Bukkennara

knows nothing about football

Correct weight

 

[THE_GUN]

Wallace lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Think he is more qualified than you - I'll mention Nutjob to him next time ............. Think he will lol more than you

 

[Jeremias]

Naish is rated higher but estimated to be bid on later due to Father sons having a later pick due to teams looking after each other with these selections

You can't claim he's a top 25 pick if he's taken outside that top 25. You can try twist things any which way you like, but that's the reality.

Naish is a top 30 talent in this draft.

But we cannot make a call on whether he's a top 25 pick until after the draft has taken place.

Doing so beforehand is just absurd.

 

[Kangas_11]

Looks like your new

Been around long enough to know you have no idea what you're talking about.

If Naish isn't bid on in the top 25, he's not a top 25 talent. Doesn't get much simpler than that.

 

[Groin guru]

The West Coast Board is primed for an apocalyptic meltdown of epic proportions. Coles are having a sale on triple-buttered popcorn, get in quick for Friday night.

Thank you for this information.

Naish is a top 30 talent in this draft.

I've spoken to a few recruiters and they said they wouldn't pick Naish in the top 60. Massive reach for Richmond. Don't shoot the messenger.

 

[Mofra]

Naish is rated higher but estimated to be bid on later due to Father sons having a later pick due to teams looking after each other with these selections

sosos was expected to be a 35-45 selection and went much later as do most FS kids

Bulldogs rate him highly - around our second pick.
99% chance we don't bid as we have FS picks in the next few drafts.

 

[maddog37]

Errr

I thought that stat was only relevant if their junior numbers were poor. Or are those the junior numbers you have posted???

 

[Taylor]

Has everyone forgot when Richmond stuck it to GWS and Brisbane in 2015 with their academy players?

They bid on Kennedy and Hipwood in a row before taking Rioli.

 

[Caj]

Naish is rated higher but estimated to be bid on later due to Father sons having a later pick due to teams looking after each other with these selections

sosos was expected to be a 35-45 selection and went much later as do most FS kids

Jack Silvagni was pick 53, hardly a huge discount

There's plenty of examples of F/S and Academy kids being bid on early, in fact there's an article today suggesting that Port Adelaide will draft Jackson Edwards as Adelaide have chose to leave him until the rookie draft

 

[Caj]

Errr

He's not talking about AFL level, he means CP% stats at junior level.

And only 2 of those are under 30% anyway

 

[Pykie]

Good to see you have listened to the Champion Data guys as well

Dude seriously 80% of the people who watch juniors rate this kid top 25-30
Bukkennara rated him #7-10
Twomey been saying top 15 all year
Shifter Sheehan saying mid 1st round
Wallace saying around pick 15


Go argue with these guys who know nothing about football compared to you and your 2 minute listening to SEN

Literally all those blokes don't work as recruiters.

Buckenara sprouts senile shit 99% of the time.


The only recruiters that matter are the 18 in that room tomorrow night.

If none of them bid on him in the top 25, he's not a top 25 pick. Simple.

 

[HumanMeatball]

Thank you for this information.


I've spoken to a few recruiters and they said they wouldn't pick Naish in the top 60. Massive reach for Richmond. Don't shoot the messenger.

Are these the same recruiters who told you Martin was coming to north?