Rate the brownlow medallists

Jun 30, 2009
30,328
41,691
Deroesfromgero
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
east perth
Last edited:

Pali23

All Australian
Nov 6, 2017
732
615
AFL Club
St Kilda
Off the top of my head

1. Ablett Jnr
2. Chris Judd
3. Adam Goodes
4. Nathan Buckley
5. Ben Cousins
6. Simon Black
7. Dustin Martin
8. Jason Akermanis
9. Patrick Dangerfield
10. Mark Riccuito
11. Nate Fyfe
12. Sam Mitchell
13. Jimmy Bartel
14. Dane Swan
15. Matt Priddis
16. Adam Cooney
17. Trent Cotchin


Adam Goodes is below more than two those blokes at least.
 
Jun 30, 2009
30,328
41,691
Deroesfromgero
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
east perth
Last edited:
Jun 30, 2009
30,328
41,691
Deroesfromgero
AFL Club
West Coast
Other Teams
east perth
Off the top of my head

1. Ablett Jnr
2. Chris Judd
3. Adam Goodes
4. Nathan Buckley
5. Ben Cousins
6. Simon Black
7. Dustin Martin
8. Jason Akermanis
9. Patrick Dangerfield
10. Mark Riccuito
11. Nate Fyfe
12. Sam Mitchell
13. Jimmy Bartel
14. Dane Swan
15. Matt Priddis
16. Adam Cooney
17. Trent Cotchin
No woe woe what is he good for woewoedin?
 
Feb 28, 2007
51,375
66,869
Sydney
AFL Club
Sydney
Adam Goodes is below more than two those blokes at least.

Disagree as he had 2 Brownlows and was the only player on that list who was capable of being an All Australian in multiple different positons on the ground. In fact on that list he was the only one that won a Brownlow in a position other than midfield (with perhaps the sort of exception of Aker who was also a forward).
 
1. Ablett Jnr
2. Chris Judd
3. Adam Goodes
4. Simon Black
5. Nathan Buckley
6. Ben Cousins
7. Mark Riccuito
8. Jason Akermanis
9. Patrick Dangerfield
10. Nat Fyfe
11. Dustin Martin
12. Sam Mitchell
13. Jimmy Bartel
14. Dane Swan
15. Trent Cotchin
16. Adam Cooney
17. Matt Priddis
18. Shane Woewodin
 

JCHolmes

Team Captain
Nov 30, 2013
565
885
AFL Club
West Coast
Tier 1: Ablett Jr & Judd (Ablett Jr over Judd though, just) GOAT Tier

Tier 1.0: Akermanis, Black, Ricciuto, Buckley, Goodes, Cousins, Swan, Mitchell, Fyfe, Dangerfield and Martin. These guys are the great generational players that come about every 20 odd years for your club.

Tier 1.0.0 or something: Bartel & Cotchin. Awesome players just a tad off the above tier.

Tier 2: Priddis, Woewodin and Cooney. Also great players just lacked the hurt factor and/or didn't sustain it for long enough.

Bolded
could well go (well I predict they will) next level by the end of their careers.
 

kangaspurs

Cancelled
Jul 14, 2014
9,722
18,848
AFL Club
North Melbourne
Other Teams
Tottenham, Melbourne City FC
1. Judd
2. Buckley
3. Goodes
4. Mitchell
5. Ablett Jr
6. Ricciuto
7. Fyfe
8. Dangerfield
9. Cousins
10. Akermanis
11. Martin
12. Black
13. Bartel
14. Swan
15. Cotchin
16. Priddis
17. Cooney
18. Woewodin
 
Apr 18, 2005
30,892
26,644
AFL Club
Melbourne
Where do you rate each brownlow medallist from 2000 on as a player - from best to worst?

Been a plethora of threads rating individuals - where do you see them fit amogst their peers?

Shane Woewodin
Jason Akermanis
Simon Black
Mark Ricciuto
Nathan Buckley
Adam Goodes
Chris Judd
Ben Cousins
Adam Goodes
Jimmy Bartel
Adam Cooney
Gary Ablett Jr.
Chris Judd
Dane Swan
Trent Cotchin
Sam Mitchell
Gary Ablett Jr.
Matt Priddis
Nathan Fyfe
Patrick Dangerfield
Dustin Martin
Ablett
Goodes
Akermanis
Ricciutto
Buckley
Mitchell
Judd
Black
Bartel
Cousins
Swan
Dangerfield
Cotchin
Fyfe
Martin
Priddis
Woewodin
Cooney
 

st_trav_ofWA

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 17, 2015
5,810
15,541
AFL Club
St Kilda
1. Ablett Jr - Two Brownlows one in a grand final winning team surrounded by stars and one in a spoon team without a stars.

2. Judd - Two Brownlows one in a team surrounded by stars the other in a team without stars - but didnt do the brownlow flag double

3. Goodes - two Brownlows but had to share one with two other blokes also couldnt do the Brownlow flag double

4. Black - Flag Brownlow double won vote in a team surrounded by stars

5. Bartel - Flag Brownlow double won vote in a team surrounded by stars

6. Akermanis - Flag Brownlow double won vote in a team surrounded by stars

7. Martin - Flag Brownlow double won vote in a team surrounded good but not great players

8. Cousins - Brownlow in a star studded side that lost the G/F

9. Swan - Brownlow in a side that lost the G/F
10. Buckley - Brownlow in a side that lost the G/F but shared it with two other guys
11. Dangerfield - Brownlow in a first year at new club
12. Fyfe - Brownlow playing under the dour coaching of Ross Lyon
13. Priddis - Brownlow off the rookie list
14. Cooney - sentimental favorite who stopped GAbblet from having back to back
15. Ricciuto - shared his brownlow with two other guys
16. Woewodin - from nowhere brownlow medal win (one season wonder)
17. Mitchell - Paper brownlow .. won it on paper only and had to share it - played in a losing g/f
18. Cotchin - Paper brownlow .. won it on paper only and had to share it
 

FisherHawk

Club Legend
Jul 19, 2007
2,059
655
Snooza
AFL Club
Hawthorn
Feb 23, 2009
32,139
45,738
Melbourne
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
New York Jets
Rating their careers as a whole, the guys still playing like Danger, Martin and Fyfe could definitely climb a tier, but you would have them below a number of guys who's careers have finished at this point in time.

Judd, Buckley, Goodes, Ablett, Cousins level. That's probably the top tier for me.
The current trio could maybe get there by career end.
 

CotchNCo

Club Legend
Mar 29, 2012
2,874
4,862
Boston, USA
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Melbourne Victory, Arsenal
Tier 1: Ablett Jr & Judd (Ablett Jr over Judd though, just) GOAT Tier

Tier 1.0: Akermanis, Black, Ricciuto, Buckley, Goodes, Cousins, Swan, Mitchell, Fyfe, Dangerfield and Martin. These guys are the great generational players that come about every 20 odd years for your club.

Tier 1.0.0 or something: Bartel & Cotchin. Awesome players just a tad off the above tier.

Tier 2: Priddis, Woewodin and Cooney. Also great players just lacked the hurt factor and/or didn't sustain it for long enough.

Bolded
could well go (well I predict they will) next level by the end of their careers.


The best thing about your post are the tiers.

You had 1-2-3 on offer but nah i'm going multi-levels.

Good list though.
 
C

Cousins last? Short memories.

I'd certainly have him ahead of Cooney, Woewodin, Bartel and Priddis.

you have always to put drug cheats at the bottom. if not for that, probably in the top 5 somewhere.
 
Back