Best 22 without trades?

[RUNVS]

Not an easy thing to do based on the fact that trades mean more drat picks but ignoring that bit for a moment, in this, ultimate definition of an off season thread, what would your best 22 look like right now if you only included players that your team personally drafted (so no trades).

For the Swans

B: Nick Smith, Heath Grundy, Lewis Melican
HB: Jarrad McVeigh, Dane Rampe, Jake Lloyd
C: Dan Hannebery, Tom Mitchell, Zak Jones
HF: Kieren Jack, Sam Reid, George Hewett
F: Gary Rohan, Tim Membrey, Tom Papley
R: Sam Naismith, Luke Parker, Isaac Heeney
INT: Shane Biggs, Nic Newman, Callum Mills, Will Hayward

So basically

Out
Kennedy
Franklin
Tippett

In
Membrey
Biggs
Mitchell

Obviously not as good a team without Buddy in it, but it would still be a team challenging for the top 4 I think.

What about your team?

 

[Forward Press]

B: Sheppard Mackenzie Nelson
HB: Hurn Barrass Schofield
C: Gaff Sheed Duggan
HF: Partington McGovern Ryan
F: Rioli Darling LeCras
R: Naitanui Shuey Ebert
INT: Masten Lycett Hutchings Cole

Hard to do considering there is no Kennedy, Yeo, Redden, Cripps or Jetta, all first 18 players this season. Had to include a player that hasn't even debuted yet and one clearly on the way out (LeCras). I probably missed out a couple or so but meh, if we fielded this line-up this year we would struggle to not finish bottom 4.

Edit - I like Lycett and Hutchings but that interchange makes me spew. Our list profile has changed significantly since last year, was considering chucking in untried players (so far) like Venables and Ryan.

 

[half_back_flank]

We take out Dunn, Howe, Treloar, Adams, Wells, Crisp and WHE from our best 22. Varcoe, Greenwood, Aish and Murray on the cusp.

Safe to say, pretty shithouse side without them.

Edit: Didn't realise you could add in players you'd drafted out. Beams, Shaw and Williams would be handy but don't really make up for what we've drafted in.

 

[The Joker]

StKilda wouldn't be able to field a team, well a competitive one anyway!


Freo would lose Bennell, BHill, Hamling, Wilson Kersten, Matera and McCarthy from the squad, five possibly six starting 22!


Hayden Ballantyne ~ Michael Apeness ~ Sean Darcy

Michael Walters ~ Matt Taberner ~ Darcy Tucker

Adam Cerra ~ Lachie Neale ~ Stephen Hill

Lachie Weller ~ Michael Johnson ~ Connor Blakely

Luke Ryan ~ Alex Pearce ~ Griffin Logue

Aaron Sandilands ~ Nat Fyfe ~ David Mundy

Brennan Cox ~ Brady Grey ~ Ed Langdon ~ Ethan Hughes

So in effect, probably 2 years behind where they currently are if you don't factor in that they were all traded for picks that would have been used. I also took back the Weller for pick 2 trade, even though technically Freo did draft Brayshaw!

 

[gangsta deluxe]

We are excellent with this, with perhaps a fwdline kp issue. Don't have time for the full write up but...

Add Ward, Griffen, Jones, Stringer, Higgins, Harbrow...

Lose Trengove, Suckling, Biggs, Boyd.. not sure if Schache could reliably be called best 22.

Probably forgetting a few

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Well the hawks wouldn’t have a midfield, with Mitchell, omeara, Burgoyne not around.

The threepeat would have been hard as well without Gunston, Gibbo, lake, mcevoy, Hale, Guerra. But we may have kept Kennedy and franklin in this bizarro world.

 

[demondavey]

Out: Hibberd, Melksham, Garlett, Lever, Lewis, Frost, Bugg.

 

[Leather Poisoning]

Out: Hibberd, Melksham, Garlett, Lever, Lewis, Frost, Bugg.

Lewis wasn’t a trade, it was theft.

 

[Proper Gander]

Out: Hibberd, Melksham, Garlett, Lever, Lewis, Frost, Bugg.

In Frawley, Watts, Howe, Dunn, um ... Martin ... Toump ... um ... Sylvia? Holy s**t

 

[demondavey]

Lewis wasn’t a trade, it was theft.

We seem to be paying a lot for something we stole!

 

[Power Raid]

DBJ Clurey Liernart
bonner Jonas Houston
Westhoff Wines Pittard
Hartlett Marshall Broadbent
Johnson Howard Gray

Ladhams Wingard SPP

boak Amon SGray Atley

 

[gandaal]

I'm not sure we could field a team

 

[gandaal]

FB: Ciaran Byrne, Sam Rowe, Harrison McCreadie
HB: Tom Williamson, Jacob Weitering, Kade Simpson
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton, Ed Curnow, Marc Murphy
HF: Charlie Curnow, Levi Casboult, Jarrod Garlett
FF: Harry McKay, Jack Silvagni, Zac Fisher
R: Matthew Kreuzer, Patrick Cripps, Paddy Dow
I: David Cuningham, Lochie O'Brien, Nick Graham, Cam O'Shea

Sam Rowe, Ed Curnow, Jarrod Garlett and Cam O'Shea all were drafted by other clubs before Carlton got them but they were all drafted by Carlton in the National, preseason or Rookie drafts so they should all count.

 

[telsor]

From the Premiership team (not best 22, but anyway...)

Out: Houli, Townsend, Caddy, Nankervis, Prestia, Grigg

In from trades: Deledio
In from depth: Conca, Griffiths, Soldo, Miles, Lloyd

 

[Beer n Skittles]

FB: Ciaran Byrne, Sam Rowe, Harrison McCreadie
HB: Tom Williamson, Jacob Weitering, Kade Simpson
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton, Ed Curnow, Marc Murphy
HF: Charlie Curnow, Levi Casboult, Jarrod Garlett
FF: Harry McKay, Jack Silvagni, Zac Fisher
R: Matthew Kreuzer, Patrick Cripps, Paddy Dow
I: David Cuningham, Lochie O'Brien, Nick Graham, Cam O'Shea

Sam Rowe, Ed Curnow, Jarrod Garlett and Cam O'Shea all were drafted by other clubs before Carlton got them but they were all drafted by Carlton in the National, preseason or Rookie drafts so they should all count.

Add in Tuohy, Kennedy, Betts.

 

[TallyHawk]

B: Hardwick Brand Stratton
HB: Birchall O'Brien Sicily
C: Smith Kennedy Hill
HF: Bruest Franklin Puopolo
F: Rioli Roughead Shoenmakers
R: Pittonet Shiels Lewis
Interchange: Suckling Lovell Howe Glass

Leaving out Hodge, and Burton as they were drafted with picks traded in.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

B: Brown, Talia, Lever
HB: Smith, Davis, Laird
C: Sloane, Mrouch, Douglas
HF: Knight, Walker, Vince
F: Cameron, McGovern, Gunston
R: Tippett, Dangerfield, Brouch
I: Kelly, Greenwood, Milera, Gallucci
E: Hartigan, Lyons, Atkins

Davis > Hartigan
Lever > Doedee
Tippett < Jacobs
Dangerfield > Gibbs
Gunston = Jenkins
Vince > Hampton
Cameron < Betts

Into squad:
Tippett
Dangerfield
Davis
Lever
Gunston
Vince
Cameron
Lyons
Wigg
Kerridge


Out of squad:
Jenkins
Lynch
Jacobs
Betts (assume FA is trade)
Gibbs
Hampton
Seedsman
Gibson
Cheney

 

[Pali23]

Geary Gilbert Rice

White Goddard Webster

Newnes Ross Acres

Billings McCartin Gresham

Lonie. Battle. Cripps

McEvoy Steven Dunstan

Armitage McKenzie Clark Coffield

 

[NetworkNerd]

B: Hardwick Brand Duryea
HB: Birchall O'Brien Glass
C: Smith Kennedy Hill
HF: Bruest Franklin Puopolo
F: Rioli Roughead Shoenmakers
R: Pittonet Shiels Lewis
Interchange: Suckling Lovell Howe Nash

Leaving out Hodge, and Burton as they were drafted with picks traded in.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

No room for Sicily or Stratton?

 

[half_back_flank]

Add in Tuohy, Kennedy, Betts.

Gibbs, Garlett, Jacobs.

 

[TallyHawk]

No room for Sicily or Stratton?

Fair call, fixed it.


On iPad using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

DBJ Clurey Liernart
bonner Jonas Houston
Westhoff Wines Pittard
Hartlett Marshall Broadbent
Johnson Howard Gray

Ladhams Wingard SPP

boak Amon SGray Atley

Trengove would be in the team, probably as ruckman?

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Add in Tuohy, Kennedy, Betts.

+ Jacobs & Gibbs.

Henderson too.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

FB: Ciaran Byrne, Sam Rowe, Harrison McCreadie
HB: Tom Williamson, Jacob Weitering, Kade Simpson
C: Sam Petrevski-Seton, Ed Curnow, Marc Murphy
HF: Charlie Curnow, Levi Casboult, Jarrod Garlett
FF: Harry McKay, Jack Silvagni, Zac Fisher
R: Matthew Kreuzer, Patrick Cripps, Paddy Dow
I: David Cuningham, Lochie O'Brien, Nick Graham, Cam O'Shea

Sam Rowe, Ed Curnow, Jarrod Garlett and Cam O'Shea all were drafted by other clubs before Carlton got them but they were all drafted by Carlton in the National, preseason or Rookie drafts so they should all count.

Side has much more forward power...

B: Weitering, Rowe, Byrne
HB: Tuohy, Henderson, Simpson
C: SPS, Cripps, E Curnow
HF: C Curnow, Casboult, Garlett
F: Betts, Kennedy, Kreuzer
R: Jacobs, Gibbs, Murphy
I: McKay, Silvagni, Wiliamson, Dow

 

[Carbine Chaos]

B: Sheppard Mackenzie Nelson
HB: Hurn Barrass Schofield
C: Gaff Sheed Duggan
HF: Partington McGovern Ah Chee
F: Rioli Darling LeCras
R: Naitanui Shuey Ebert
INT: Masten Lycett Hutchings Cole

Hard to do considering there is no Kennedy, Yeo, Redden, Cripps or Jetta, all first 18 players this season. Had to include a player that hasn't even debuted yet and one clearly on the way out (LeCras). I probably missed out a couple or so but meh, if we fielded this line-up this year we would struggle to not finish bottom 4.

Edit - I like Lycett and Hutchings but that interchange makes me spew. Our list profile has changed significantly since last year, was considering chucking in untried players (so far) like Venables and Ryan.

What’s Ah Chee doing in there?