List Mgmt. Ranking the MFC list

Remove this Banner Ad

deeco

Norm Smith Medallist
Jun 3, 2012
5,948
7,305
AFL Club
Melbourne
Don't really have anyone worth ranking, when the boys work as a team we're good, when they s**t the bed it's because they run around like headless chooks. Don't currently have anyone truly damaging enough that if we lose them we're more ****ed than we would be without. Maybe Gawn? Until that changes we won't really be making big leaps up the ladder. Signs for the future are looking up if some of these younger players develop real gooderer
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Timmydaswan

Rookie
Aug 20, 2015
30
6
AFL Club
Melbourne
1. Viney
2. Jones
3. Vince
4. Gawn
5. Hogan
6. MacDonald
7. Tyson
8. Watts
9. Garlett
10. Trengrove (soon)
 

Timmydaswan

Rookie
Aug 20, 2015
30
6
AFL Club
Melbourne
Since debut (Round 17, 2006):

2006: 8 games [8 possible]
2007: 21 [22]
2008: 21 [22]
2009: 20 [22]
2010: 22 [22]
2011: 22 [22]
2012: 21 [22]
2013: 22 [22]
2014: 22 [22]
2015: 22 [22]

I make that 201 out of the last 206 games.

EDIT: Those five games netted five losses. Am I making this up, or have we not won a game without Nathan Jones since 2006?
Havn't won without him because he hasn't missed any
 
This isn't a ranking of quality, but rather order selected for mine:

  1. Gawn
  2. Viney
  3. Oliver
  4. Hogan
  5. Lever
  6. Jones
  7. Jetta
  8. Hibberd
  9. T McDonald
  10. O McDonald
  11. Petracca
  12. Tyson
  13. Garlett
  14. Hunt
  15. ANB
  16. Harmes
  17. Lewis
  18. Melksham
  19. Stretch
  20. Salem
  21. Brayshaw
  22. Bugg
  23. Vince
  24. Hannan
  25. Pedersen
  26. Frost
  27. Fritsch
  28. J Smith
  29. Wagner
  30. Weideman
 
1. Max Gawn
2. Jack Viney
3. Clayton Oliver
4. Christian Petracca
5. Jesse Hogan
6. Michael Hibberd
7. Jake Lever
8. Nathan Jones
9. Neville Jetta
10. Jeff Gartlett
11. Jayden Hunt
12. Tom McDonald
13. Dom Tyson
14. Alex Neal-Bullen
15. Jake Melksham
16. Christian Salem
17. Jordan Lewis
18. Bernie Vince
19. Mitch Hannan
20. Angus Brayshaw
21. James Harmes
22. Oscar McDonald
23. Billy Stretch
24. Sam Weideman
25. Cam Pederson
26. Tomas Bugg
27. Sam Frost
28. Bailey Fritsch
29. Harley Balic
30. Aaron Vandenberg
31. Dean Kent
32. Joel Smith
33. Jay Kennedy-Harris
34. Dion Johnston
35. Mutch King
36. Patrick McKenna
37. Charlie Spargo
38. Harrison Petty
39. Declan Keilty
40. Josh Wagner
41. Oskar Baker
42. Tim Smith
43. Corey Maynard
44. Lachlan Filipovic
 

pjfairbairn

AFL Premiership Supporter, 2021
Feb 21, 2011
3,446
4,735
Brisbane
AFL Club
Melbourne
Most important to least important, in 2018:

1. Max Gawn
2. Jack Viney
3. Clayton Oliver
4. Nathan Jones
5. Jesse Hogan
6. Jake Lever
7. Christian Petracca
8. Michael Hibberd
9. Tom McDonald
10. Neville Jetta
11. Jordan Lewis
12. Alex Neal-Bullen
13. Dom Tyson
14. Jeff Garlett
15. Oscar McDonald
16. Jake Melksham
17. Christian Salem
18. Jayden Hunt
19. Bernard Vince
20. James Harmes
21. Sam Frost
22. Angus Brayshaw
23. Mitch Hannan
24. Bailey Fritsch
25. Bill Stretch
26. Tommy Bugg
27. Cam Pederson
28. Corey Maynard
29. Harley Balic
30. Joel Smith
31. Tim Smith
32. Sam Weidemann
33. Oskar Baker
34. Aaron Vandenberg
35. Jay Kenned-Harris
36. Josh Wagner
37. Dean Kent
38. Declan Keilty
39. Charlie Spargo
40. Dion Johnstone
41. Mitch King
42. Harrison Petty
43. Pat McKenna
44. Lachlan Filipovic
 
May 27, 2006
40,580
78,472
This is the location section. 🤗
AFL Club
Melbourne
Pretty difficult exercise.

1 | Max Gawn
2 | Bernie Vince
3 | Jack Viney
4 | Nathan Jones
5 | Jesse Hogan

6 | Jeff Garlett
7 | Jack Watts
8 | Tom McDonald
9 | Neville Jetta
10 | Jack Trengove

11 | Dom Tyson
12 | Angus Brayshaw
13 | Christian Salem
14 | Aaron vandenBerg
15 | Clayton Oliver

16 | Lynden Dunn
17 | Christian Petracca
18 | Ben Kennedy
19 | Dean Kent
20 | Jake Melksham

21 | Cam Pedersen
22 | Colin Garland
23 | Heritier Lumumba
24 | James Harmes
25 | Tomas Bugg

26 | Alex Neal-Bullen
27 | Billy Stretch
28 | Matt Jones
29 | Chris Dawes
30 | Jack Grimes

31 | Jake Spencer
32 | Sam Frost
33 | Ben Newton
34 | Jayden Hunt
35 | Mitch White

36 | Josh Wagner
37 | Viv Michie
38 | Oscar McDonald
39 | Sam Weideman
40 | Jay Kennedy-Harris

41 | Max King
42 | Dean Terlich
43 | Liam Hulett
44 | Mitch King
45 | Joel Smith

Cripes.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

  1. Oliver
  2. Gawn
  3. Viney
  4. Hogan
  5. Petracca
  6. T.McDonald
  7. Hibberd
  8. Jones
  9. Garlett
  10. Jetta
  11. Lever
  12. Hunt
  13. Tyson
  14. Lewis
  15. Neal-Bullen
  16. Melksham
  17. Salem
  18. Brayshaw
  19. Harmes
  20. O.McDonald
  21. Frost
  22. Hannan
  23. Pedersen
  24. Stretch
  25. Vince
  26. vandenBerg
  27. J.Smith
  28. Fritsch
  29. Maynard
  30. Bugg
  31. Weideman
  32. Wagner
  33. Kennedy Harris
  34. T.Smith
  35. Kent
  36. Balic
  37. King
  38. Keilty
  39. Baker
  40. Spargo
  41. Petty
  42. Johnstone
  43. McKenna
  44. Filipovic

36 to 44 was just a guessing game really.
 
Feb 15, 2015
31,575
70,864
South Yarra
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Mt Buller Demons
  1. Oliver
  2. Gawn
  3. Viney
  4. Hogan
  5. Petracca
  6. T.McDonald
  7. Hibberd
  8. Jones
  9. Garlett
  10. Jetta
  11. Lever
  12. Hunt
  13. Tyson
  14. Lewis
  15. Neal-Bullen
  16. Melksham
  17. Salem
  18. Brayshaw
  19. Harmes
  20. O.McDonald
  21. Frost
  22. Hannan
  23. Pedersen
  24. Stretch
  25. Vince
  26. vandenBerg
  27. J.Smith
  28. Fritsch
  29. Maynard
  30. Bugg
  31. Weideman
  32. Wagner
  33. Kennedy Harris
  34. T.Smith
  35. Kent
  36. Balic
  37. King
  38. Keilty
  39. Baker
  40. Spargo
  41. Petty
  42. Johnstone
  43. McKenna
  44. Filipovic
36 to 44 was just a guessing game really.
I’ve clicked like on pretty much everything here really, but I like your list for giving due importance to my man Clayton
 

Cannon82

Cancelled
10k Posts Melbourne Poster of the Year Melbourne Demons - Ben Kennedy Player Sponsor 2016 Melbourne Demons - Jeremy Howe Player Sponsor 2015 Melbourne Demons - Dom Barry Sponsor 2014 Melbourne Demons - Jeremy Howe Sponsor 2014
Oct 26, 2012
16,398
23,165
AFL Club
Melbourne
I’ve clicked like on pretty much everything here really, but I like your list for giving due importance to my man Clayton

Yiss, I also liked for the same reason.

1. Clolliver
2. C-Pet
3. and onwards - irrelevant
 
Feb 15, 2015
31,575
70,864
South Yarra
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Mt Buller Demons
Yiss, I also liked for the same reason.

1. Clolliver
2. C-Pet
3. and onwards - irrelevant
I probably should know which players fall under C-Pet but I don’t. Is that basically 1. Oliver, 2. Oliver morphed with Petracca and then whatever? If yes is has merit.
 

Cannon82

Cancelled
10k Posts Melbourne Poster of the Year Melbourne Demons - Ben Kennedy Player Sponsor 2016 Melbourne Demons - Jeremy Howe Player Sponsor 2015 Melbourne Demons - Dom Barry Sponsor 2014 Melbourne Demons - Jeremy Howe Sponsor 2014
Oct 26, 2012
16,398
23,165
AFL Club
Melbourne
I probably should know which players fall under C-Pet but I don’t. Is that basically 1. Oliver, 2. Oliver morphed with Petracca and then whatever? If yes is has merit.

Christian's first name is still Christian, is it not?
 

Cannon82

Cancelled
10k Posts Melbourne Poster of the Year Melbourne Demons - Ben Kennedy Player Sponsor 2016 Melbourne Demons - Jeremy Howe Player Sponsor 2015 Melbourne Demons - Dom Barry Sponsor 2014 Melbourne Demons - Jeremy Howe Sponsor 2014
Oct 26, 2012
16,398
23,165
AFL Club
Melbourne
Indeed. But does this mean you are rating 1 to 5 of Tulip’s list or the more austere Clayton, Christian et al set up?

Just flying the Oliver / Petracca flag. They play, we win. The other 20 blokes on the field will just be along for the ride.
 
Feb 15, 2015
31,575
70,864
South Yarra
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Mt Buller Demons
Just flying the Oliver / Petracca flag. They play, we win. The other 20 blokes on the field will just be along for the ride.
I agree totally with this. Under normal circs I might chuck a Viney in there, but on zero preseason total I think you can ask for too much. Clayton will be our best midfielder in decades. Petracca is his own thing but equally or nearly as important.

I hope Goodwin has drilled the other 38 to act basically as a worthy corps de ballet
 
Aug 29, 2010
61,083
85,023
Canada
AFL Club
Melbourne
Other Teams
Winnipeg Jets
I agree totally with this. Under normal circs I might chuck a Viney in there, but on zero preseason total I think you can ask for too much. Clayton will be our best midfielder in decades. Petracca is his own thing but equally or nearly as important.

I hope Goodwin has drilled the other 38 to act basically as a worthy corps de ballet

Thinking the others should walk the other 2 onto ground Roman Empire style
IMG_0060.JPG
 

Tempy Tiger

Premiership Player
Sep 18, 2006
4,416
3,547
AFL Club
Melbourne
Just flying the Oliver / Petracca flag. They play, we win. The other 20 blokes on the field will just be along for the ride.
I reckon Oliver has shown way more than Petracca so far. He’s won a B and F in his second year and was talked about as an outside Brownlow chance. Petracca just does freakish things but he’s not in the game anywhere near as much as Clarry.
 

Tempy Tiger

Premiership Player
Sep 18, 2006
4,416
3,547
AFL Club
Melbourne
1. Clarry
2. Gawn
3. TMAC
4. Hibberd
5. Hogan
6. Jones
7. Viney
8. Petracca
9. Nev
10. ANB
11. Lever
12. Melksham
13. Salem
14. OMAC
15. Jeffy
16. Lewis
17. Harmes
18. Hunt

We really have got some quality now in our best 18. Should be top four if we get a decent run injury wise.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back