Past Swans past player movements

[Punts]

Murry R3 rising star

 

[mtooler]

Who lost two grand finals. He's a good player but we didn't have a shortage of contested ball mids so our money is better spent on what didn't/don't have, fast outside players who can hit a target.

Mitchell always stood up when our mids were getting beaten up badly, particularly in finals.

 

[Number37]

Mitchell always stood up when our mids were getting beaten up badly, particularly in finals.

More proof that he has little impact on the result of a game.

 

[bedford]

More proof that he has little impact on the result of a game.

Exactly

 

[mtooler]

More proof that he has little impact on the result of a game.

Not really, proof he couldn't carry the entire team on his back which he did with increasing regularity while everyone melted around him.

 

[Number37]

Not really, proof he couldn't carry the entire team on his back which he did with increasing regularity while everyone melted around him.

You are confusing your JPKs with your Tom Mitchells.

 

[mtooler]

You are confusing your JPKs with your Tom Mitchells.

Nah, I thought Tom Mitchell was the one that really came on in the 2nd half v WB in the granny. Where Parker and others go entirely missing only JPK could enter the conversation as standing with Mitchell. I argued we needed Miles this year to support JPK, hes the closest cheapest copy of Tom Mitchell in the league.

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

More proof that he has little impact on the result of a game.

Geelong should of been the team to target Mitchell he would of complimented Dangerfield and Selwood perfectly, Mitchell at Hawthorn is a waste.

 

[Superstar swan]

Murry R3 rising star

Collingwood did well in identifying him

 

[bedford]

Nah, I thought Tom Mitchell was the one that really came on in the 2nd half v WB in the granny. Where Parker and others go entirely missing only JPK could enter the conversation as standing with Mitchell. I argued we needed Miles this year to support JPK, hes the closest cheapest copy of Tom Mitchell in the league.

Parker was injured

 

[Number37]

Nah, I thought Tom Mitchell was the one that really came on in the 2nd half v WB in the granny. Where Parker and others go entirely missing only JPK could enter the conversation as standing with Mitchell. I argued we needed Miles this year to support JPK, hes the closest cheapest copy of Tom Mitchell in the league.

First you place Mitchell above JPK then you equate him to a player that was delisted by Richmond 2 weeks after we smashed them by 100.
You are out of your mind.

 

[LukeParkerno1]

Collingwood did well in identifying him

Win-win trade we still get a top 30 pick for him this year. Fair trade for both clubs

 

[mtooler]

First you place Mitchell above JPK then you equate him to a player that was delisted by Richmond 2 weeks after we smashed them by 100.
You are out of your mind.

Dont think you are thinking it through, right now id have Mitchell ahead of Kennedy. Mitchell hit the scoreboard in big games more than kennedy and gut run was always getting into spots to recieve the second kick from a kick in. Kennedy while good isnt in the form that Mitchell is in. Miles is what we need a tackling extractor at clearances, he can replicate that aspect of Mitchells game not so much the rest, no one can.

 

[bedford]

Dont think you are thinking it through, right now id have Mitchell ahead of Kennedy. Mitchell hit the scoreboard in big games more than kennedy and gut run was always getting into spots to recieve the second kick from a kick in. Kennedy while good isnt in the form that Mitchell is in. Miles is what we need a tackling extractor at clearances, he can replicate that aspect of Mitchells game not so much the rest, no one can.

Turn it up

 

[Mick Oxlong]

Dont think you are thinking it through, right now id have Mitchell ahead of Kennedy. Mitchell hit the scoreboard in big games more than kennedy and gut run was always getting into spots to recieve the second kick from a kick in. Kennedy while good isnt in the form that Mitchell is in. Miles is what we need a tackling extractor at clearances, he can replicate that aspect of Mitchells game not so much the rest, no one can.

Yes, ‘cos Miles is really tearing it up in the AFL at the moment!

 

[BloodySwan]

The clubs biggest criticism is we're too Buddy centric, not that we don't have anyone in the midfield. What would Titchell add to our current setup which we don't already have? Anyone who watches our games would see getting the ball we're fine. Delivery into our forwards is where we lack - something Mitchell is still not very good at doing

 

[Jewelsbon]

The clubs biggest criticism is we're too Buddy centric, not that we don't have anyone in the midfield. What would Titchell add to our current setup which we don't already have? Anyone who watches our games would see getting the ball we're fine. Delivery into our forwards is where we lack - something Mitchell is still not very good at doing

Now now now you're using that odd phenomenon called logic again and I thought we all knew now that when it comes to Mitchell there is no such thing as logic, just twisted revisionist history.

 

[grimlock]

I see 2005 premiership photo participant Tyler Roos is now playing for Southport in the NEAFL.

 

[brad cooper]

Mitchell always stood up when our mids were getting beaten up badly, particularly in finals.

Which finals are you talking about? 2016 gf would be the only example of this occuring.

 

[mtooler]

Yes, ‘cos Miles is really tearing it up in the AFL at the moment!

As a lot of our recruits were prior to joining the Swans. JPK. Short memory, might want to get that looked into.

 

[mtooler]

The clubs biggest criticism is we're too Buddy centric, not that we don't have anyone in the midfield. What would Titchell add to our current setup which we don't already have? Anyone who watches our games would see getting the ball we're fine. Delivery into our forwards is where we lack - something Mitchell is still not very good at doing

Mitchell would help win clearances and contested possessions, other players can do it in our side, they just aren't anywhere near as good as Mitchell at doing it.

 

[mtooler]

Which finals are you talking about? 2016 gf would be the only example of this occuring.

Mitchell standing up, or our mids consistently melting under pressure which is why we needed to retain Mitchell.

 

[brad cooper]

Mitchell standing up, or our mids consistently melting under pressure which is why we needed to retain Mitchell.

Mitchell standing up in finals when our other mids went missing. Okay the 2016 gf is one but jpk and heeney were certainly not awol. Parker played injured and hanners was quiet before injury. You insinuated that mitchell did this in other finals when we were getting beaten up, im just curious as to which finals your referring to?

 

[BloodySwan]

Mitchell would help win clearances and contested possessions, other players can do it in our side, they just aren't anywhere near as good as Mitchell at doing it.

And winning more clearances would create more forwards for us how?

 

[mtooler]

And winning more clearances would create more forwards for us how?

Would create more forward entries.