List Mgmt. Ranking the MFC list

[Fork n Hell]

I reckon Oliver has shown way more than Petracca so far. He’s won a B and F in his second year and was talked about as an outside Brownlow chance. Petracca just does freakish things but he’s not in the game anywhere near as much as Clarry.

Dont forget Clarry came in and hit the ground running but Petracca had his knee then his toe injuries in his first 2 years so had a couple of setbacks to his fitness base early on. I expect with another preseason under his belt this year he will stay involved in the midfield for longer periods then go forward for a rest and kick a few lazy goals at full forward every game.

 

[Tulip]

Worth another go at the halfway mark of the year. Suspect it'll look different again at the end of the season.

1. Oliver
2. Hogan
3. Gawn
4. T.McDonald
5. Viney
6. Jetta
7. Hibberd
8. Jones
9. Brayshaw
10. O.McDonald
11. Lever
12. Petracca
13. Melksham
14. Lewis
15. Salem
16. Neal-Bullen
17. Fritsch
18. Garlett
19. Tyson
20. Vince
21. Hunt
22. Harmes
23. Hannan
24. Pedersen
25. Spargo
26. Frost
27. Weideman
28. Kent
29. Bugg
30. Stretch
31. J.Smith
32. Wagner
33. T.Smith
34. vandenBerg

I'm not giving up on the guys out the picture yet, on talent they're up there, but they've fallen far.

Anyone's guess from there.

 

[schmuttt]

Hogan has been our best player this year imo, but can understand arguments for Gawn/Oliver.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Hogan easily number one at this stage. Ridiculous having Trac outside the top 5

 

[Fork n Hell]

Worth another go at the halfway mark of the year. Suspect it'll look different again at the end of the season.

1. Oliver
2. Hogan
3. Gawn
4. T.McDonald
5. Viney
6. Jetta
7. Hibberd
8. Jones
9. Brayshaw
10. O.McDonald
11. Lever
12. Petracca
13. Melksham
14. Lewis
15. Salem
16. Neal-Bullen
17. Fritsch
18. Garlett
19. Tyson
20. Vince
21. Hunt
22. Harmes
23. Hannan
24. Pedersen
25. Spargo
26. Frost
27. Weideman
28. Kent
29. Bugg
30. Stretch
31. J.Smith
32. Wagner
33. T.Smith
34. vandenBerg

I'm not giving up on the guys out the picture yet, on talent they're up there, but they've fallen far.

Anyone's guess from there.

.
i would also have Hogan on top but there's not much wrong there imo. I could swap a few around a bit but that would just be nit picking.

 

[Dancing Potato]

Hogan has probably been our best so far but if using the OP's criteria of 'most important for the season ahead' Gawn is number one for me.

The drop in quality between Gawn and whoever his replacement would be is just so damn severe. Like...off a cliff levels of severe.

 

[pjfairbairn]

Hogan easily number one at this stage. Ridiculous having Trac outside the top 5

For current impact, Trac isn't in the top 10...

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

For current impact, Trac isn't in the top 10...

I thought the premise of the thread was importance, not current impact.

 

[Daemon]

Worth another go at the halfway mark of the year. Suspect it'll look different again at the end of the season.

1. Oliver
2. Hogan
3. Gawn
4. T.McDonald
5. Viney
6. Jetta
7. Hibberd
8. Jones
9. Brayshaw
10. O.McDonald
11. Lever
12. Petracca
13. Melksham
14. Lewis
15. Salem
16. Neal-Bullen
17. Fritsch
18. Garlett
19. Tyson
20. Vince
21. Hunt
22. Harmes
23. Hannan
24. Pedersen
25. Spargo
26. Frost
27. Weideman
28. Kent
29. Bugg
30. Stretch
31. J.Smith
32. Wagner
33. T.Smith
34. vandenBerg

I'm not giving up on the guys out the picture yet, on talent they're up there, but they've fallen far.

Anyone's guess from there.

No arguments from me. I agree with your top 10, probably just shifting furniture with a couple e.g. Gawn and Oliver swap, swap Viney with OMac (the rock). Such a solid team at the moment. Oh I'd also switch around Melksham with Lever, he's been immense and deserves some recognition.

 

[Dancing Potato]

I thought the premise of the thread was importance, not current impact.

I think it was for the season, not further ahead than that?

Trac isn't tracking (yeah I went there) in the top 5 this year for importance to our end of season result.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

I think it was for the season, not further ahead than that?

Trac isn't tracking (yeah I went there) in the top 5 this year for importance to our end of season result.

Fair enough, then. Wouldn’t have him too far out though, and if the AFL came to Goodwin at the end of the year and said they’re dissolving our list and we can only keep 5 players you can bet Trac would be one of them

 

[Tulip]

Fair enough, then. Wouldn’t have him too far out though, and if the AFL came to Goodwin at the end of the year and said they’re dissolving our list and we can only keep 5 players you can bet Trac would be one of them

Definitely, but if I had to choose one of or Jones to play on Monday for a guaranteed good game I would choose Jones.

 

[Gysberts2Bate]

Definitely, but if I had to choose one him and or Jones to play on Monday for a guaranteed good game I would choose Jones.

Yeah I misunderstood. I probably agree, but I’d also be nervous that if I don’t pick Trac I’d be missing out on him pulling out a game like QB last year

 

[stretcharmstrong]

Gawn
...
TMac
Viney
Claz
Hogan
Jones
...
Hubbard
Jetta
Omac
Brayshaw
Melksham
Protractor
...
Throw a blanket over 10
...
Throw a blanket over the rest

 

[Simon_Says]

Does form carry in into this?
Or Rep?
Looking at it unbiasedly my analysis would go as follows


Hogan
Gawn
TMac
Clarry
Jones
Jetta
Omac
Angus Brayshaw
Pig Hibbo

Viney
NIB
Salem
*Lever (If Lever was still on the park, without a doubt he belongs in the top of this ranking with the above guys)
Bern
Melksham

Spargo
Hannan (Its hard to seperate the middle section especially these guys)
Harmes
Fritta
Lewis
Track


Joel Smith
Dom Tyson
Tim Smith
Frost
Hunt
Stretch
Choofta
Pedo
Wagner
Jeffy
Bugg
AVB

The above mention guys in the bottom QRT of the list, its obviously going to be harder to rank them when they haven't had the time in the game.

 

[Tempy Tiger]

Hogan easily number one at this stage. Ridiculous having Trac outside the top 5

Why? He just flashes in and out of the play. I like Tulips list and he isn’t even in the top 10!
His ceiling is very high but he isn’t dominating matches right now, he’s showing glimpses.