No it’s the current list.Is that the same list Hawthorn have destroyed for so long now it's actually boring?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
No it’s the current list.Is that the same list Hawthorn have destroyed for so long now it's actually boring?
Played 3 less games than Cox, has kicked 4 more goals, and has been playing with a PCL injury and in a bottom 4 sideOkay -he just kicked 5 goals against a side in the top 4 in front of 84,000 people. How's Lynch going this year?
You don't get it - at all!They have the better midfield, what other part of their list is better?
Jeez, if Collingwood gets to give up s**t players and keep their R1 pick, we should offer Miles plus Eliis (pick either) and Lloyd.Just a few ideas
Collingwood trades with the Suns
Deal 1: Suns pick 40 and 42 for J Smith, Mayne, J Thomas and pick 66
Deal 2: Suns lose Lynch for comp 1
Richmond
Deal 1: Sun pick 40 and 42 for Tigers pick 17 and Miles
Deal 2: Suns lose Lynch for comp 1
Hawthorn
Deal 1: Suns pick 18 and 42 for Hawks pick 9 and W Langford and Whitecross
Deal 2: Suns lose for comp 1
No Mayne , Langford or J Smith please .Just a few ideas
Collingwood trades with the Suns
Deal 1: Suns pick 40 and 42 for J Smith, Mayne, J Thomas and pick 66
Deal 2: Suns lose Lynch for comp 1
Richmond
Deal 1: Sun pick 40 and 42 for Tigers pick 17 and Miles
Deal 2: Suns lose Lynch for comp 1
Hawthorn
Deal 1: Suns pick 18 and 42 for Hawks pick 9 and W Langford and Whitecross
Deal 2: Suns lose for comp 1
Damn. We'll just have to keep him then :/Not even in the VFL.
LOL did you seriously think about this trade before posting it ?Just a few ideas
Collingwood trades with the Suns
Deal 1: Suns pick 40 and 42 for J Smith, Mayne, J Thomas and pick 66
Deal 2: Suns lose Lynch for comp 1
Richmond
Deal 1: Sun pick 40 and 42 for Tigers pick 17 and Miles
Deal 2: Suns lose Lynch for comp 1
Hawthorn
Deal 1: Suns pick 18 and 42 for Hawks pick 9 and W Langford and Whitecross
Deal 2: Suns lose for comp 1
Lynchy has also been playing footy 20 years longer than Cox.Played 3 less games than Cox, has kicked 4 more goals, and has been playing with a PCL injury and in a bottom 4 side
LOL did you seriously think about this trade before posting it ?
Collingwood Keep their 1st round pick
Get to off load Mayne which they dont want who is on $500k as well as off load 2 fringe players like Thomas & Smith for decent picks in a great draft
The equivalent for Richmond would be to Give up Miles ,Lloyd,Conca for #40 + #42 and Gold
Thomas is kicking close to 2 goals a game this year, he’s hardly a fringe player. The rest I agree with though.LOL did you seriously think about this trade before posting it ?
Collingwood Keep their 1st round pick
Get to off load Mayne which they dont want who is on $500k as well as off load 2 fringe players like Thomas & Smith for decent picks in a great draft
The equivalent for Richmond would be to Give up Miles ,Lloyd,Conca for #40 + #42 and Gold
In all honest i dont look at his statts , Watched him in 2 games live and probably 2 on television and he wasnt much chop , But ill take your word for it but will be 28 in january only has 53 games and 45 goals doesnt reallly scream out AFL player - Reece Conca has better credentials atmThomas is kicking close to 2 goals a game this year, he’s hardly a fringe player. The rest I agree with though.
Heavily injury (and drug) interrupted career unfortunately. Ability has never been in question, but he didn’t debut for 2-3 years after being drafted due to feet issues and then got banned as he was establishing himself in the 22. Played more as a mid until this year where he’s been played predominantly forward with good results, hence almost half his career goals coming in the last 12 games.In all honest i dont look at his statts , Watched him in 2 games live and probably 2 on television and he wasnt much chop , But ill take your word for it but will be 28 in january only has 53 games and 45 goals doesnt reallly scream out AFL player - Reece Conca has better credentials atm
Agreed but cant just wipe all that away when 28 years old, Would devalue him considerably , as a straight out trade for picks i would value him at around 45+ in this years draft as a tradeHeavily injury (and drug) interrupted career unfortunately. Ability has never been in question, but he didn’t debut for 2-3 years after being drafted due to feet issues and then got banned as he was establishing himself in the 22. Played more as a mid until this year where he’s been played predominantly forward with good results, hence almost half his career goals coming in the last 12 games.
Hey I never said he was super valuable at the trade table, just that he’s not fringe. He’s entrenched himself in the 22 well and truly this year. That aside, he’s a free agent so no trade would be needed anyway. It’s really a moot conversation.Agreed but cant just wipe all that away when 28 years old, Would devalue him considerably , as a straight out trade for picks i would value him at around 45+ in this years draft as a trade
Don't mind him at all if the price is right .Hey I never said he was super valuable at the trade table, just that he’s not fringe. He’s entrenched himself in the 22 well and truly this year. That aside, he’s a free agent so no trade would be needed anyway. It’s really a moot conversation.
Lynch, De Goey, Elliott, Hoskin-Elliott, Stephenson How will other clubs even be able to compete?
The same current list the Hawks ONCE AGAIN destroyed in round 2?No it’s the current list.
Thomas is 26In all honest i dont look at his statts , Watched him in 2 games live and probably 2 on television and he wasnt much chop , But ill take your word for it but will be 28 in january only has 53 games and 45 goals doesnt reallly scream out AFL player - Reece Conca has better credentials atm
Were you guys able to change the list after the lions blew you out or won’t we be seeing you in SeptemberThe same current list the Hawks ONCE AGAIN destroyed in round 2?
Or were you blokes allowed to change the list since then?
I hear you brother, this Premiership drought is killing me.Were you guys able to change the list after the lions blew you out or won’t we be seeing you in September
1.10.1991 He will be 28 in january like i saidThomas is 26
You must have forgotten the 40+ point choke just last yearI hear you brother, this Premiership drought is killing me.
However what’s that got to do with the fact the Hawks have destroyed Collingwood for so long now it’s become boring?