Collingwood 2010/11 vs Richmond 2017/18

[Summer Nights]

Who would win?

 

[mike123]

Collingwood 2011 should be included in the title

 

[Summer Nights]

Collingwood 2011 should be included in the title

Fixed.

 

[UnitedWarrior93]

Collingwood would win for me.

 

[Sorryboutthatchief]

Collingwood 2011 should be included in the title

Yeah cos the Malthouse saga shafted a great team. Agreed!

 

[Old Stuckup]

Pies.

 

[Fadge]

Tiges.

Jolly, Ball, Didak, Swan, Maxwell, etc. haven't played for a while and are getting on in years.

 

[Leviathan Pie]

Pies 2010/11 were unbelievable, in a superb era (Hawthorn/Geelong etc.)

Think they'd have the Tigers covered.

 

[PieLebo87]

Tiges.

Jolly, Ball, Didak, Swan, Maxwell, etc. haven't played for a while and are getting on in years.

Wouldn’t be by much though.

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

Well both have one premiership, I suppose whoever has two is ultimately gonna be better. But still to win one premiership is fantastic, dumb troll thread though

 

[Frank Gallagher]

A half full strength 2018 Collingwood would win now.

 

[PieLebo87]

Well both have one premiership, I suppose whoever has two is ultimately gonna be better. But still to win one premiership is fantastic, dumb troll thread though

Kinda hard for Collingwood 2010/2011 to win the second premiership now lol

 

[kaiserchief13]

Hopefully they have the same result in the 2nd year. Think Richmond would win at MCG, Collingwood anywhere else

 

[DustinsGuns]

Hopefully they have the same result in the 2nd year. Think Richmond would win at MCG, Collingwood anywhere else

Lol kaisercheif at it again.

Wha coaching the pies should and in what era should be the real question? Tiges now, pies in 2010.

Different strategies clearly determine the winner

 

[Substance]

Honestly don't know. That was back when daisy thomas tore games to pieces. Maybe Richmonds gameplan of constantly changing the angles would get it done over the boundary hugging plan of the pies.

 

[Tony Harrison]

No discontent in our coaches box.

 

[Captain_Bender]

Hopefully Richmond can go back to back unlike Collingwood

 

[kaiserchief13]

Lol kaisercheif at it again.

Wha coaching the pies should and in what era should be the real question? Tiges now, pies in 2010.

Different strategies clearly determine the winner

?

 

[Bored_Pie]

Would smash them.

Honestly don't know. That was back when daisy thomas tore games to pieces. Maybe Richmonds gameplan of constantly changing the angles would get it done over the boundary hugging plan of the pies.

Pfft. Richmond push sides to the boundary.. We would smash them.

 

[HTT]

If we had an actual game I reckon the tiges would win. A bit like how whoever the best team is in 8 years would probably beat us now. Thats what time does.
That pies team was pretty dominant though so on a level playing field probably the pies.

 

[Eatosk]

The Pies team of 2010/2011 would win. That team was pretty awesome, similar to Essendon of 2000/2001.

 

[juss]

Impossible to say. The game changes. Just as the Premiers in 8 years time will probably have a new and unique style compared to today's teams. That Collingwoood side were an awesome team as are the current Tigers.

 

[Greggy]

It’s a hard one to pick really, the hard running pressure game we bring could’ve made that Collingwood back line look second rate.

 

[Tiger71]

Would smash them by 48

 

[TJASTA]

Jack Graham