Opinion Moore or Elliott

[legendstatus]

Why do you come to the conclusion that he'll always be a ticking time bomb for injuries?
He just needs to get a full preseason under his belt, just like Matt Sharenburg has...Moore is a big part of our future & I hope he stays.

Because as a jnr he had the same issues, what would be your conclusion then? There is zero evidence that this will improve

Over to you


Sent from my Warped mind

 

[Go Woods]

Because as a jnr he had the same issues, what would be your conclusion then? There is zero evidence that this will improve

Over to you


Sent from my Warped mind

I'm no expert, but he needs an injury free run at a full preseason, build up his strength, achieve the body of work required through his legs. He certainly does not deserve contract $ of more than $500k per season yet, if $ is the issue holding him back from signing on.

 

[JM#1]

Elliot, Hoskin Elliot, Stephenson all roaming around the forward line. Sounds good to me.

 

[HFF]

Elliott everyday of the week.

You know he will impact and contribute instantly.

 

[FadeAway]

Hasn’t Elliot had his lower discs fused? His back is fu**ed!!

 

[jackcass]

Hasn’t Elliot had his lower discs fused? His back is fu**ed!!

Didn't seem to stop him playing in 2017.

 

[jathanas]

Elliot is by far the better player, but I would choose more. Having a key back, forward, ruckman winger is rare and I think particularly come finals he will be important. Elliot we can cover as our small forward brigade are playing really well

I support this logic (Moore is more important to our current requirements) but on an emotional level I have a real soft spot for Elliot.

Ideally we keep both and manage to get them healthy. We'd be flag favorites if they were 100% right now.

 

[FadeAway]

Didn't seem to stop him playing in 2017.

Wasn’t it end of 2017?

 

[jackcass]

Wasn’t it end of 2017?

2017 was post back surgery which he had in 2016.

 

[left at home]

Wasn’t it end of 2017?

Ankle at the end of 2017

 

[Rimmer]

It's frustrating Elliot can't stay fit I like watching him in full flight; but in a way as an outsider looking in the great enigma is Moore. What do you do? He is a tall approaching the age when talls blossom, his dad was a god. He might be the next Travis Cloke or he could end up a Ty Vickery. How hard do you try to keep him if Sydney is truly knocking at the door ready to pay overs ...

 

[Tbone McGraw]

It's frustrating Elliot can't stay fit I like watching him in full flight; but in a way as an outsider looking in the great enigma is Moore. What do you do? He is a tall approaching the age when talls blossom, his dad was a god. He might be the next Travis Cloke or he could end up a Ty Vickery. How hard do you try to keep him if Sydney is truly knocking at the door ready to pay overs ...

If Moore was guaranteed to stay fit, I would say he would become a gun key defender of the comp. However doesn't look good for him with his history.

Unfortunately Elliott is similar.

Re Moore or Elliott, I take Elliott but only just.

 

[loki04]

If Moore was guaranteed to stay fit, I would say he would become a gun key defender of the comp. However doesn't look good for him with his history.

Unfortunately Elliott is similar.

Re Moore or Elliott, I take Elliott but only just.

Moore would also be a gun KPF. His issue is injury and perhaps mental toughness when carrying "niggles".

 

[MISFITS]

Moore.
Elliot has a degenerative back condition.(he won't play many games)
Plus Elliot is replaceable.
Moore is a rare athlete and can fill some desperately needed key Positions.

 

[EddiesBigBucks]

Elliott. His heart beats black and white.

 

[PeanutButter Pies]

 

[DuckToaster]

Elliott if he can back to 80/90% of what he was. People forget just how good he is. Bleeds for the jumper too.

 

[Sea fog]

Elliott if he can back to 80/90% of what he was. People forget just how good he is. Bleeds for the jumper too.

Guess we're about to find out on that one.

 

[TradeDraft]

Moore by a Mile

 

[Barham to Kink]

Moore by a Mile

No.

By 10 miles.

 

[left at home]

Rather have both thanks

 

[caloschwaby]

One is a tall backman and the other is a small/medium forward. Are they really comparable in these "Would you rather X or Y" hypotheticals?

 

[ClaytonM]

Moore by a Mile

Reality is we haven’t seen the best of both of them. I have little doubt Elliott would have been up there amongst our best over the past ten years if he had of stay fit. He is really quality and Xfactor.

Moore is yet to put together more than a dozen decent games in a row let alone a full year. If he can’t get his body right he may be looking at a similar deal as Elliott in a few years time. Daniher just pulled the pin and Moore is tracking similarly.

If Moore can stay on the park he will be AA at some point, but it is not guaranteed. On performance so far Elliott has more runs on the board, albeit over a longer period.

 

[Chief Ten Beers]

Is it possible to have both Moore and Elliot, just ditch Beams?

 

[Sea fog]

Reality is we haven’t seen the best of both of them. I have little doubt Elliott would have been up there amongst our best over the past ten years if he had of stay fit. He is really quality and Xfactor.

Moore is yet to put together more than a dozen decent games in a row let alone a full year. If he can’t get his body right he may be looking at a similar deal as Elliott in a few years time. Daniher just pulled the pin and Moore is tracking similarly.

If Moore can stay on the park he will be AA at some point, but it is not guaranteed. On performance so far Elliott has more runs on the board, albeit over a longer period.

And Jordy might be tracking the same way as well. It is funny how the guys with a lot of talent can never get on the park. Jordy was on the park less than Moore this year.