Traded Tom Scully [traded to Hawthorn for a future fourth round pick]

[TheFourPillars]

Oh by the way was the price for darren jarman fair?

 

[Kuuz]

Why?
Pick 50 something is useless to them. Can't they pay his salary out and it's not included in the cap? Rather than gifting him to another finals side?

 

[cdcanman]

Pick 53 is no what he is worth.

Needs to be looked at.



Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

Again, doesn't your club determine what he is worth?
Looked at for what reason?
They're searching for that Hawthorn mole in GWS's list management team aren't they?

 

[DangerSloane]

Do you even know the minimum wage in the NFL or NBA? How about the average wage?

No comparison.

Glad you asked because yes I do.
NBA minimum year contract is $1m but... And it's a big but. They have two way contracts which are $75k guaranteed. Funnily enough almost identical to the minimum wage for an AFL player.
Glad you asked though....
How much realistically does it cost to move cities? In reality people who are far worse off do it all the time.
Poorest excuse possible that one.

 

[DangerSloane]

Yeh serious that if I was GWS id do anything but give him up for that kind of price. Worst possible outcome for them

 

[Colonial]

Again, doesn't your club determine what he is worth?
Looked at for what reason?
They're searching for that Hawthorn mole in GWS's list management team aren't they?

Obviously not as we would of had all the deals we were happy to let go done by now.

Because a player of his skill level and signed is nowhere near worth pick 53.

Investigated for incompetence.

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

 

[Rosscoe]

Yeah it is not the spirit of the game...

 

[Holy Rioli]

Why?
Pick 50 something is useless to them. Can't they pay his salary out and it's not included in the cap? Rather than gifting him to another finals side?

So we're a finals side when it suits your argument about why we shouldn't get a player on the cheap, but outside of this we have one of the worst lists in the comp?

Also the bold part....you do realise there is no scope for players to be paid outside of the salary cap with regards to existing contracts right?

 

[TheFourPillars]

Yeah it is not the spirit of the game...

Ffin lol hahaha

 

[LordLucifer]

If the two clubs involved are happy to do the deal then that is all that matters.

 

[TheFourPillars]

Yeah it is not the spirit of the game...

Unless its st kilda or melbourne or carlton right cos they have been down the bottom for so long. Thats the sort of communist spirit that we need.

 

[Kuuz]

Yeh serious that if I was GWS id do anything but give him up for that kind of price. Worst possible outcome for them

Oh you.

Pretty sure the worst possible outcome would be a salary cap breach, banned from the draft and fined AKA Carlton a decade + back.

Not saying he's coming to Hawthorn, but stating more in general, that if GWS deem them pick 20-60, then there will be a reason aside from salary cap pressure. Yeesh.

 

[Hawks1976]

If the two clubs involved are happy to do the deal then that is all that matters.

Spot on Rohan for 61 should also be investigated based on this rationale

 

[TheFourPillars]

Oh you.

Pretty sure the worst possible outcome would be a salary cap breach, banned from the draft and fined AKA Carlton a decade + back.

Not saying he's coming to Hawthorn, but stating more in general, that if GWS deem them pick 20-60, then there will be a reason aside from salary cap pressure. Yeesh.

Naah mate his problem is scully wants to go to hawthorn nothing more. If he end edd up at Carlton he wouldnt care. He said it himself.

 

[Rosscoe]

Unless its st kilda or melbourne or carlton right cos they have been down the bottom for so long. Thats the sort of communist spirit that we need.

Nah more of a democratic view that he is worth more than pick 53

 

[TheFourPillars]

Nah more of a democratic view that he is worth more than pick 53

Lol democracy. Like when Franklin was only worth pick 19 as a free agent. Mate its the salt and there is plenty of it out there

 

[Back Straight]

It's Mabo, it's the vibe, yeah that's it, it's the vibe....

Investigate now!!!!

 

[Mr Meeseeks]

Unless its st kilda or melbourne or carlton right cos they have been down the bottom for so long. Thats the sort of communist spirit that we need.

St Kilda just traded in a 27 year old guy with injury concerns for peanuts too. A VERY similar salary dump...

Difference was the Saints player has a premiership and 3 AAs.

Cant recall a lot of complaining about that one last week....

 

[Rosscoe]

Lol democracy. Like when Franklin was only worth pick 19 as a free agent. Mate its the salt and there is plenty of it out there

Exactly and then you lobbied the AFL to eradicate Cost of Living Allowance...now you are like the vultures hungry for the scraps to fill your insatiable appetite

Just pay a Fair Price

 

[Messenger]

Then pay what he is worth.



Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

We aren't actually doing the deal on this board...

 

[Messenger]

Exactly and then you lobbied the AFL to eradicate Cost of Living Allowance...now you are like the vultures hungry for the scraps to fill your insatiable appetite

Just pay a Fair Price

We're helping them with their cap issues. That's fair.

 

[Colonial]

We aren't actually doing the deal on this board...

Stunned.



Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

 

[DangerSloane]

Oh you.

Pretty sure the worst possible outcome would be a salary cap breach, banned from the draft and fined AKA Carlton a decade + back.

Not saying he's coming to Hawthorn, but stating more in general, that if GWS deem them pick 20-60, then there will be a reason aside from salary cap pressure. Yeesh.

You think they'd let that happen?

 

[TheFourPillars]

Exactly and then you lobbied the AFL to eradicate Cost of Living Allowance...now you are like the vultures hungry for the scraps to fill your insatiable appetite

Just pay a Fair Price

Lol we will fill our appetite and u will like it mate

 

[evo]

Tantamount to cheating.

Mulder should investigate.