Player Watch Tim Broomhead - (Delisted 2020)

[Finnishpie]

One year as excellent talented depth.

No issues.

I’m not a particular fan of delisting to make them a rookie.

You want them then give them a contract and trust your judgment.

The option to delist then rookie again should only be used for the players that you are happy to see g, but if push comes to shove can have as emergency back up like Oxley.

To me Broomhead far too talented for an Oxley risk move to delist then rookie.

One year is fine

I guess the question is: who gets delisted. I’m actually struggling to find the 4 we need. Blair, Goldsack, Wells, Smith? But Goldy and Wells could stay on and Smith would be stiff even though I’m not a fan.

 

[Finnishpie]

Pretty sure it was the left leg he broke and that that was the leg he was driving with. Either way, I'd have assumed the leg on the scooter still gets a solid weight bearing work out.

Rewatching the vid, you can see his left leg is tiny compared to the one on the scooter.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

I guess the question is: who gets delisted. I’m actually struggling to find the 4 we need. Blair, Goldsack, Wells, Smith? But Goldy and Wells could stay on and Smith would be stiff even though I’m not a fan.

I think they would pretty much cut ie meet Mr Mayhem, the three as the likeliest:

Blair
Smith
Oxley

Then the injured player who
Might be seen as too unlikely to be that fully fit player:

Kirby

That’s the first part.

Then you’d need to know who might be depth and attract a nice move away and that seems

Fasolo.

Others that might be vulnerable to trade or even meet Mr Mayhem?

This I don’t know.

Then who might retire?

Wells (sad but it happens)
Goldsack (gets a year surely)

They’ll probably be a surprise somewhere too.

 

[left at home]

I guess the question is: who gets delisted. I’m actually struggling to find the 4 we need. Blair, Goldsack, Wells, Smith? But Goldy and Wells could stay on and Smith would be stiff even though I’m not a fan.

Oxley will.

 

[Mkcaptain]

I actually reckon Broomy would fit really well into our forward line this season. If he could increase his defensive tenacity he would be a perfect replacement for Varcoe.

 

[Ketchup]

I actually reckon Broomy would fit really well into our forward line this season. If he could increase his defensive tenacity he would be a perfect replacement for Varcoe.

After reading that Grundy story about his eating habits I’m convinced he’s never going to make it.

Hope I’m wrong as his skill set is very very nice

 

[76woodenspooners]

I guess the question is: who gets delisted. I’m actually struggling to find the 4 we need. Blair, Goldsack, Wells, Smith? But Goldy and Wells could stay on and Smith would be stiff even though I’m not a fan.

+ Kirby

 

[76woodenspooners]

Oxley will.

He’s currently on the rookie list?

 

[left at home]

He’s currently on the rookie list?

Yes but still will be delisted

 

[Finnishpie]

Yes but still will be delisted

Doesn’t count really.

 

[Finnishpie]

After reading that Grundy story about his eating habits I’m convinced he’s never going to make it.

Hope I’m wrong as his skill set is very very nice

What are his eating habits?

 

[Finnishpie]

I think they would pretty much cut ie meet Mr Mayhem, the three as the likeliest:

Blair
Smith
Oxley

Then the injured player who
Might be seen as too unlikely to be that fully fit player:

Kirby

That’s the first part.

Then you’d need to know who might be depth and attract a nice move away and that seems

Fasolo.

Others that might be vulnerable to trade or even meet Mr Mayhem?

This I don’t know.

Then who might retire?

Wells (sad but it happens)
Goldsack (gets a year surely)

They’ll probably be a surprise somewhere too.

Oxley is rookie so he doesn’t really count.

You’re right about fasolo though. Seems likely to be traded. A bit of bad luck that ha been injured and questionable defensively.

Elliot is out of contract too. Wonder if the salary cap might squeeze him out.

 

[left at home]

Doesn’t count really.

Actually his does, cause if we are looking to bring players in, even on rookie list every spot counts.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Oxley is rookie so he doesn’t really count.

You’re right about fasolo though. Seems likely to be traded. A bit of bad luck that ha been injured and questionable defensively.

Elliot is out of contract too. Wonder if the salary cap might squeeze him out.

After everything you’d think Elliott is still a must keep.

It’s been tough for Fasolo but say it’s elliott v fasolo both up and about to be it’s a no brainer Elliott is so far the keeper.

 

[jackcass]

Oxley is rookie so he doesn’t really count.

You’re right about fasolo though. Seems likely to be traded. A bit of bad luck that ha been injured and questionable defensively.

Elliot is out of contract too. Wonder if the salary cap might squeeze him out.

Why not? Doesn't him being delisted open a spot for someone like Kirby, Dunn or Broomy to drop down to the rookie list and be retained? Doesn't that free up a senior list spot?

Of those who should be departing at years end, I'd have Blair, Greenwood, Smith and Oxley as the only certs. Then some significant discussion about the Sack, Broomy, Dunn and Kirby. Then there will always be someone who requests a trade.

I think we'll retain the contracted guys like Crocker, Wells, Mayne and Varcoe.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Why not? Doesn't him being delisted open a spot for someone like Kirby, Dunn or Broomy to drop down to the rookie list and be retained? Doesn't that free up a senior list spot?

Of those who should be departing at years end, I'd have Blair, Greenwood, Smith and Oxley as the only certs. Then some significant discussion about the Sack, Broomy, Dunn and Kirby. Then there will always be someone who requests a trade.

I think we'll retain the contracted guys like Crocker, Wells, Mayne and Varcoe.

Absolutelty. The one rookie spot that is designated to a senior player can be made available to another senior player brought down from the senior list. Add Goldy to that list of possibles. Saying Oxley is "just a rookie" and his list spot is unimporatnt is incorrect. A senior spot can still easily be opened up.

 

[MyManLynch]

I guess the question is: who gets delisted. I’m actually struggling to find the 4 we need. Blair, Goldsack, Wells, Smith? But Goldy and Wells could stay on and Smith would be stiff even though I’m not a fan.

Fasolo may leave, Oxley May be delisted...Crocker? Kirby?

 

[Finnishpie]

Why not? Doesn't him being delisted open a spot for someone like Kirby, Dunn or Broomy to drop down to the rookie list and be retained? Doesn't that free up a senior list spot?

Of those who should be departing at years end, I'd have Blair, Greenwood, Smith and Oxley as the only certs. Then some significant discussion about the Sack, Broomy, Dunn and Kirby. Then there will always be someone who requests a trade.

I think we'll retain the contracted guys like Crocker, Wells, Mayne and Varcoe.

Sorry, I mean that we still have to get rid of (I think) 4 from the senior list - Oxley doesn't count for that.

 

[jackcass]

Sorry, I mean that we still have to get rid of (I think) 4 from the senior list - Oxley doesn't count for that.

Only 3 compulsory changes to the senior list as far as I know.

 

[Finnishpie]

Only 3 compulsory changes to the senior list as far as I know.

Right. Thanks for the clarification. For some reason I thought 4.

 

[Stifler's mom]

Set to be delisted and rookie listed.
I really hope he recovers from his broken leg and gets an extended injury free run to show his wares.

2019 is make or break for him at Collingwood. He has a nice skill set, but needs to put it all together in a side that now has great depth, so spots are tough to earn.

Hopefully he can have a big preseason and a great 2019.

 

[jackcass]

Set to be delisted and rookie listed.
I really hope he recovers from his broken leg and gets an extended injury free run to show his wares.

2019 is make or break for him at Collingwood. He has a nice skill set, but needs to put it all together in a side that now has great depth, so spots are tough to earn.

Hopefully he can have a big preseason and a great 2019.

Happy to see him offered another year on the rookie list. Sends the right messages to the playing group. He's had a shocking run, glandular fever (2013), broken arm (2014), shoulder (2015-16), ankle (2016) and then the broken leg this year. 2017 was the only year he's had an unbroken run at it and was in and out of the side. Seen enough in him at VFL level to see what he might bring to the senior side if he can replicate that form but the onus is on him to take any chance he gets.

 

[Bard]

His career is at the crossroads like Thomas’ was, he has the ability and the opportunity to turn it around, but does he have the drive? Tune in next time to find out....

 

[CFC2010]

 

[MarkT2]

Far from convinced he's good enough but more than happy to ride out a year as a rookie to see how it pans out.