Traded Tom Scully [traded to Hawthorn for a future fourth round pick]

[Slick]

Trouble is most of your supporter base actually believe it.

I can’t speak on their behalf but all good.

 

[sthmelb_dimmies]

Sorry Hawks doctors who examined Scully, from what Bigfooty guy knows, he is in trouble.

 

[The Nostradamus]

wish hawks didnt get scully and scrimshaw cheap as they seem to be lumping it all in with the wingard deal to make it seem good overall

they got rorted in the wingard deal

 

[The wily weagle]

What this deal really comes down to is a battle of the medical teams

If Hawthorn can get Scully right, they have got one of the greatest steals of all time

If they cant get him right, GWS will be "i told you so" and have freed up more salary cap space.

I would back in Hawthorns team here, the managed to have got O'Meara right and when they signed up Burgoyne back in the day he hobbled into the club on one leg after been told he was basically finished. Turns out, he is still playing

 

[TheFourPillars]

No, no, no. We pulled out as we didn't want to pay what GWS were asking

Well played mate but as u can see we still have our first for next year. We were never paying two firsts for shiel

 

[TheFourPillars]

wish hawks didnt get scully and scrimshaw cheap as they seem to be lumping it all in with the wingard deal to make it seem good overall

they got rorted in the wingard deal

This is the thing we are willing to do whats necessary if within our plans the 2nd and 3rd round picks dont matter

 

[DapperDon]

Well played mate but as u can see we still have our first for next year. We were never paying two firsts for shiel

What round was Ryan taken in?

 

[TheFourPillars]

What round was Ryan taken in?

Mate thats not the question is it because scrimshaw was pick 7. We obviouly value wingard because we lost rioli. We also can run him through the middle. We couldnt do the shiel deal bcos that would have locked us out of the wingard deal

 

[DapperDon]

Mate thats not the question is it because scrimshaw was pick 7. We obviouly value wingard because we lost rioli. We also can run him through the middle. We couldnt do the shiel deal bcos that would have locked us out of the wingard deal

It was a joke mate, it's all good

 

[hawkermitch]

It has taken me a while to read this thread.
From what I gather it shows supporters of teams who are fair and others who dislike the hawks the most show it any chance they get.
The Swans got Josh Kennedy and Ben McGlynn for a 3rd rounder combined; this was as they basically doubled their salary and guaranteed
them games. They got Buddy for free and complain.
The Cats really dislike the hawks - think it goes back even before hawks defeated cats by 6 points in the 1989 grand final, they hold
a grudge.
The Lions can complain but the got Hodge still performing at a cheap price of a very late pick.

Tom Scully is from south east Melbourne suburbs so driving to Mulgrave is the easy way to go.
His injury is severe, a high risk and no guarantees.
Tom had a contract with GWS that ended in 2021 so can see why they offloaded him, 3 years left is a long time.

The funny part is I hope and dream he is fit to play Easter Monday against a rival who despises hawks the most.

That would be fun - hope Tom can return to at least 80% fitness, as Hawks haven't had a replacement for Brad Hill,
who is a 3 time premiership player the Hawks traded to Freo where he could play with his brother and it was the right thing to do;
and I and many hawks fans miss Brad but want the best for him unlike other clubs that hold a player to contract
when for family reasons wants to go home.

 

[Vindicater]

So what are the details of Scullys recovery?

Did Hawthorn send him for a surgery after trading for him or had he already had it?

 

[Steven Tyler]

So what are the details of Scullys recovery?

Did Hawthorn send him for a surgery after trading for him or had he already had it?

Had the pins removed from his ankle 7 weeks ago
The club is saying he will start light running soon and will build up from there

Mind you, our injury updates are as believable as WWE

 

[Mitchell54]

Ok well on top of that it’s a salary dump for GWS. We’l see, but don’t be suprised biccy boy when we get him for a 2nd and steak knives

Why the massive overvaluation of Scully?

 

[Burtman]

Had the pins removed from his ankle 7 weeks ago
The club is saying he will start light running soon and will build up from there

Mind you, our injury updates are as believable as WWE

I’ve heard grant birchall is still two weeks away

 

[Procrastinator35]

So what are the details of Scullys recovery?

Did Hawthorn send him for a surgery after trading for him or had he already had it?

He's a long-term punt....Lets be honest.

As with O'Meara, it may well take an entire year until he's anywhere near right again....And even this year, O'Meara's knees had to be 'managed' at a 75% workload.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

They would say that though, wouldn't they.



Scully was running prior to Xmas incidentally.

 

[Holy Rioli]

They would say that though, wouldn't they.



Scully was running prior to Xmas incidentally.

Do you have a video of that though? It is highly likely that photo was doctored is the advice I received.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Do you have a video of that though? It is highly likely that photo was doctored is the advice I received.

LOL.

 

[GUMBLETRON]

Scully was running prior to Xmas incidentally.

What does this say about the list management and medical program at GWS?

 

[threesixpio]

What does this say about the list management and medical program at GWS?

They were happy to get decent picks elsewhere

 

[Holy Rioli]

They were happy to get decent picks elsewhere

They managed to get the equivalent of 2274 (worth slightly more than pick 3) points in the Shiel trade, so they felt the 59 points they got for Scully were all they needed.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

What does this say about the list management and medical program at GWS?

Not too much, to be fair. They may have had him doing similar if he'd stayed.

 

[Colonial]

What does this say about the list management and medical program at GWS?

Our medical program sucked.

Interesting to see how the program has improved in the off season.

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk

 

[Buzzasto DaSilva]

What does this say about the list management and medical program at GWS?

We are a rabble, shut us down or shift is to Tasmania...

 

[Procrastinator35]

We are a rabble, shut us down or shift is to Tasmania...

50/50 split betwixt Canberra & Darwin for the win.