Position 2019 Midfielders

[Jiska]

Yeah but that shouldn't affect his fitness too much right? He can still run full pelt, just no tackling/full contact he should be right to go round one.
Interrupted preseason isn't ideal but a shoulder is quite different to ankles, groin, hamstrings, knees etc.

Dunno. toxic was the one saying no Jelly because of surgery, but selected Fyfe last year and now selecting Titch. Very confusing.

 

[Me Myself and I]

Titch AC Joint surgery in November, three months recovery period

This post says differently.
https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2019-injuries-and-suspensions.1210354/#post-59073642

 

[Jiska]

This post says differently.
https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2019-injuries-and-suspensions.1210354/#post-59073642

Hawthorn:
-Tom Mitchell: AC joint surgery in November. 2-3 months recovery.

 

[Plunk]

I have the Gawndy combo, if anybody else is in the same boat, I'd love to hear your midfield structure. Currently I have 4 premos + Libba but I was thinking of downgrading else where to bring in a fifth or just swap libba with a cash cow and upgrade another line.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

I have the Gawndy combo, if anybody else is in the same boat, I'd love to hear your midfield structure. Currently I have 4 premos + Libba but I was thinking of downgrading else where to bring in a fifth or just swap libba with a cash cow and upgrade another line.

Yes I have Gawndy .....my midfield (ats) is 4 premo's, Brouch, and Libba .......the only change maybe Hanners/Libba ?

 

[Dark Sharks]

Zerrett has a small dick.

I'm starting to warm to picking him again, despite the fact i think he'll cop the tag ahead of Shiel.

 

[Hawkboy62]

Titch AC Joint surgery in November, three months recovery period

Returned 2 weeks early with the year 1-4's. Claims it is completely healed and is doing full training.

 

[adammania9]

Going cold on Zerrett, he’s slightly underpriced but not enough to push old ladies out of the way for. I struggle to see him averaging 110.

 

[Jiska]

Returned 2 weeks early with the year 1-4's. Claims it is completely healed and is doing full training.

November with 3 months recovery makes it February, so sounds like he returned 2 months early. Bizarre that a 3 month recovery can turn in to a few weeks. Good to hear tho.

 

[Jiska]

Going cold on Zerrett, he’s slightly underpriced but not enough to push old ladies out of the way for. I struggle to see him averaging 110.

I don’t understand the love for him.
I also don’t understand the toxic man crush.

 

[Jiska]

I have the Gawndy combo, if anybody else is in the same boat, I'd love to hear your midfield structure. Currently I have 4 premos + Libba but I was thinking of downgrading else where to bring in a fifth or just swap libba with a cash cow and upgrade another line.

I’ve got Gawndy.
Backs 3-0-3
Midfield 4-0-4
Forwards 4-1-1

 

[Didstar]

Warming to Sloane if he has a full preseason. Before last year 6 consecutive 105+ average and has been reasonable durable over the years.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Warming to Sloane if he has a full preseason. Before last year 6 consecutive 105+ average and has been reasonable durable over the years.

 

[Jiska]

Warming to Sloane if he has a full preseason. Before last year 6 consecutive 105+ average and has been reasonable durable over the years.

He’s a good option. I had him for a while but ended up going for better options. I don’t think you can’t rely on his scores pre-Dangerfield and there were enough problems in his 2017 scoring, without explanation, for me to prefer others that had better consistency.

 

[ubeaut]

Warming to Sloane if he has a full preseason. Before last year 6 consecutive 105+ average and has been reasonable durable over the years.

Has he learnt to deal with a tag though?
He's up against Hewett and Jacobs in rounds 2 and 4 so I guess we'll find out early on. These 2 are the best taggers imo.

 

[Didstar]

Has he learnt to deal with a tag though?
He's up against Hewett and Jacobs in rounds 2 and 4 so I guess we'll find out early on. These 2 are the best taggers imo.

The tag is the worry. But Sloane in recent years has been very up and down. Can make up for some lower scores with the big 150+ scores. Definitely not a lock by any means, but very tempting at the price.

 

[Dark Sharks]

Anyone got a 2017 top 10 mid and a 2018 top 10 mid breakdown?

Would love to know the actual percentage of players who back their lofty price tags up each year.


Thinking Dangerfield, Mitchell, Oliver, Neale, Fyfe, all would. Everyone else is hit and miss.





Brb just adding those 5 players to my team

 

[Jiska]

Anyone got a 2017 top 10 mid and a 2018 top 10 mid breakdown?

Would love to know the actual percentage of players who back their lofty price tags up each year.


Thinking Dangerfield, Mitchell, Oliver, Neale, Fyfe, all would. Everyone else is hit and miss.

Google gave me this

https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_rankings?year=2017&rt=LT&st=SU
https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_rankings?year=2018&rt=LT&st=SU

 

[Plunk]

I’ve got Gawndy.
Backs 3-0-3
Midfield 4-0-4
Forwards 4-1-1

like that a lot, I’m running with;
Backs 3-0-3
Mids 5-0-3
Forwards 3-1-2


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Jiska]

like that a lot, I’m running with;
Backs 3-0-3
Mids 5-0-3
Forwards 3-1-2


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Considered that structure, but seems to be a lack of decent forward rookies but plenty of decent mid rookies. Of course, JLT may well change all that.

 

[Plunk]

Considered that structure, but seems to be a lack of decent forward rookies but plenty of decent mid rookies. Of course, JLT may well change all that.

I think it’s the idea of starting 4 rookies in the highest scoring line that scares me.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Dark Sharks]

At the risk of ruining one of my juicy POD's, i have to ask what people's thoughts are on this spud


Ruined my life last year by playing like a crab.... but am i attracted to bad boys with premo potential?




High risk, high reward boiz. Might be more reckless with my POD's this year, and he's tempting my chol.


Career low disposal average last year, but i'm putting that down to being underdone/new team and Kenny the campaigner giving him minimal game time.

Any idea where i can find his TOG averages over his career?

 

[toxic]

At the risk of ruining one of my juicy POD's, i have to ask what people's thoughts are on this spud


Ruined my life last year by playing like a crab.... but am i attracted to bad boys with premo potential?

View attachment 598190


High risk, high reward boiz. Might be more reckless with my POD's this year, and he's tempting my chol.


Career low disposal average last year, but i'm putting that down to being underdone/new team and Kenny the campaigner giving him minimal game time.

Any idea where i can find his TOG averages over his career?

Brave even mentioning that crab in these parts

 

[Andrew Birch]

At the risk of ruining one of my juicy POD's, i have to ask what people's thoughts are on this spud


Ruined my life last year by playing like a crab.... but am i attracted to bad boys with premo potential?

View attachment 598190


High risk, high reward boiz. Might be more reckless with my POD's this year, and he's tempting my chol.


Career low disposal average last year, but i'm putting that down to being underdone/new team and Kenny the campaigner giving him minimal game time.

Any idea where i can find his TOG averages over his career?

I've had him in my team at some stage most years. Am considering him again. Would need to have a really solid pre-season though. His D/E% drop off is even more of a concern than his TOG for me though.

https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/pc-port-adelaide-power--tom-rockliff?advv=Y

 

[Deliverance]

Anyone got a 2017 top 10 mid and a 2018 top 10 mid breakdown?

Would love to know the actual percentage of players who back their lofty price tags up each year.


Thinking Dangerfield, Mitchell, Oliver, Neale, Fyfe, all would. Everyone else is hit and miss.





Brb just adding those 5 players to my team

From year to year, usually only 3-4 back it up from memory. Finding the 6-7 that slot in to the top ten is tricky.