Wayne Arthurs
#trinitygrammarftw
#trinitygrammarian
#grammarians
#trinitygrammarftw
#trinitygrammarian
#grammarians
Roger Federer is not the GOAT
- Thread starter Butcher32
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Novak's even further behind Serena's slams count!
- Apr 2, 2000
- 74,796
- 25,009
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
Serena's are all so easy though as womens tennis is a bit of a joke.
- Banned
- #1,004
Serena can't be in the conversation for GOAT lol, we all know she wouldn't be ranked top 100 on the Men's tour, so how can you be GOAT ?
- Dec 2, 2014
- 18,575
- 31,249
- AFL Club
- Essendon
Fed, Nadal, Novak are all GOATs, When they're done Tennis will be in a hole for 20 years.
- Nov 27, 2012
- 2,258
- 2,659
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Would it be fair to say that Novak’s very best exceeds Rafa and Fed? If you had to take either of the 3 in the best possible form I find Novak to be the one that’s pretty much impossible to beat.
Nah. Federer's shot variety at his peak eclipses Novak's "wall". Even when he was at his very best, Federer was able to beat him or get close. Some squandered opportunities too.
All a matter of opinion i guess. On clay, djokovic best defeats Feds best. Wimbledon clearly federer, aus open i give it to novak and us open federer.
- Apr 2, 2000
- 74,796
- 25,009
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, Chicago Bulls.
I think it's Fed then Novak and then Nadal. Nadal suffers from being so dominant on clay but not nearly as dominant on other surfaces. A huge % of his GS's are just French Open titles.
All three at their absolute best it's clearly Federer though. He can do it all.
All three at their absolute best it's clearly Federer though. He can do it all.
- Oct 2, 2002
- 4,353
- 4,233
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
- Other Teams
- Arsenal
I don’t think Novak will catch Fed. Would have to win half the GS over the next 3 years. Tough ask.
However if Novak were to win the FO again next year meaning he’d have won every GS at least twice adding to all 9 masters titles, then I think he’s in the GOAT conversation. Fed never took Rafa down at RG. Novak already has.
However if Novak were to win the FO again next year meaning he’d have won every GS at least twice adding to all 9 masters titles, then I think he’s in the GOAT conversation. Fed never took Rafa down at RG. Novak already has.
- Banned
- #1,011
Is it? Who are the challengers?
If Djokovic has indeed rediscovered his mojo, he could quite plausibly win 6 from the next 12. I don't think that's at all far-fetched.
If we say Serena's not the GOAT, are we being racist or sexist?
Any player with a two handed backhand are not worthy to be considered the GOAT.
Don’t be cruel, she’s a mother don’t you know!
Because she has more slams than anyone currently playing
Federer has some catching up to do, but father time will beat him!
Because she has more slams than anyone currently playing
Federer has some catching up to do, but father time will beat him!
This debate is still going!!
Williams is the GOAT in the women’s game, Federer is the GOAT in the men’s game. They cannot be compared as they play two different divisions.
Like it or not when most people ask who is the GOAT time in tennis they are referring to men’s tennis.
Don't stress, Xtreme is trolling us all. Until of course if Nadal passes Feds slam tally, then he will be called the GOAT from this poster.
Then they are ignorant sexist pigs, even the media wrote after last nights match that she has the right to claim GOAT status due to her amount of grand slams won
Then they are ignorant sexist pigs, even the media wrote after last nights match that she has the right to claim GOAT status due to her amount of grand slams won
Yeah, not like the media to have an agenda...
- Banned
- #1,021
Then they are ignorant sexist pigs, even the media wrote after last nights match that she has the right to claim GOAT status due to her amount of grand slams won
I agree the sexist behaviour should stop, lets have an open field irrespective of if you're male or female.
To tell the truth which makes Fedex fans spit chips
I'm not remotely a fan of Federer.
I am a fan of comparing an apple with an apple, instead of a zucchini though.
Then they are ignorant sexist pigs, even the media wrote after last nights match that she has the right to claim GOAT status due to her amount of grand slams won
She has every right to claim that status, she is a superstar in her field.
I am a Federer fan and in my opinion I think he is the GOAT, but that’s just my opinion.
I am also a fan of Williams but I don’t think she is the best female tennis player I have seen in my lifetime, I have Navratilova and Graf ahead of her. But again that’s just my opinion.
So you think they should play against each other?
- Banned
- #1,025
Why not ? All are professionals on the same money, all have two arms and two legs. Would be a good opportunity for Federer to challenge Serena.
