By having both in the midfield we would in most cases be just matching up. We dont have a hell of a lot of big ball winning mids and in games we have lost it has shown up.Actually I reckon Caddy is a good mid and very good forward. IMHO we should be rotating Josh and Dusty mid and forward all game all year. Resting them, putting a big body in the middle and causing mismatches.
Cads can be a really dominant player. He's right now a basically AA grade medium forward, and B grade mid. There's no reason he can't be a better mid and just as good a forward.
Edwards, Prestia, Lambert, Higgins, Graham Ellis are all smallls and cotchin at 185 is a medium sized mid.
when we add in Houl;i and Short down back and the three amigos Butler, Rioli, and Castagna and there isn't a hell of a lot of height and size left.
Its probably one reason why McIntosh keeps getting a game despite being so poor and why Grigg is persevered with.
Its why Caddy playing thru there and getting games into Ross and RC-D is so important.