- Banned
- #526
I think overall most people were happy with the first half... most not so much the second half. (Me I said at half time Clarko will pack up his bags and let it happen has done that over his career in nothing games if we were a little too good early)
I think the major differences were some people were calling out the usual suspects and some were calling out 'premiership heroes' in the second half
Overall I think both were right it was some of the usual suspects, some premiership heroes and or the youngsters.
I think where the biggest discrepancies were
The premiership heroes playing well some did most didn't but ppl forgive them for that premiership... my position if they played a bad game just call it, it happens
Then there was the blaming of the usual suspects if they played a good game sometimes that happens too but if they didn't just say it as well.
Too many ppl viewed the game on past history rather than just the game itself. Liam Shiels for example looked disinterested I've never really seen him play like that but that's what I saw. He's as good as a 4th midfielder in the league you'll ever see over his career so far but he didn't look tuned in and didn't even look to tackle much something he holds afl records in. Do I think that is Liam Shiels, NO, it's just what I saw on one night. I don't judge him on one night overall, but I don't either say Liam Shiels is a triple premiership player so I won't judge him on the game I just saw because he won 3 premierships when discussing the game we just saw. He was fairly average all night for him.
P.S: I reckon for a guy who's been around forever, won 3 premierships as an automatic selection midfielder, he's one of the least discussed players on our list over that period... he's almost the Chris Mew of the 80's.
I think the major differences were some people were calling out the usual suspects and some were calling out 'premiership heroes' in the second half
Overall I think both were right it was some of the usual suspects, some premiership heroes and or the youngsters.
I think where the biggest discrepancies were
The premiership heroes playing well some did most didn't but ppl forgive them for that premiership... my position if they played a bad game just call it, it happens
Then there was the blaming of the usual suspects if they played a good game sometimes that happens too but if they didn't just say it as well.
Too many ppl viewed the game on past history rather than just the game itself. Liam Shiels for example looked disinterested I've never really seen him play like that but that's what I saw. He's as good as a 4th midfielder in the league you'll ever see over his career so far but he didn't look tuned in and didn't even look to tackle much something he holds afl records in. Do I think that is Liam Shiels, NO, it's just what I saw on one night. I don't judge him on one night overall, but I don't either say Liam Shiels is a triple premiership player so I won't judge him on the game I just saw because he won 3 premierships when discussing the game we just saw. He was fairly average all night for him.
P.S: I reckon for a guy who's been around forever, won 3 premierships as an automatic selection midfielder, he's one of the least discussed players on our list over that period... he's almost the Chris Mew of the 80's.