Position 2019 Midfielders

[stevebbb]

Is macrae must have

Definitely not a must have, but he's pretty close
With Titch gone, I like the look of him at M1

 

[toxic]

Definitely not a must have, but he's pretty close
With Titch gone, I like the look of him at M1

I've decided Macrae or Grundy have to go, can't afford both without compromise city taking over

 

[GT619]

Not if your running Gawndy and danger. Way too much budget on 4 guys.

Got all 4, I am considering conigs for him

 

[Deliverance]

Got all 4, I am considering conigs for him

Maybe last year was a spike year.maybe not. He's not getting any more expensive, so you can bring him in later easily enough.

 

[blackshadow]

Is macrae must have

Not if your running Gawndy and danger. Way too much budget on 4 guys.

Definitely not a must have, but he's pretty close
With Titch gone, I like the look of him at M1

I've got Macrae Gawn and Danger and am running with Goldie over Grundy.



One suave *

 

[GT619]

Maybe last year was a spike year.maybe not. He's not getting any more expensive, so you can bring him in later easily enough.

Who are the next best options under him

 

[Deliverance]

Who are the next best options under him

NFI.
I have Fyfe Cripps and Oliver currently. But I'm a bit all over the place with a few possies still.

 

[TravisJohnstone]

Definitely not a must have, but he's pretty close
With Titch gone, I like the look of him at M1

He's such a hack of a player too. Frustrating seeing him score so big.

 

[Yoda_]

Will Dumb Sheet be a top 10 mid? What about BCrouch or Libba? If the answer is no then what is the value of starting more than 1? Especially with all the premo and rookie options available. And with people going with Roberton, Smith,Mills, Newman etc in the backs and Greene, Worpel etc in fwds.
Too many midpricers means too many trades needed.
I mean I've already got Smith, Roberton and Greene. Any more than 1 mid midpricer is overkill if you've got midpricers elsewhere.
I don't get all the love for players off 1/2 meaningless, low intensity, bruise free preseason games.

Good call, however, these mid pricers are garnering us both (overall) points and money that similar rookies would earn us. Furthermore, they have the potential to possibly be a keeper (ala Libba, B.Crouch).

 

[Yoda_]

Worry with Sheed is, when he is crap he is poor.

In the preceeding 3 season, he has only scored between 85 - 100 three times. Which suggests consistency is a problem for young Dom. Good luck to the people trying him but it's a no for me.

 

[caaarnthetiges]

Worry with Sheed is, when he is crap he is poor.

In the preceeding 3 season, he has only scored between 85 - 100 three times. Which suggests consistency is a problem for young Dom. Good luck to the people trying him but it's a no for me.

Lock, sheed is. Wrong, are you.

 

[Yoda_]

Lock, sheed is. Wrong, are you.

Good luck with that

 

[stevebbb]

Treloar for Brownlow.

 

[atlas1]

Treloar for Brownlow.

 

[Moustachio]

In an effort to back up MPM with some kind of logic, let's crowdsource the season averages for the following JLT midfield wonders (I'll start, please replace with your own and anyone you think should get a look in):

Walsh = 80
Cousins = 75
Libba = 90
Sheed = 100
Rocky = 105
BCrouch = 105
Steele = 110
Brayshaw = 110
Sloane = 105
Zerrett = 105

 

[Red Syrah]

$1.2 M for M3 & 4 (already have macrae and cripps)

nominate 2

 

[ubeaut]

In an effort to back up MPM with some kind of logic, let's crowdsource the season averages for the following JLT midfield wonders (I'll start, please replace with your own and anyone you think should get a look in):

Walsh = 80
Cousins = 75
Libba = 90
Sheed = 100
Rocky = 105
BCrouch = 105
Steele = 110
Brayshaw = 110
Sloane = 105
Zerrett = 105

Last 4 aren't midpricers.
Pretty close to the mark, I would say Dumb Sheet and Rocky go 95 though and Brayshaw 105 - 110

 

[Wellsy35]

$1.2 M for M3 & 4 (already have macrae and cripps)

nominate 2

Oliver and Cogs.

 

[ubeaut]

$1.2 M for M3 & 4 (already have macrae and cripps)

nominate 2

Oliver and Coniglio

 

[Scythe94]

In an effort to back up MPM with some kind of logic, let's crowdsource the season averages for the following JLT midfield wonders (I'll start, please replace with your own and anyone you think should get a look in):

Walsh = 80
Cousins = 75
Libba = 90
Sheed = 100
Rocky = 105
BCrouch = 105
Steele = 110
Brayshaw = 110
Sloane = 105
Zerrett = 105

Can’t see Steele going near a 110 average over a full season, but the rest are reasonable. Maybe downgrade Sheed and Rockliff by 5-10. Brouch the big, arousing unknown.

 

[Red Syrah]

Oliver and Cogs.

Oliver and Coniglio

both saying the same, and the same as I have... finally I'm getting on the right track with this jumble of a team

 

[Jcpdragonx]

$1.2 M for M3 & 4 (already have macrae and cripps)

nominate 2

Cogs or Neale + MCrouch

 

[Bollox]

Go on, pick up Rocky

 

[Kadog]

$1.2 M for M3 & 4 (already have macrae and cripps)

nominate 2

Fyfe & Cogs

 

[Red Syrah]

Fyfe & Cogs

Not worried about his elbow?