TradeDraft
Premium Platinum
Gave me a Good Laugh about the Biased
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Gave me a Good Laugh about the Biased
I’d have him over Gawn and Rance.
Alright, exclude Grundy, but how the **** is Rance a top 5/10 player?
So if its justified because Grundy didn't have a great GF, so shouldn't that exclude Rance since De Goey embarassed him?
Wouldn't worry too much about it Dave.. opinions are like you know what.. everyone has got one re.
Personally I think De Goey is a better player than Cripps and Martin.. more versatile and more weapons..
Moore will also prove himself as our 2nd best player..
Some players also seem to be auto selections yr in yr out in these top 10 lists..
Do not remotely care what the media write and pick.
Far too many sewer rats to sift through.
Far better question and fun question is to pick our very own Top Ten best players?
Criteria might be their level of play, their projected growth as a player, their potential fitness etc.
All those things. Even their importance to the team, in other words, everything.
Best 10 on our list (I’m placing in no specific order as such, so will place them jumper order)
- De Goey
- Grundy
- Elliott
- Treloar
- Pendlebury
- Beams
- Adams
- Sidebottom
- Crisp
- Moore
It’s a cunning excercise because even players like, Langdon, Maynard, Stephenson, Howe, Cox, Varcoe, Dunn are thereabouts. Then the expected rise of Sier and then there’s Phillips.
And how to judge the real poise and potential of Scharenberg...
And if he was fully fit, Wells would be a certainty top ten. But alas, the body gets older.
So stuff the media, who are your top ten players on our list?
I think that's entirely reasonable, being in the 10-20 best players in the league is still amazing. He didn't do a lot in the Grand Final which has to impact his rating
Spot on.Who cares what the experts think. Collingwood players have always been underrated. I remember even in 2010 the prevailing view in the media was that we didn't have any star players.