2019 Player X v Y v Z

[freddy mercury]

Billings Vs Boak????

 

[Red Syrah]

Keira, ridley (d 4 and 5) and mrouch (m5)

Vs

Llllllooyd, derrrrrrrrsma (d 1 and 5) and libba (m5)

Being conservative:
Keira, ridley (d 4 and 5) and mrouch (m5) = 75 +70 + 110 = 255 (1 keeper)

Vs

Llllllooyd, derrrrrrrrsma (d 1 and 5) and libba (m5) = 105 + 55 + 95 = 255 (1 keeper + possible in Libba)

Looks like its toss a coin, but I'd go with 2.

 

[Keg on legs]

Billings Vs Boak????

Reckon I'd go boak if i had the coin.



But i dont so i have billings

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Brayshaw vs Taranto

 

[Spacedog]

Brayshaw vs Taranto

Brayshaw

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Brayshaw

 

[Spacedog]

Angus comes from the Rockliff school of pigs

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Angus comes from the Rockliff school of pigs

 

[JuddgementDay]

Rocky vs Sheed

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Rocky vs Sheed

Toss a coin

 

[JuddgementDay]

Toss a coin

It hasn't landed

 

[buddy2fernando]

Tom Jonas or Christian Salem?

 

[PoopingHindi]

Rocky vs Sheed

Rocky...and by a large margin.

forget about the coin. lock him in and you can toss something else when he's scoring 130's while Sheed averages 92

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Neale & Billings
V
Dusty & Boak

Boak and Dustbin

I’d take 2.

Mills vs Milera ?

Mills

MCrouch V Treloar V Coniglio V Steele

MCrouch, Conigs, Steele, Treloar.
Always been a big Treloar fan but there's just too many Pies mids to select any with confidence, especially Treloar who's already at a high price.

I’d take Mills. Just.

Sweet v Bines?
More Sundays v DPP flexibility?

(my team doesn’t have any other ruck/fwds)

Bines. The DPP is very important, some of the rookies you pick will turn out to be duds and become loophole options anyways.

 

[Seymour Skinner]

Billings Vs Boak????

Boak

Brayshaw vs Taranto

Brayshaw is a no go for me personally due to the concussion history.
Brayshaw is more of a DT pick imo, but I'd still pick him ahead of Taranto, don't think he can push 100+ yet.

Tom Jonas or Christian Salem?

Why?
Salem, but why?

 

[JuddgementDay]

Rocky...and by a large margin.

forget about the coin. lock him in and you can toss something else when he's scoring 130's while Sheed averages 92

I was concerned about his durability, but stuff it - as you said, go for the higher ceiling
My team is full of Mid-pricers anyway, why play safe now

 

[PowerForGood]

Brayshaw vs Taranto

Brayshaw.

 

[PowerForGood]

Keira, ridley (d 4 and 5) and mrouch (m5)

Vs

Llllllooyd, derrrrrrrrsma (d 1 and 5) and libba (m5)

2 has a higher ceiling.

 

[PowerForGood]

I went with Lycett.

But 1 looks better as a group to me

1. Grundy / Luke Ryan / Walters / Moore
v
2. Lycett / Crisp / T. Kelly / Billings

Option 2 will move Lycett into fwd at some stage and bring in Grundy.

 

[toxic]

Mills and neale

Vs

Smith and macrea?

Smith and Neale and pocket the savings

 

[Keg on legs]

Smith and Neale and pocket the savings

Exactly what i ended up doing.

Used the savings to go duursma to ridley but not 100% sold on him or keira so a bit stuck

 

[King_Steele]

Macrae, Dusty & Worpel (yes Deliverance I know)
V
Oliver, Neale & Billings

(Want as many captain options as possible, I believe Macrae & Dusty are those with Neale & Oliver consistent 110)

 

[SavDog23]

Macrae, Dusty & Worpel (yes Deliverance I know)
V
Oliver, Neale & Billings

(Want as many captain options as possible, I believe Macrae & Dusty are those with Neale & Oliver consistent 110)

Oliver, Dusty, Billings imo.

 

[toxic]

Macrae, Dusty & Worpel (yes Deliverance I know)
V
Oliver, Neale & Billings

(Want as many captain options as possible, I believe Macrae & Dusty are those with Neale & Oliver consistent 110)

Dusty not a captain option

Macrae and Oliver are

 

[Deliverance]

Macrae, Dusty & Worpel (yes Deliverance I know)
V
Oliver, Neale & Billings

(Want as many captain options as possible, I believe Macrae & Dusty are those with Neale & Oliver consistent 110)

Option 1.

Billings = lololololol