2019 Player X v Y v Z

[Yoda_]

I should clarify that Moore is my D3 at this stage, even though I don't rate him :/

What scares me off about Darcey is the lack of scoring he has produced (2 x 100+, 2 x 90+) from his 54 games.

Moore averages his career (49) he only earns $60,000. Is that viable? I understand it's going to be a new position etc. etc. etc. I just don't see ït"with Moore. Good luck to the guys who go with there gut though

 

[blackshadow]

Brayshaw vs Cogs vs Steele

I currently have Cogs but only $13k in the kitty, a little more cash would be handy I think. I really like the look of Brayshaw, he's been in and out of my side since day 1. Steele is also tempting me.

This is my current midfield.

One suave *

 

[JDavey]

This is such a myth.

Collins averaged 72 (12 games) including 2 x 100. He scores and scores well for a guy in his position. He averaged 72 in his two JLT outings so the potential to score is certainly there from a guy entrenched in the Suns best 22.

Im not hoping he becomes a keeper, just hoping he can garner me the same points/cash as the diluted defensive rookies we have.

He scored like that as a floating intercept defender. With Rory Thompsons injury I suspect he plays lock down with Burgess getting third man duties. That's what we saw in JLT 2. Way too much uncertainty for 188k.

 

[JDavey]

Brayshaw vs Cogs vs Steele

I currently have Cogs but only $13k in the kitty, a little more cash would be handy I think. I really like the look of Brayshaw, he's been in and out of my side since day 1. Steele is also tempting me.

This is my current midfield.

One suave ****

Cogs easily for me. Think he will be very good again this year.

 

[JDavey]

Tricky one for the masses to judge;

(Options 1 - Current set up)

Lachie Whitfield & Jack MaCrae,

v

Rory Laird & Angus Brayshaw


Expecting Gus to enter into prime SC territory and be a top 10 SC midfielder this year but really, really like the points MacCrae will pump out.

Option 1 for me. Whitfield may pass Laird this year and Macrae should end up averaging 10 points more then Brayshaw at least.

 

[blackshadow]

Tricky one for the masses to judge;

(Options 1 - Current set up)

Lachie Whitfield & Jack MaCrae,

v

Rory Laird & Angus Brayshaw


Expecting Gus to enter into prime SC territory and be a top 10 SC midfielder this year but really, really like the points MacCrae will pump out.

Option 1 easily from where I sit.

I have a feeling that with Smith back in Laird bleeds 5-10 points and Macrae should outscore Brayshaw although I see him improving.

One suave *

 

[jdwood]

I am sure I am not the only one grappling with B Crouch vs Rocky vs Sheed. I am only picking one, currently that is B Crouch but certainly not confident.

 

[JDavey]

I am sure I am not the only one grappling with B Crouch vs Rocky vs Sheed. I am only picking one, currently that is B Crouch but certainly not confident.

This is presuming you have Libba who I would take over all of them? Next up for me would be Brad Crouch but I'm passing on all

 

[blackshadow]

I am sure I am not the only one grappling with B Crouch vs Rocky vs Sheed. I am only picking one, currently that is B Crouch but certainly not confident.

I've taken the rocky road over Brouch, Sheed and Libba.

One suave *

 

[Girthquake]

Moore & Ballard, or Moore & McCarthy

 

[rocker_oz33]

Moore & Ballard, or Moore & McCarthy

See what 4ookies get named before getting linc and bell.

I like linc been hoping he would break out and be injury free for years .
I think hes over priced for the scores he will get.

 

[JDWCE]

Brayshaw & Hurn or MCrouch & Crisp

 

[jdwood]

Brayshaw & Hurn or MCrouch & Crisp

Considering I have option 1, I'd suggest option 1.

 

[toxic]

Brayshaw & Hurn or MCrouch & Crisp

All 4

 

[JDWCE]

All 4

Back to the drawing board

 

[Red Syrah]

Oliver + newnes
V
Mrouch + billings

 

[Red Syrah]

Back to the drawing board

Or you go wrong whichever you choose

 

[JDWCE]

Or you go wrong whichever you choose

That's already set in stone

 

[JDWCE]

Oliver + newnes
V
Mrouch + billings

Crouch and Billings. Newnes will up his average almost certainly but Billings more likely to become a keeper

 

[Red Syrah]

That's already set in stone

I actually meant to type ' you can't go wrong' ......

 

[JDWCE]

I actually meant to type ' you can't go wrong' ......

But that's where you're wrong

 

[Keg on legs]

There is something about Moore I just can't shake but I don't like it. Libba, Crouch, Smith, Williams - all can potentially be keepers. I don't see it with Moore, so why pay that much when a rookie could make the $$$ quicker?

Out of the options I would go with Option 3, but if you are willing to take the risk, Option 2. I don't trust Billdick.

Yeah he doesn't sit comfortably in my team but it's a structure issue.

I would happliy trade Macrea down to Neale to get me Libba at M6 but that would mean having to field 3 rookies. I already have Setters and Drew with Petroleum Jelly and Parker.

I would have 140k to spend but it's hard to find anyone else i would trust at F4

Ffs i wish Relton would come out of retirement

 

[sheepdog23]

McRae v Fyfe v Kelly


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[JDWCE]

McRae v Fyfe v Kelly


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

Crae. Fyfe won't play enough games, Kelly has had bugger all pre season

 

[DaveyBoy123]

I think I'm down to pretty much this, with only my R2, M5 & M6's to be decided on:

Goldy, BCrouch & Libba
vs
Gawn, Libba & Cousins
vs
Gawn, BCrouch & M8 rookie (likely Constable or Scott)