Recommitted Tom Phillips [re-signed until end of 2021]

Proud 2 Be Ur New Dad

R.I.P Billy Conforto
May 7, 2019
44
56
AFL Club
Collingwood
Ed Langdon i rate higher than Phillips

Ed probably late teens, Phillips early 20’s picks. Pies fans will no doubt try argue Phillips to be worth the same though
Both fairly vanilla for mine, Tom probably has more runs on the board given he has deep finals experience and has a higher ceiling with his tank and size and obviously has been playing at a higher level for longer.

Both pretty meh however in my opinion. He's great as our 6th best mid.
 

chunkylover53

Norm Smith Medallist
Aug 13, 2008
8,383
18,230
From Where You'd Rather Be
AFL Club
Carlton
I'd go as far as offering our first (technically Adelaide's) for him. Also happy to overpay him for a few years to get him across - we have a shitload of cap space and we won't be landing a 'star' like Coniglio.

Really rate him, and didn't realise he was still only 22.
 

Linda_Lovelace

Cancelled
Jul 28, 2004
3,780
5,718
Melbourne
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Collingwood
It will come down to money
If the difference between opposition offer and pies offer is large that’s when I could see him going

He will get less to stay at the Pies than elsewhere, its always the case when a big club that is in the flag window is the players club.

North throws a ton of money every year and no one comes.
 
Apparently still awaiting afl approval due to it being heavily back ended
With the pies cap obviously being tight
Right. Of course, but probably just a formalty. The AFL gets to these things in their own time. Like they have more important things to do...lol
 
Back