I think Kerr in afl would be less than 7/10.
I see where you are going with it but I can’t see Kerr being more than fringe/backup key forward for any afl team
-
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Analysis 2019 List Management Discussion
- Thread starter The Smoking Gun
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
I think Kerr in afl would be less than 7/10.
I see where you are going with it but I can’t see Kerr being more than fringe/backup key forward for any afl team
We were keen on Sier and Dawson from Sydney.
Both now out of contract.
Be interesting at end of the year
Both now out of contract.
Be interesting at end of the year
Zuribagger
Hopeful
- May 6, 2017
- 527
- 1,345
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Agree with your suggestion for the team this weekend but I also thought: how weird we are sending Weits who was our once in a generation number 1 pick to our ex Magoos rookie.
All picks - early and late - are talented but I reckon tenacity and resilience has a big role in seeing that talent develop. Weits and Gowers both have it. Don’t know why we lost Gowers cheap but we did well to identify that and draft him. It was great how SOS profiled SPS and saw that tenacity & resilience in him (moving away from home to boarding school, learning English, bull-riding tough nut...). SOS himself had those traits. We’re in good hands.
Hoping with Teague in charge we will see
Polson play on ball
Garlett as a running defender/small forward. Just pick one
Lang half forward
Stocker as a mid
Jack as a defender
Murphy small forward
More the merrier
Polson play on ball
Garlett as a running defender/small forward. Just pick one
Lang half forward
Stocker as a mid
Jack as a defender
Murphy small forward
More the merrier
Pure speculation atm showed a little bit last year when he played a few games but we won't know until he gets senior games .
- Dec 22, 2006
- 9,560
- 11,355
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur
What is clear is that we are totally reliant on Kruezar and what we have as back up is not good enough... The Adelaide kid Reilly O’Brien looks the goods and if he is forced out of the side when Jacobs comes in he will be disheartened, is out of contract in 2019 and would be a great long term option for us.
Jacobs is 31. Adelaide would be silly to let him go tbh.
Unfortunately the kid won't be going nowhere, your spot on he's definitely one of the types we are crying out for
I'm a massive Dow fan, wouldn't swap him for anything he did a couple of things on the weekend that only high end players are capable of the glimpses are very exciting, wait for the his fitness base to climb then we'll see him starting to explode. His hands particularly his one grab marks are really impressive.
There is a few around. Goddard in the WAFL is young but looks good, 1 or 2 in the SANFL and there are names like Sean Darcy, Darcy Cameron, Max Lynch that all look like they just need an opportunity. I don't think we will have any issue getting 1 or even 2.
Moody Blue
Premiership Player
They better get on their bikes quick. Big guys usually take 3-4 years to find their feet. Not sure we have that sort of time left with Kreuzer.
Weiterbot23
Cancelled
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer Sponsor 2016
Carlton Blues - Matthew Kreuzer 2009 Player Sponsor
Don't Collingwood have 17 players out of contract including Grundy
Surely something has to fall out
I'd be going aggressive at Stephenson, worst case they overpay to keep him abs loose someone else
They won't lose anyone they don't want too or can't afford too lose, my understanding is they have room to move in their salary cap and players who are on ok/good coin that will free more space up when they are decided on at the end of the year. ie Wells Goldsack Dunn Varcoe Reid Phillips Greenwood.
According to FW the list is:
- Ben Crocker
- Ben Reid (UFA)
- Brayden Sier
- Daniel Wells
- Jack Madgen
- Jamie Elliott (RFA)
- John Noble
- Levi Greenwood
- Lynden Dunn
- Max Lynch
- Rupert Wills
- Sam Murray
- Taylor Adams
- Tim Broomhead
- Tom Phillips
- Travis Varcoe
- Tyson Goldsack (UFA)
Phillips, Adams, Lynch, Sier and maybe Wills the ones of interest but I find it hard to believe they'd let them go at the end of the season. Plenty of older guys to jettison before then.
On profile Goddard is the best prospect (would be lovely to be given a state league freebie and nab him pre draft) he didn't nominate for the mid season rookie draft.
Cameron a couple of years advanced, but can't crack a game at Sydney but would be a good back up if available at the right price.
Darcy looked good for a bit, losing plenty of bulk in his first AFL season. Needs to lose more, although latest shots seem to have him larger again. If he doesn't have the necessary commitment to drop the kgs, is not worth the risk. Reports that Freo are in to Tim English suggests they are not happy with their numerous options as long term no. 1. A bloke like Lloyd Meek may be a decent break glass rookie if we wanted a cheap option. They also have Scott Jones in the wings.
Lynch a good option, but hard to see him let go as only genuine Grundy successor (Roughead probably in tandem would be option if Grundy went down)
May be stuck with one of Phillips or Lobbe for another year unless TDK can have a dominant second half to the season at Northern and a couple of impressive auditions in the ones.
This amateur talent watcher is tracking Henry Walsh and Crippa's baby brother as future ruck prospects. Henry next year, although an underager at this year's championships. Not totally sure, but think young Cripps is two years away. A slight glance to TDK's young brother, Sam, for this year's draft, although currently KPD and part time KPF and ruck. May not fall within our range, but I am sure we are tracking all of them.
- Sep 2, 2017
- 1,414
- 5,231
- AFL Club
- Carlton
dragonsblues
Club Legend
- Jun 23, 2013
- 1,367
- 3,057
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Zuribagger
Hopeful
- May 6, 2017
- 527
- 1,345
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Though a sad result, it’s good to see the club biting the bullet on Pickett. It comes back to identifying whether each player has that tenacity and commitment to succeed (no matter how talented).
Damn! What could have been...
Lynch a sneaky chance with a good enough offer...
Been half expecting this in regards to pickett, didnt feel like he wanted it enough.
- Mar 25, 2019
- 7,036
- 14,354
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Wonder if Teague had anything to do with the decision? Bolton always backed him in, phenomenal talent but shame he could never get right for a full season.
- Status
