2019 Player X v Y v Z

[Benno_900]

Help guys- what's the go with the Hoff? Seeing he may be dropped. Is it likely to be more than just a week??

Who to trade: Hoff or Atkins????

It's probably just a kick up the arse.

May just be one week.

 

[Axly]

Lycett v Marshall v Daniel

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Lycett v Marshall v Daniel

Without seeing team, Daniel.

Who to cull B Smith Milera Hornbag?

 

[Axly]

Without seeing team, Daniel.

Who to cull B Smith Milera Hornbag?

Here's my team.


Hornbag , has done his job.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

Here's my team.


Hornbag , has done his job.

Still Daniel but I'd upgrade mids first.

 

[stevebbb]

Rich vs Weller vs Andrews vs Hurley vs Salem vs Sicily

 

[Axly]

Rich vs Weller vs Andrews vs Hurley vs Salem vs Sicily

Hurley or Andrews.
Both weren't great last week, but safer than the others for their price imo

 

[JuddgementDay]

Rich vs Weller vs Andrews vs Hurley vs Salem vs Sicily

Sicily of the fwd experiment is over

 

[stevebbb]

Sicily of the fwd experiment is over

Unfortunately we won't know that, Clarko is a campaigner. Hopefully some info pops up during the week which confirms it

 

[gutsroy]

Rich vs Weller vs Andrews vs Hurley vs Salem vs Sicily

Rich
Weller
Andrews / Hurley
Would not go Salem.

 

[ROOINYOU]

am stuck on who comes in this week for final mid spot.
Bont-112 avg and looks good for a 105-110 avg for the rest of the year.
Sloane-108 avg and could easily pump out 110+ avg from here...concerns over his hammy scare the other week though.
Matt-102avg and could easily go 105 for the year...value pick for sure.
Treloar another I'm looking at, but my hate for the Pies is holding him back.

if I can save cash it will go towards upgrade of either Hore/Smith to Hurn in the coming weeks.
only got 533k to play with, so no use looking at guys over that.
already have Cripps,Neale,Fyfe,Jelly,Oliver,Macrae and Brad.
my head says Bont, gut says Sloane, dreams say Matt......and my anoos says Treloar.

what order do you guys rank these guys for total points from now to the end?

 

[InTheBack]

Lycett v Billings v Ziebell v Daniel

(Less favoured is daniel as he is moat expensive)

 

[Squiba]

Thoughts on Treloar? Can bring in both he and Grundy without culling ROB this week if Naish and or Garner get axed

 

[Benno_900]

Lycett v Billings v Ziebell v Daniel

(Less favoured is daniel as he is moat expensive)

Daniel

 

[Changa10]

Thoughts on Treloar? Can bring in both he and Grundy without culling ROB this week if Naish and or Garner get axed

I grabbed Treloar last week. Think he is a good get at his price. No Beams should see him continue at his current average at minimum.

For defence; Stewart v Houston v L Weller

This will be for my D6, and I am planning on getting Hurn next week after his price drops a bit more.

 

[stevebbb]

I grabbed Treloar last week. Think he is a good get at his price. No Beams should see him continue at his current average at minimum.

For defence; Stewart v Houston v L Weller

This will be for my D6, and I am planning on getting Hurn next week after his price drops a bit more.

Stewart for me. Very consistent, no headaches
Houston could start scoring poorly with Port's best team coming back in
Weller would be my 2nd option, but will probs average 5-9 less than Stewart

 

[Squiba]

I grabbed Treloar last week. Think he is a good get at his price. No Beams should see him continue at his current average at minimum.

For defence; Stewart v Houston v L Weller

This will be for my D6, and I am planning on getting Hurn next week after his price drops a bit more.

I'd be looking for the bankable 100 odd and go Stewart

 

[Changa10]

Stewart for me. Very consistent, no headaches
Houston could start scoring poorly with Port's best team coming back in
Weller would be my 2nd option, but will probs average 5-9 less than Stewart

I'd be looking for the bankable 100 odd and go Stewart

Thanks Kents. Was probably more deciding between Weller and Stewart, but I think you are right.




Although, Weller has not had a score under 87 since Round 1, his high score is only 106, and taking out that 55 his average is 97. But at least Stewart has made the 120's a couple of times, and has only been under 90 twice all year.

I think for the extra $20k I would be getting a better high end ceiling at least.

 

[Red Syrah]

am stuck on who comes in this week for final mid spot.
Bont-112 avg and looks good for a 105-110 avg for the rest of the year.
Sloane-108 avg and could easily pump out 110+ avg from here...concerns over his hammy scare the other week though.
Matt-102avg and could easily go 105 for the year...value pick for sure.
Treloar another I'm looking at, but my hate for the Pies is holding him back.

if I can save cash it will go towards upgrade of either Hore/Smith to Hurn in the coming weeks.
only got 533k to play with, so no use looking at guys over that.
already have Cripps,Neale,Fyfe,Jelly,Oliver,Macrae and Brad.
my head says Bont, gut says Sloane, dreams say Matt......and my anoos says Treloar.

what order do you guys rank these guys for total points from now to the end?

Sloane, bont, Matt, treloar.
For the price and potential Sloane is the best value

 

[DaveyBoy123]

SPs Owies & Hayden can wait (unless 1 of them is in this week).

Quite simply, who will have made more $$$ in say 5 weeks time:

Hately or Hind?

 

[Obese Arachnid]

SPs Owies & Hayden can wait (unless 1 of them is in this week).

Quite simply, who will have made more $$$ in say 5 weeks time:

Hately or Hind?

Hately.

 

[stevebbb]

I need some help!!!
This would be my D4 to D8 and the number of trades left.

Option 1: Rich, Smith, Milera (Duursma, Logue) + 4 trades left
vs
Option 2: Stewart, Laird/Rich, Smith (Logue, Answerth) + 3 trades left


With the first option I could 1 up/1 down in a few weeks time and bring in Hurn/Whitfield/Stewart/Laird, that is if I can avoid any LTIs and keep my 4 trades for a while

Questions are: How valuable is that trade? Can Milera go back to scoring 90-95 next week? Will Answerth stick around to potential cover in the late rounds if required?


Thoughts?


Trades for each option are:
Option 1 = Answeth to Hayden + Corbett to Rich
Option 2 = Corbett to Hayden + Milera to Stewart; [next week] Duursma to Laird/Rich

 

[stevebbb]

I need some help!!!
This would be my D4 to D8 and the number of trades left.

Option 1: Rich, Smith, Milera (Duursma, Logue) + 4 trades left
vs
Option 2: Stewart, Laird/Rich, Smith (Logue, Answerth) + 3 trades left


With the first option I could 1 up/1 down in a few weeks time and bring in Hurn/Whitfield/Stewart/Laird, that is if I can avoid any LTIs and keep my 4 trades for a while

Questions are: How valuable is that trade? Can Milera go back to scoring 90-95 next week? Will Answerth stick around to potential cover in the late rounds if required?


Thoughts?


Trades for each option are:
Option 1 = Answeth to Hayden + Corbett to Rich
Option 2 = Corbett to Hayden + Milera to Stewart; [next week] Duursma to Laird/Rich

 

[JuddgementDay]

I prefer option 2
Relying on both smith & milera is not good, just keep one of them

 

[Danco]

I prefer option 2
Relying on both smith & milera is not good, just keep one of them

Yeah agreed - Option 2
Stewart

Also, i'd almost go as far as fielding Logue over Smith