Round 15 trades

[delinquent1807]

Bringing in Hatley last minute to cover Cripps, got a feeling I will want the extra 46k back by games end.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

 

[Milanista28]

Kyron or Hanrahan? I think kyron

 

[JT_the_Man]

Burgess/Young > Logue
Hore/Smith > Naish

I guess?

 

[JT_the_Man]

Can’t get Hately without cashing in early, so I’ll pass.

 

[vanders]

Kyron or Hanrahan? I think kyron

Hanrahan could easily be dropped next week. Go the other bloke, or better yet get Cameron from WCE

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Burgess/Young > Logue
Hore/Smith > Naish

I guess?

Hold fire on the second trade Richmond have 6 ins into the 18 and only 3 outs so far, Naish might get dropped.

Im going Hayes to Hately tonight then I was going Wilkie to Boak tomorrow but i might hold 24 hours in case Hore gets dropped.

 

[dash555]

Loophole Clarke or Hately?

 

[BOMBERBLITZ]

Clarke if you think the Bombers can get up!
...otherwise Hately

 

[Benno_900]

Loophole? Do you people not own Cripps?

 

[JT_the_Man]

Hold fire on the second trade Richmond have 6 ins into the 18 and only 3 outs so far, Naish might get dropped.

Im going Hayes to Hately tonight then I was going Wilkie to Boak tomorrow but i might hold 24 hours in case Hore gets dropped.

Yeah have only gone Young to Logue for now.

 

[Biggie]

Anyone trading Cripps?

 

[Jiska]

No trades this week. Time to consolidate.

 

[pendlebury_10]

Naish or Garner ?

 

[Benno_900]

Naish or Garner ?

Looking at Richmond's bench, Naish is getting dropped. Perhaps lineball between him and Butler.

 

[adammania9]

Dan Rich or Tom Stewart?

 

[Andrew Birch]

Dan Rich or Tom Stewart?

TStew over TRex for mine. Both good picks though.

 

[Metapod]

Looking at Richmond's bench, Naish is getting dropped. Perhaps lineball between him and Butler.

Think it stays. Bench will be: Houli, Bolton, Baker, Naish (Butler, Chol, Menadue, Graham getting chopped)

 

[pincrusher]

Think it stays. Bench will be: Houli, Bolton, Baker, Naish (Butler, Chol, Menadue, Graham getting chopped)

Why on earth do you think Graham would be dropped? I didn't see his last game, but statistically, he had 23 touches (11 contested) and 11 tackles (Prestia was next highest with 8 tackles). 3rd highest SC score in the team against the crows.

 

[enobrien]

Think it stays. Bench will be: Houli, Bolton, Baker, Naish (Butler, Chol, Menadue, Graham getting chopped)

Bachar and Baker the locks.

Next two spots are Graham/Naish (mid) or Bolton/Butler (fwd)
Not 2 of the same pos

So fwiw I think Naishys gone

 

[qqaaxx]

After jumping on Hurley two weeks ago for a bit of difference I’ll definitely be going Hore->Sloane via Duursma.

 

[magpies03]

Have a full team other thank Durs and Logue in D5 and D6. 8 Trades left.

Would like to downgrade Answerth this week to Naish/Garner this week and upgrade Durs next week to Hurn/Lloyd so probably just the 1 trade this week.

Or might upgrade Duurs to RIch but then have a backline without Lloyd or Hurn which is not healthy I dont think.

 

[Metapod]

Why on earth do you think Graham would be dropped? I didn't see his last game, but statistically, he had 23 touches (11 contested) and 11 tackles (Prestia was next highest with 8 tackles). 3rd highest SC score in the team against the crows.

Naish the better match up against saints IMO. Quicker.

Bachar and Baker the locks.

Next two spots are Graham/Naish (mid) or Bolton/Butler (fwd)
Not 2 of the same pos

So fwiw I think Naishys gone

More I think about it, is Houli locked? Clearly best best 22 but the fact he has been named on the extended bench, does that suggest he’s under an injury cloud?
Also interesting to note Short/Butler named in our VFL side. Don’t be surprised if Short gets a warm up in the VFL this week. Naish to take his spot, Graham to be named if that’s the case

 

[pincrusher]

Naish the better match up against saints IMO. Quicker.

More I think about it, is Houli locked? Clearly best best 22 but the fact he has been named on the extended bench, does that suggest he’s under an injury cloud?
Also interesting to note Short/Butler named in our VFL side. Don’t be surprised if Short gets a warm up in the VFL this week. Naish to take his spot, Graham to be named if that’s the case

All bench players are automatically named in VFL squads IIRC.

 

[Benno_900]

Bachar and Baker the locks.

Next two spots are Graham/Naish (mid) or Bolton/Butler (fwd)
Not 2 of the same pos

So fwiw I think Naishys gone

Locks:
Astbury for Balta
Short for Garthwaite
Soldo for Chol
Edwards for Higgins
Cotchin for Menadue

So Lambert for one of Butler or Naish it seems

Perhaps both go out if Bolton is in

 

[Benno_900]

All bench players are automatically named in VFL squads IIRC.

Short was named in the 18 though