Prediction 2019 "Hypothetical Trade, FA, random player you wish we could get" thread..

[MasterSamurai]

Btw, * it with this Bennell talk!! Injuries and/or drugs, whatever it is, it’s his ******* problem! This club needs to be ‘Alert’ to make sure we get the right people to guide to the Next’ with the youngsters!

 

[Bugs1977]

Btw, fu** it with this Bennell talk!! Injuries and/or drugs, whatever it is, it’s his ******* problem! This club needs to be ‘Alert’ to make sure we get the right people to guide to the Next’ with the youngsters!

Agreed. People talk about him like we’re gonna strike oil with him or something.

 

[Kinghts 24]

Are you saying something like:

GWS get:
Hawks 1st rounder (currently pick 6)

Hawks get:
GWS 1st rounder (currently pick 14)
GWS compo 1st rounder (currently pick 15)
Patton
Coniglio

GWS then uses pick 6 to draft Green and also have pick 10. Hawks get to sign Coniglio to a deal around 1m per season, get Patton and also have to late 1st round picks.

If this is what you meant then I guess it is doable but my concern is GWS might want a little more but you never know they might be happy with getting Green and keeping the other pick (currently pick 10).

SOLD!! This is the deal of the century.

By the way, the "sweentener" to GWS for us getting Coniglio for free is surely our willingness to take Patton off their hands and his big fat salary ;-)

 

[MasterSamurai]

SOLD!! This is the deal of the century.

By the way, the "sweentener" to GWS for us getting Coniglio for free is surely our willingness to take Patton off their hands and his big fat salary ;-)

Gws won’t be seeing that way though. It’ll be “ Which MoFo blinks first”!!!!

 

[Hawk_francais]

Realising that the Tim Kelly trade could potentially impact us depending where he goes.

1. Brad Hill could be negotiated as part of a three-way trade with the Dockers & Geelong. I don't think he's very likely to go to Geelong, could end up that we'll be asked to please Geelong to the tune of a late first rounder/decent player to go along with whatever Freo are sending them. I think this is less likely as I don't know what on earth would induce Tim Kelly to join Freo over WC.

2. If Kelly goes to WC it would almost certainly take them out of the race for Coniglio. They surely wouldn't still have cap space to sign two players on 800k-1m each. Coniglio surely doesn't go for Freo.

 

[TylerDurden]

Realising that the Tim Kelly trade could potentially impact us depending where he goes.

1. Brad Hill could be negotiated as part of a three-way trade with the Dockers & Geelong. I don't think he's very likely to go to Geelong, could end up that we'll be asked to please Geelong to the tune of a late first rounder/decent player to go along with whatever Freo are sending them. I think this is less likely as I don't know what on earth would induce Tim Kelly to join Freo over WC.

2. If Kelly goes to WC it would almost certainly take them out of the race for Coniglio. They surely wouldn't still have cap space to sign two players on 800k-1m each. Coniglio surely doesn't go for Freo.

Cannot see Kelly going to Freo under any circumstances.

Btw, he's definitely leaving.

 

[Bumps"N"Grins]

Cannot see Kelly going to Freo under any circumstances.

Btw, he's definitely leaving.

With the two Hills out that position could change.

 

[TylerDurden]

With the two Hills out that position could change.

That's what Geelong wants. It's not what Tim wants.

 

[OnceKicked50]

Mate of mine spotted Smith at the Holden centre yesterday.

 

[Brant]

Mate of mine spotted Smith at the Holden centre yesterday.

Did he buy one?

 

[Brant]

Mate of mine spotted Smith at the Holden centre yesterday.

Seriously though, who has the Holden Centre?

Lexus is Collingwood, right?

Is it Melbourne?

 

[Bugs1977]

Seriously though, who has the Holden Centre?

Lexus is Collingwood, right?

Is it Melbourne?

Holden Centre is Collingwood mate (training and administration base). Maybe Smitty was just checking all their feelings weren't hurt after last Friday night.

 

[HODGEYROAD]

Collingwood pretty much have nothing of note they could give us for Smith, isn't their 1st pick this season like late 30s or something ?

 

[Judd2Sewell]

By my quick estimation we will finish in 13th place and this would be how the picks end up (accounting for the swaps, etc):

 

[HODGEYROAD]

By my quick estimation we will finish in 13th place and this would be how the picks end up (accounting for the swaps, etc):

View attachment 707212

Trade it, we don't need another Dowler or Thorp.

 

[kirbatron]

Last 4 pick 6's

Francis (Hopper at 7)
Petrevski Seton
Stephenson
King (Rozee at 5)

Handy kids.

 

[4THAWN]

Oi so it just clicked to me why clarko wanted karl amon. Did some good things in the Showdown, good left boot as one poster has already pointed out to me weeks ago.

I think karl/jarman would be an amazing duo with the ability to swap out between a forward pocket, back flank, and could also drag hardwick into the mix for the forward line.

 

[Brant]

Oi so it just clicked to me why clarko wanted karl amon. Did some good things in the Showdown, good left boot as one poster has already pointed out to me weeks ago.

I think karl/jarman would be an amazing duo with the ability to swap out between a forward pocket, back flank, and could also drag hardwick into the mix for the forward line.

Amon is super quick & pretty aggressive, although (from memory) his aggression doesn't always lead to effective defensive efforts etc. like say Popeye's or Cyril's do.

No Thanks, to Hardwick as a forward.

 

[4THAWN]

Amon is super quick & pretty aggressive, although (from memory) his aggression doesn't always lead to effective defensive efforts etc. like say Popeye's or Cyril's do.

No Thanks, to Hardwick as a forward.

 

[Brant]

View attachment 707258

What's that?

 

[Bugs1977]

What's that?

I'll go with there Hardwick's stats

 

[4THAWN]

What's that?

some of blakes games in his 56 goal/16 game TAC cup season

 

[Brant]

I'll go with there Hardwick's stats

If/when we get relegated back to u/18's, he can play forward.

Until then, whilst up against AFL Defenders, he's too short to be a 3rd Tall, too slow to be a Small Forward & too bloody good in defence to be wasted through poor positioning.

 

[Bugs1977]

some of blakes games in his 56 goal/16 game TAC cup season

He certainly loves a goal (or 10)

 

[4THAWN]

If/when we get relegated back to u/18's, he can play forward.

Until then, whilst up against AFL Defenders, he's too short to be a 3rd Tall, too slow to be a Small Forward & too bloody good in defence to be wasted through poor positioning.

Could say sicily's too good in defense to be wasted through poor positioning, hasn't stopped clarko from trying it and will not stop clarko from trying it