Toast Coaches Votes 2019

[Nothing]

Not surprisingly Freo didn't get any votes for R16.

R17
Votes
10 James Worpel (HAW)
8 Nat Fyfe (FRE)
4 Bradley Hill (FRE)
3 Ricky Henderson (HAW)
2 Ben Stratton (HAW)
2 Mitchell Lewis (HAW)
1 Ben McEvoy (HAW)

Tally Name
65 Fyfe
35 Walters
35 B Hill
26 Mundy
17 Ryan
11 Wilson
9 A Pearce
7 Taberner
5 McCarthy
4 Langdon
3 Tucker
3 Hogan
2 Hamling
1 Blakely

Fyfe's tally of 65 surpasses the 2018 sixty to be his highest tally since 2016 (at least). Brad Hill's 35 surpasses his best Freo tally (34 in 2017).

Fyfe's equal 5th overall.

 

[Belnakor]

Fyfe's tally of 65 surpasses the 2018 sixty to be his highest tally since 2016 (at least). Brad Hill's 35 surpasses his best Freo tally (34 in 2017).

in 2015 he had 98 votes after 13 rounds...

 

[freo_leo29]

in 2015 he had 98 votes after 13 rounds...

that injury screwed him tho, he still lost

 

[Nothing]

in 2015 he had 98 votes after 13 rounds...

I only started keeping the tally in 2016. I figured 2015 would be higher.

 

[Belnakor]

that injury screwed him tho, he still lost

only because gray's coach gave him 5 in the last round deliberately

 

[freo_leo29]

only because gray's coach gave him 5 in the last round deliberately

Hannebery beat him tho

 

[ChimpaWompa]

I remember being annoyed by that too, Hannebery within striking distance of Fyfe in the last round and he miraculously gets the top coaches votes to clinch it..


heres the stats from that game, not exactly scandalous and in hindsight its obvious Longmire hated Tom Mitchell lmao, but still pretty suss.

 

[freo_leo29]

I think its moreso Fyfe got injured and lost due to missing games/playing injured in 2015.

Robbie Gray got 10 votes in the final round of 2014 when he tore us to shreds, Fyfe once again on the sidelines.


In an award where you can poll 6-10 votes each game for being top 3 on the ground, it is never good to be missing so many games.

 

[Joao]

Nobody actually thinks Hannerbery or Gray is better than Fyfe though (and I really like Gray).

 

[Nothing]

The votes for our game will be interesting. Any of 6 to 8 players could get votes.

 

[Nothing]

Votes vs Sydney
8 Jake Lloyd (SYD)
6 Rory Lobb (FRE)
5 David Mundy (FRE)
4 Tom Papley (SYD)
3 Bradley Hill (FRE)
2 Dane Rampe (SYD)
1 Sean Darcy (FRE)
1 Reece Conca (FRE)

No votes for Reid even though he kicked 21% of the game's goals. Brayshaw's contested possessions did nothing for the coaches, likewise Parker.

Tally Name
65 Fyfe
38 B Hill
35 Walters
31 Mundy
17 Ryan
11 Wilson
9 A Pearce
7 Taberner
6 Lobb
5 McCarthy
4 Langdon
3 Tucker
3 Hogan
2 Hamling
1 Blakely
1 Conca
1 Darcy

First votes for Lobb, Darcy and Conca. Freo's total votes go past 2017. ~24 off 2018. Mundy with votes in 5 games better than any season since 2016.

 

[Belnakor]

Votes vs Sydney
8 Jake Lloyd (SYD)
6 Rory Lobb (FRE)
5 David Mundy (FRE)
4 Tom Papley (SYD)
3 Bradley Hill (FRE)
2 Dane Rampe (SYD)
1 Sean Darcy (FRE)
1 Reece Conca (FRE)

5 : 3 Jake Lloyd
4 : 2 Lobb
0 : 5 Mundy
0 : 4 Papley
3 : 0 Hill
2 : 0 Rampe
0 : 1 Darcy
1 : 0 Conca

What a weird collection of votes?

 

[Lach72]

Those votes are cooked. Yo could watch that game and NOT give Joel Hamling a vote? And give Darcy one

 

[Righteo]

Lloyd's robust stat line was not commensurate with his perceived impact on the match. He played a proper Joel Bowden-type game.

Also GTFO with this no votes for Hamling bullshit. WTF is wrong with Lyon and Longmire?

 

[Chad in Vegas]

Those votes are cooked. Yo could watch that game and NOT give Joel Hamling a vote? And give Darcy one

Completely agree. Hamling was clearly the best player on the ground from what I saw. It was the defensive equivalent of a 6+ goal game from a forward. Darcy was a borderline liability for the first half and Lloyd deserves to be in the votes but not at 8.

 

[Snuffaluphagus]

Lloyd's robust stat line was not commensurate with his perceived impact on the match. He played a proper Joel Bowden-type game.

Also GTFO with this no votes for Hamling bulls**t. WTF is wrong with Lyon and Longmire?

Individually, Lloyd getting 8 and Hamling none is just weird, the fact they both happened is downright conspiracy level s**t. How did both coaches think Lloyd's side to side kicking and junk marks provide more value than what Hamling did

 

[MadEyeEmmy]

LOL Lloyd....he's a great fantasy pig but surely not much more than that

 

[PowerToThePurpl]

How Lukey Ryan and Hamling didn’t even poll at least 1 vote each is absolutely beyond me.

Edit: Brayshaw even???

 

[longsuffreosupp]

Maybe Reid and Hamling cancelled each other out. Both played well, but their opposition player played well too..

 

[Chad in Vegas]

Compare Hamlings stat line with Liam Jones from Carlton who got the max 10 votes against Gold Coast. Jones took 4 more marks (only 1 more contested mark though) but other than that the stat lines are almost identical. I didn't watch the Carlton game but it would be interesting to hear from someone that did as to how his game compared to Hamlings.

 

[masai]

Those votes are cooked. Yo could watch that game and NOT give Joel Hamling a vote? And give Darcy one

Jesus beeping Christ, what the flip does Joel have to do to get votes, climb a goal post !!!.

This is outright discrimination against our fullback. Obviously Darcy must be providing them with free milk.

No Joel, no Freo.

 

[Bender571]

At least Hamling got in the poll for player of the round.

 

[Nothing]

Votes vs Bulldogs
9 Marcus Bontempelli (WB)
9 Jack Macrae (WB)
3 Caleb Daniel (WB)
3 Jason Johannisen (WB)
3 Aaron Naughton (WB)
2 Andrew Brayshaw (FRE)
1 Bailey Dale (WB)

Brayshaw with his first votes for the year, after getting 3 votes in the Carlton game last year, a decent effort in a 50 point shellacking. He becomes the 18th player for Freo to get votes this year, equal to our number last year.

 

[Nothing]

Votes Player (Club)
9 Michael Walters (FRE)
8 Nat Fyfe (FRE)
7 Bradley Hill (FRE)
2 Aaron Sandilands (FRE)
2 Ed Langdon (FRE)
2 Tim Kelly (GEEL)


Tally Name
73 Fyfe
45 B Hill
44 Walters
31 Mundy
17 Ryan
11 Wilson
9 A Pearce
7 Taberner
6 Lobb
6 Langdon
5 McCarthy
3 Tucker
3 Hogan
2 Hamling
2 Brayshaw
2 Sandi
1 Blakely
1 Conca
1 Darcy

Fyfe up to 4th overall.

Sandi's first votes for the year, becoming the 19th player to get votes. Our total votes is greater than last year, with 269.
Brad Hill and Fyfe get a lot more voting games but Walters has had 4 BOGs (Hill one, Fyfe two).

 

[Funkster]

Votes Player (Club)
9 Michael Walters (FRE)
8 Nat Fyfe (FRE)
7 Bradley Hill (FRE)
2 Aaron Sandilands (FRE)
2 Ed Langdon (FRE)
2 Tim Kelly (GEEL)


Tally Name
73 Fyfe
45 B Hill
44 Walters
31 Mundy
17 Ryan
11 Wilson
9 A Pearce
7 Taberner
6 Lobb
6 Langdon
5 McCarthy
3 Tucker
3 Hogan
2 Hamling
2 Brayshaw
2 Sandi
1 Blakely
1 Conca
1 Darcy

Fyfe up to 4th overall.

Sandi's first votes for the year, becoming the 19th player to get votes. Our total votes is greater than last year, with 269.
Brad Hill and Fyfe get a lot more voting games but Walters has had 4 BOGs (Hill one, Fyfe two).

Wonder if Langdon had the 2 from one coach or 1 from each side. My guess is the one coach gave him the two, and that was the Freo coaches - they seem to rate hard work over finess and Langdon did work hard.