Opinion The 'Carlton related stuff that doesn't need it's own thread' thread

[Aphrodite]

You're being generous with the number of Suns fans. The way it looked on TV if you add the 6 & 5 in your number above that would be closer to the truth.

Couldn't hear them at all at the ground.

 

[DamianBis]

Bit harsh mate, people part with their hard earned to go and support their team, all supporters of all teams act the same way. Would you say this if the Suns had won the last two flags which could have been the case if things had of went right for them.

I go to between 5-10 games every year and I've never been at a game and seen an opposition team booed from start to finish like this. It's irrelevant who we were playing.whether suns are bottom or top. The booing when a player takes a good mark in their forward line is pathetic.

Personally there's probably 2-3 moments every game where I clap for the opposition. When Jeremy Howe gets up on someone's shoulders or Eddie slots one from 40 out on the boundary line I appreciate it.

I think it's just a tribal thing. You don't hear the opposition because there's so few people. So the few Nuffies instead of getting drowned out by opposition noise end up having other people join in.

On CPH1831 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[thylacine60]

I don't get booing. Like cheering double-faults. Odd.

 

[Robertio]

I go to between 5-10 games every year and I've never been at a game and seen an opposition team booed from start to finish like this. It's irrelevant who we were playing.whether suns are bottom or top. The booing when a player takes a good mark in their forward line is pathetic.

Personally there's probably 2-3 moments every game where I clap for the opposition. When Jeremy Howe gets up on someone's shoulders or Eddie slots one from 40 out on the boundary line I appreciate it.

I think it's just a tribal thing. You don't hear the opposition because there's so few people. So the few Nuffies instead of getting drowned out by opposition noise end up having other people join in.

On CPH1831 using BigFooty.com mobile app

Give the Adelaide oval a miss.

 

[Stamos]

I don't get booing. Like cheering double-faults. Odd.

I get it if the player has done something untoward. Or if the shot at goal has come from a dubious umpiring decision. I think booing in these instances is part of the culture of the game.

But not just because they're the opposition.

 

[Kruezing]

Let’s all go out this week and cheer the umps ...

 

[Robertio]

I get it if the player has done something untoward. Or if the shot at goal has come from a dubious umpiring decision. I think booing in these instances is part of the culture of the game.

But not just because they're the opposition.

I haven't once said i support booing, but it's there and has been there for a 100 years. Just another part of our game.

 

[thylacine60]

Let’s all go out this week and cheer the umps ...

not sure how you'd do that but it's a great idea.....

 

[Jabba73]

Let’s all go out this week and cheer the umps ...

not sure how you'd do that but it's a great idea.....

They already get cheered when they finally call one correctly in our favour ... pretty sure

 

[thylacine60]

you're not helping...........isn't there an umpire's round?

 

[DamianBis]

I get it if the player has done something untoward. Or if the shot at goal has come from a dubious umpiring decision. I think booing in these instances is part of the culture of the game.

But not just because they're the opposition.

Yup 100% agree. Nothing wrong with the cheer when someone misses after a dubious free kick or 50. But after every shot is silly

On CPH1831 using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Jabba73]

Read an article on Mitch Robinson and Malthouse and their time at the Blues but no link, sorry.

Robbo basically says the game has passed MM by and he can break players down but not build them up. Basically said MM took the fun out of footy.

 

[Blue Pulse]

Read an article on Mitch Robinson and Malthouse and their time at the Blues but no link, sorry.

Robbo basically says the game has passed MM by and he can break players down but not build them up. Basically said MM took the fun out of footy.

AFL 2019: Mitch Robinson reveals he began to lose love for footy under Mick Malthouse at Carlton

‘He made it very tough for me’: Ex-Blue says Mick ruined his Carlton career

www.foxsports.com.au

 

[Dadda Dave]

Read an article on Mitch Robinson and Malthouse and their time at the Blues but no link, sorry.

Robbo basically says the game has passed MM by and he can break players down but not build them up. Basically said MM took the fun out of footy.

I read that myself somewhere ...
So Mick is on the bottom of Robbo's Christams card list by the looks ..
Having that attitude, it's no wonder he lost the players..
Cranky ole prick..

 

[chunkylover53]

Oh man isn't Malthouse just copping it sweet at the moment - it's a beautiful thing.

Mitch Robisons comments aren't surprising, but Murph's reaction in his interview earlier in the week was hilarious. They must've really hated him.

How did a bloke so caught up in his own ego and bullshit make it through 31 years of coaching?

 

[Dadda Dave]

Oh man isn't Malthouse just copping it sweet at the moment - it's a beautiful thing.

Mitch Robisons comments aren't surprising, but Murph's reaction in his interview earlier in the week was hilarious. They must've really hated him.

How did a bloke so caught up in his own ego and bulls**t make it through 31 years of coaching?

Straight away when Murp was asked the question it was like... "WTF"

 

[Aphrodite]

Straight away when Murp was asked the question it was like... "WTF"

 

[Dadda Dave]

No wonder Eddie legged it ..

 

[chunkylover53]

Lol Murph genuinely smirks the second Malthouse's is bought up and you can see he's trying to hold back and be a robot and he just thinks '* it'.

 

[therubbernub]

Read an article on Mitch Robinson and Malthouse and their time at the Blues but no link, sorry.

Robbo basically says the game has passed MM by and he can break players down but not build them up. Basically said MM took the fun out of footy.

Coming from Mitch who would have absolutely no agenda

 

[Sector 7G]

Coming from Mitch who would have absolutely no agenda

Not exactly a stand alone opinion.
Nick Graham LOL'd at the thought of MM coming back.
Murphy was working on the principle of if you can't say something nice don't say anything at all.

 

[chunkylover53]

Coming from Mitch who would have absolutely no agenda

Yeah nah Mick made Murph captain and even Murph is laughing at him.. Robbo has gone on to be a BnF winner and leader at a current Top 4 club. Agenda or not their opinions have solid reasoning behind them.

 

[Jabba73]

Coming from Mitch who would have absolutely no agenda

Is his opinion, backed by others, irrelevant?

 

[therubbernub]

Is his opinion, backed by others, irrelevant?

Sacked from the club by the coach who disciplined him ? Yeah i would say his opinion is highly likely to be tainted. Who else backed him? And what did they SAY?

 

[therubbernub]

Yeah nah Mick made Murph captain and even Murph is laughing at him.. Robbo has gone on to be a BnF winner and leader at a current Top 4 club. Agenda or not their opinions have solid reasoning behind them.

I dont know why everyone is so certain that they know what is going through Murphs mind