Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion 2020 Changes

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

BEEG said:
Current structure is terrible, watching this live crap week in week out had become to much.

Can't go to Elliot 1 on 1 he is a shell of the player from 2 years ago.

Firstly we really need to look at some Indigenous players with speed to bring in through the draft for our forward line, enough is enough, how can the Eagles have Ryan, Cameron, Rioli.

We were all about defensive pressure last year Elliot and Cox I'm sorry but won't be needed.

Mayne Miocheck DeGoey
Papley Stephenson WHE

Pies need to go after Papley and Brad Hill these two players alone would make huge changes to our team dynamic

Trade
Elliot
Thomas
Sharenberg

Delist
Crocker
Wells
Broomhead
Varcoe
Magden
Reid

Trade/Sign
Papley
Hill
Click to expand...
I actually think Elliott is more a victim of poor/slow ball movement.
Small fwd is the worst position for that , it’s a feast or famine situation, mostly famine for us .
They’ve all kicked bags and had nothing games too.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

TKiL said:
we knew he had foot problems when we drafted him - his subsequent injuries have been in different parts of his legs but the warning was there - this guy is injury prone
Click to expand...

Who on our list is not Injury Prone? Can only think of De Goey,Grundy and Steele
 
Matt_352 said:
Definitely sack Harvey, how long does Bucks have on his contract? Looking more and more like 2018 was a fluke.
Click to expand...
Unfortunately the club wont get rid of him. Our only hope is that St Kilda force his hand and do us a favour and take him. That way he can keep St Kilda in the bottom 4 for years to come, where he coincidentally will go head to head with Buckley as he drags the club down to the bottom again.
 
Players that could leave us are from:


  • Varcoe
  • Reid
  • Dunn
  • Elliot
  • Wells
  • Goldsack
  • Dunn
  • Thomas
  • Daicos
  • Wills
  • Crocker
  • Murray
  • Broomhead
  • Appelby
  • Tohill
  • Madgen
 
Anyone remember my posting in the pre season
We're in a conundrum
Jeez I copped it

I suppose last season was as I predicted , a anomaly ,a chance to pinch one

Smacks of dogs 2016

We as I understand it
Should have moved Moore to sydney for Lloyd
Langdon to sydney for florent
Packaged Lloyd and Thomas for lynch or may
Packaged shaz and broomy to Sa for whatever
Rookies elliot, goldy

Thomas now is worth 1/2 what he was
Moore same
Philips to st Kilda for ?

We could have had this with luck

A spine
Rough head
Reid
De goey
Cox
Lynch
 
Darkyprotector said:
Anyone remember my posting in the pre season
We're in a conundrum
Jeez I copped it

I suppose last season was as I predicted , a anomaly ,a chance to pinch one

Smacks of dogs 2016

We as I understand it
Should have moved Moore to sydney for Lloyd
Langdon to sydney for florent
Packaged Lloyd and Thomas for lynch or may
Packaged shaz and broomy to Sa for whatever
Rookies elliot, goldy

Thomas now is worth 1/2 what he was
Moore same
Philips to st Kilda for ?

We could have had this with luck

A spine
Rough head
Reid
De goey
Cox
Lynch
Click to expand...
Lol Reid is cooked and Cox is shit
 
Roverjg said:
View attachment 716020
View attachment 716021

Despite the fact there is some I would like to move on because of their currency I feel the club will only act on those that are coming out of contract this year because of slaray cap constraints
Click to expand...
I would get rid of all the players on that list that are coming out of contract this year with the only exception being Noble and possibly Greenwood.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

TradeDraft said:
Players that could leave us are from:


  • Varcoe
  • Reid
  • Dunn
  • Elliot
  • Wells
  • Goldsack
  • Dunn
  • Thomas
  • Daicos
  • Wills
  • Crocker
  • Murray
  • Broomhead
  • Appelby
  • Tohill
  • Madgen
Click to expand...
You know what, If I woke up tomorrow and all of these players were gone, I doubt I'd lose any sleep. Some good players there, but I don't see any of them lifting us from our current woes
 
Matt_352 said:
Lol Reid is cooked and Cox is s**t
Click to expand...

Mate you know little
Quick to bag
But very slow on ideas
DO YOU EVER READ A THREAD

Note Reid centre half back
Note I said with any luck
Note start of the year

Here's a hint start posting like your having a discussion , try a open mind
We're guilty of expecting a different result doing the same old
For a start cox needs a partne who can take a overhead mark, who demands coverage
Maybe he won't then always be 1 out
Against 3
Gee that would help

A tunnelling free kick every once and a while for UNREALISTIC SPOILING ATTEMPTS WOULD BE GREAT TOO
 
Darkyprotector said:
Mate you know little
Quick to bag
But very slow on ideas
DO YOU EVER READ A THREAD

Note Reid centre half back
Note I said with any luck
Note start of the year

Here's a hint start posting like your having a discussion , try a open mind
We're guilty of expecting a different result doing the same old
For a start cox needs a partne who can take a overhead mark, who demands coverage
Maybe he won't then always be 1 out
Against 3
Gee that would help

A tunnelling free kick every once and a while for UNREALISTIC SPOILING ATTEMPTS WOULD BE GREAT TOO
Click to expand...
Feck me, how many times does he get tunneled. It's outrageous.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Opinion 2020 Changes

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top