Tulip
Hall of Famer
- May 3, 2009
- 37,249
- 34,495
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Tottenham
Lyon is a flog. 10 marks for Dunkley. He’s a kidfu** off Garry Lyon you phoney. Saying Melbourne have to make a decision on Kyle Dunkley in the off season.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Lyon is a flog. 10 marks for Dunkley. He’s a kidfu** off Garry Lyon you phoney. Saying Melbourne have to make a decision on Kyle Dunkley in the off season.
I’m wondering whether he was given the extension given the preseason injuries to try and and take the heat off Goodwin knowing it would be a lost season.Guess Pert will hand him a 4 year extension then...
He says as he has a sook at me without a hint of irony, don’t proof read many of your own posts apparentlyDo you only come out of hiding to have a cry ? Fair dinkum
You don't delist or make a call on a guy after HALF A SEASON! Garry pretends he likes Melbourne but he has nfi..
Righto pal...cause you’re the ******* righteous big guy on this board. Glad we can all look to you to tell us what we ******* think is wrong.It's not about effort at all. Collingwood gave up in the last because we aren't a threat
Right and there's 3 more years left in his deal for us to turn that round. 3 years is a * load of time to turn s**t around.Let's be honest we brought May in to take that next step and win a flag. He was a right now player. Ok calling him a bust was probably too harsh but it's certainly shaping as one. I reckon Mahoney would swap him for Ben King if we had a choice now.
We aren't 5-15 because of effort floggoRighto pal...
Whatever the reason it was a classic Melbourne mistakeI’m wondering whether he was given the extension given the preseason injuries to try and and take the heat off Goodwin knowing it would be a lost season.
It’s amazing how making the entirely wrong decision runs in the familyIs Wagner German for momentum sapper or something?
Yeah no s**t, but when we have a half of football to play it might be worth actually ******* going in a bit harder when 3 goals down don’t you think?We aren't 5-15 because of effort floggo
I agree with that. But his injury/suspension history is there. All will be forgiven if we make finals / win a flag with May a key cog but that seems a mile off.Right and there's 3 more years left in his deal for us to turn that round. 3 years is a fu** load of time to turn s**t around.
Could be a lack of effort due to lack of confidence in a game plan though.We aren't 5-15 because of effort floggo
They did go in hard. They swarmed the contest and Collingwood's midfield turned it into an uncontested game. The defenders put in a shitlosd of effort. The midfielders played like dumb campaigners who fall into the same positional mistakes as always. It's not an effort thingYeah no s**t, but when we have a half of football to play it might be worth actually ******* going in a bit harder when 3 goals down don’t you think?
Not really, things can turn fast. Look at Brisbane. Make some smart calls in the off season and actually spend time identifying and working on our problems and we might surprise ourselves. May can play mate.I agree with that. But his injury/suspension history is there. All will be forgiven if we make finals / win a flag with May a key cog but that seems a mile off.
Come on WW3!Its going to be difficult to make finals from here.
Well midfielders doing the same old same old is what I’d call a lack of effort. Call it cerebral effort then FFSThey did go in hard. They swarmed the contest and Collingwood's midfield turned it into an uncontested game. The defenders put in a s**tlosd of effort. The midfielders played like dumb campaigners who fall into the same positional mistakes as always. It's not an effort thing
I dunno I've seen plenty of effort all year. Just been unrewarded with s**t house ball movement.Could be a lack of effort due to lack of confidence in a game plan though.
If we aren't nearly as terrible, and May can play a full 22 games next year, he'll be AA. When he's actually played, he's been excellent.Not really, things can turn fast. Look at Brisbane. Make some smart calls in the off season and actually spend time identifying and working on our problems and we might surprise ourselves. May can play mate.
I’ve seen a fair lack of two way running though.I dunno I've seen plenty of effort all year. Just been unrewarded with s**t house ball movement.
Yeah, movement’s been s**t. My thinking is we had a bunch of outs early in the year which lead to out of position players and losses then when the season became unwinnable effort and confidence dropped away. Its not that they haven’t tried all year, it’s been a confluence of injuries, poor skills (from VFL players) and a subsequent lack of faith in game plan.I dunno I've seen plenty of effort all year. Just been unrewarded with s**t house ball movement.
Crack in you flogI’m enjoying eating our own tbh
You don’t finish second last without lacking effort though. I mean come on, we haven’t worked very hard. Oliver, Brayshaw and Viney have plodded.Yeah, movement’s been s**t. My thinking is we had a bunch of outs early in the year which lead to out of position players and losses then when the season became unwinnable effort and confidence dropped away. Its not that they haven’t tried all year, it’s been a confluence of injuries, poor skills (from VFL players) and a subsequent lack of faith in game plan.