Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Wilkie and Battle have both had excellent seasons. I'm against trading him though/
Not sure i'd describe Battle's season as 'excellent'...but showed promise.
Still, with Brown close to retirement i'm surprised that you'd let go of Jake.
Is it because his back injury is affecting his performance? Questionable character and effort at times as well.
Definitely the type of player we are crying out for, We obviously had a lot of success with the Brian lake trade. Be interesting to see what he’s worth. Looks like a salary dump so trade wise I don’t think they’ll get his full value, 2nd or third might get it done. Do the players actually like him? Seems like abit of a flogI think Clarkson flew to the USA to chat with Carlisle when the trade was at a stalemate and Hawthorn made a pitch for his services. He ultimately ended up at St Kilda but perhaps the Hawks would still be interested..?
I thought he was considered something of a leader at St Kilda. Not so much at Essendon but the story went that he grew up a bit after that trade, the snapchat scandal which saw his contract re-negotiated, and then the year off when he worked in construction or something while he served his suspension. Had some time to reflect on what he was doing and why.Definitely the type of player we are crying out for, We obviously had a lot of success with the Brian lake trade. Be interesting to see what he’s worth. Looks like a salary dump so trade wise I don’t think they’ll get his full value, 2nd or third might get it done. Do the players actually like him? Seems like abit of a flog
Salary isnt an issue. If he is traded, it will be to get currency for other trades so full value would be expected in picks.Definitely the type of player we are crying out for, We obviously had a lot of success with the Brian lake trade. Be interesting to see what he’s worth. Looks like a salary dump so trade wise I don’t think they’ll get his full value, 2nd or third might get it done. Do the players actually like him? Seems like abit of a flog
Not sure i'd describe Battle's season as 'excellent'...but showed promise.
Still, with Brown close to retirement i'm surprised that you'd let go of Jake.
Is it because his back injury is affecting his performance? Questionable character and effort at times as well.
Not just a salary dump but it’s sounding like the saints are the ones who want him out rather than the other way around, which will affect his value. What would you expect for him? I think we’d be keen but he clearly isn’t worth pick 10 with the doubts over his back and with a few of the story’s that flew around about his attitude etcSalary isnt an issue. If he is traded, it will be to get currency for other trades so full value would be expected in picks.
He doesn't want to leave, it's St. Kilda who don't want him.I reckon he wants a longer deal and Saints are just giving him the 1 year trigger. Either that or Clarko got on the blower and sweet talked him.
Collingwood should seriously consider him. Would fill their tall back hole or even go forward.
What are the Saints thinking? their only decent defender and they want to trade him lols or Essendon get Jake back means we can leave hooker permanently forward
Battles season was excellentNot sure i'd describe Battle's season as 'excellent'...but showed promise.
Still, with Brown close to retirement i'm surprised that you'd let go of Jake.
Is it because his back injury is affecting his performance? Questionable character and effort at times as well.
His first chat with the Dogs didn’t go well at all.How come footy fans feel the need to judge so harshly blokes they've never even met? Man's in a very stable relationship with a child and another on the way. It's been a good four years since the Snapchat scandal (which was purely him doing a line of snow, which every player does) and there hasn't been a single rumour or word of negativity about him since. Yet still clowns reckon he's a s**t bloke. Grow up.
Really hope the Pies have a look at him as a key position boost at either end. His form at the back end of 2014 (long time ago, I know) playing as a forward was stupidly good and he's obviously a proven elite key defender, one of the best going around when fit in my humble opinion.
For Melbourne clubs that need a key defender:
Ameet Bains being at the kennel is a very interesting chronicle, seeing as Bains would have overseen Carlisle's move to St Kilda in the first place. The Bulldogs' rumoured fat salary cap and real need for key defenders means at the least, they'll chat to Carlisle once again you'd reckon.
Hawthorn have a clear need for key defensive depth too and a partnership of Carlisle and Frawley would be a very good one. He'd take that back line up another level.
North Melbourne are on the way up and Scott Thompson has prematurely retired most would agree so unless they want to back in Durdin and McKay to hold their ground next year, the Roos will need a new tall defender and Carlisle is on the table.
Constantly cheating on your ex and snorting coke on snapchat speaks volumes of this bloke. Can play though.His first chat with the Dogs didn’t go well at all.