- Feb 15, 2006
- 5,524
- 3,438
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Sunderland & Penrith
Has ability but what price do you put on culture of a club on the line to sign him...
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
You don't get rid of donkeys like Stringer and Dahlhaus only to bring in one like Carlisle. Strong, strong no.
I reckon he will end up at Hawthorn. This time it’s for real.
2 x top 5 picks should do it.Really hope so mate. Only 27 (28 at the beginning of next season). Perfect replacement for Chip in a year or so.
If Saints are the ones potentially trying to offload him, they couldn't ask for much in return?
Not sure that totally the case.Really hope so mate. Only 27 (28 at the beginning of next season). Perfect replacement for Chip in a year or so.
If Saints are the ones potentially trying to offload him, they couldn't ask for much in return?
10 for Carlisle & a second (which we don't currently have) if Hawks were keen - what better place for Jake to end up than the family club...
Carlisle had a typical Carlisle year, moments of brilliance like against Freo followed by brain fades. Also can't discount the fact that he had surgery on his back and played underdone without a preseason when he finally got on the park.That’s overs.
Saints can keep him if that’s what they’ll ask for. The fact that Carlisle didn’t play well at all this year doesn’t do his market value any good.
Can we have Papley instead?Straight swap for Jones
Pretty damn happy to keep him if that's the case.Jon Ralph says Carlisle is dead set against leaving.
Really hope so mate. Only 27 (28 at the beginning of next season). Perfect replacement for Chip in a year or so.
If Saints are the ones potentially trying to offload him, they couldn't ask for much in return?
That’s overs.
Saints can keep him if that’s what they’ll ask for. The fact that Carlisle didn’t play well at all this year doesn’t do his market value any good.
If Hooker goes forward, its to settle Francis down backWhat are the Saints thinking? their only decent defender and they want to trade him lols or Essendon get Jake back means we can leave hooker permanently forward
That must make him feel awesome.LOL, Saints are only offloading him if he gets the pick picks to the land the players they are seeking.
No good offers and he stays.
Collingwood should seriously consider him. Would fill their tall back hole or even go forward.
Ah yes...nothing boosts club morale quite like publicly putting a player on the trade table and then making him crawl back the next season when you don’t get a good enough offer.LOL, Saints are only offloading him if he gets the pick picks to the land the players they are seeking.
No good offers and he stays.