- Nov 14, 2010
- 42,038
- 46,264
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
Think he would be good for us as a third tall defender
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: St Kilda v Western Bulldogs - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Saints at 51% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Port Adelaide offered him the most coin, he doesn't want to move to SA.
He's been best 22 at the Giants for a long time, what's changing next year to push him out?Solid player probably now at his best but won’t amount to anything else don’t see him best 22 at GWS next year.
Will be playing for Saints.He's been best 22 at the Giants for a long time, what's changing next year to push him out?
Don’t really want. What do you see as his best position?Likely to leave after Coniglio resigning and who needs a utility/depth player and has SC space to entice him, Saints/Blues/Hawks? Suns?
Don’t really want. What do you see as his best position?
Bench spot to fill in or winger, I think with a good coach/system he could be a tall defender
RFA unless we match you wouldn't be paying anything in trade.Whats he worth? we are desperate for players that can play on the wing.
RFA unless we match you wouldn't be paying anything in trade.
And yet they both did.I’ve never once said they won’t stay.
But I’ve said it’s extremely optimistic to think they will give up millions (100-300k a year under what they’ll get elsewhere) to sign at gws.
They might take slight unders to stay, but not millions over their contracts, and the 900-1m a season that he suggested would be 100’s of thousands below what they get offered
Have you seen our fwd line?Biggest underperformer in the comp.
If Tom Lynch from the Crows can be the player he is, then there is no way this guy can't be as good at the least.
He is one of the best endurance athletes in the comp and moves pretty well for a big fella too.
Never understood why the Giants didn't persevere with him as a forward after the early years because it was always the spot he showed the most promise in.
Was probably the Giants worst player getting a regular game this year after starting the year decently.
Needs to lift massively.
Have you seen our fwd line?
Boyd, then McCarthy, then HH.Yes, I was going to say that, but early on it was Cameron and Patton, who was the third tall?
And he never really played inside 50 anyway.
Like Tom Lynch, roaming high.
He was taken out of there well before Himmelberg and Finlayson established themselves
Boyd, then McCarthy, then HH.
Then HH and Finlayson took over the 2 and 3 spots.and Patton(through injury) is out.
He never seemed to be able to get the job done up front.
He is a utility. The old good at all things master of none.
He is/was useful and if he was on less money I would be happy for him to stay.Ah, yeah forgot about McCarthy.
Yeah, he should have moved out of the Giants long ago.
Too much competition for the spot he needs to be in.
And yet they both did.
Not what I was quoting.When even in the quote your quoting the first line tells you I’ve never said they won’t stay ive got to question your ability to comprehend anything
I said it was optimistic to believe both would sign on for massive unders.
And I was right. They didn’t.
He is/was useful and if he was on less money I would be happy for him to stay.
But when he re-signed he did it at a good time and is supposedly on very good coin.
Not what I was quoting.
The part where you said not for unders and wishful thinking for between 900 and a million a year.
They both signed for less than what was on offer from other clubs.
Not sure if that is true as he is actually an unrestricted free agent not a restricted one and to qualify to be unrestricted 'Players are not in the top 25 per cent of salaries at their club (that is, in the club’s top nine-10 paid players) are eligible for unrestricted free agency if they have served at least eight years with the club'.
Free Agency - AFL.com.au
Australian Football League. All the latest AFL news, video, results and informationwww.afl.com.au