Preview P.F. vs. GWS (Sat 21/09 4:35pm MCG) In: Reid/Aish, Out: JDG/Levi. Teams #1523

[unplugged]

First off... HOW BLOODY GOOD! We've booked ourselves a Home Preliminary Final!

It has now been confirmed that we'll take on GWS at the MCG.

I'd have to say Scharenberg missed the Geelong QF tonight due to match up and match up only. GWS tall forward line exposed us last time, so he plays.

Injury concerns: DeGoey, Greenwood
Banging the door down: Scharenberg, Varcoe, Aish, Reid
In reserve: Wells

IN: Reid, Scharenberg
OUT: DeGoey, Greenwood (both inj)

 

[sirlothie]

Autopsy thread first campaigner. I'm waiting for it. Carn the *en Pies!

 

[unplugged]

Autopsy thread first campaigner. I'm waiting for it. Carn the fu**en Pies!

I've made the preview thread my job. Anyone else can make the Autopsy thread

 

[sirlothie]

I've made the preview thread my job. Anyone else can make the Autopsy thread

You're quick off the mark, I'll give you that.

 

[jimmy35]

Oh yeah baby great gutsy, classy win with some great storylines. Darcy so good late, young Browny some class in the heat when it mattered, Sidey busted a nut again, Tay Adams a beautiful Collingwood champ, Treloar good and Pendles the champion such a beautiful man. Thanks to Bucks as well for what he’s given to our club. Love em all. Go Pies.

 

[Finnishpie]

De Goey and Greenwood both out, I’d say. Brown would be lucky to stay in, so out for me.

In Varcoe, Aish and Wells/Reid is we want to go big.

 

[mike123]

Out: De Goey, Greenwood
In: Varcoe, Scharenberg

Roughead back up forward Scharenberg and Mayne to cover Greenwood and Roughead down back, Varcoe up forward Sidey to the wing.

 

[Mickaman]

Barring possible injuries to de Goey and greenwood I can’t see any changes. Saying that I think Varcoe would be good to get back in.

 

[ppoiter]

What happened to De Goey and Greenwood? Couldn’t watch game

 

[Mickaman]

De Goey off early in the second hamstring tightness apparently. Greenwood I think knee not sure

 

[foreigner]

Out: De Goey, Greenwood
In: Varcoe, Scharenberg

Roughead back up forward Scharenberg and Mayne to cover Greenwood and Roughead down back, Varcoe up forward Sidey to the wing.

No, Roughy needs to be defence. Maybe Reid in if DeGoey doesn't come up in two weeks

 

[Finnishpie]

What happened to De Goey and Greenwood? Couldn’t watch game

Hamstring and knee.

Both would be in trouble for prelim. Greenwood probably for the season.

 

[Ron]

Levi suspected ACL according to Channel 7.
Big shame if it is accurate.

 

[mike123]

No, Roughy needs to be defence. Maybe Reid in if DeGoey doesn't come up in two weeks

Then

Out: De Goey, Greenwood
In: Reid, Varcoe

Mayne goes back to cover Greenwood

 

[ExcitementMachine]

Greenwood suspected ACL. Terrible news. Thankfully he's one we can most easily cover.

 

[Finnishpie]

Greenwood suspected ACL. Terrible news. Thankfully he's one we can most easily cover.

Yeah, I guess so. Though he’s been pretty good in defence this year.

 

[hellfire]

Levi suspected ACL according to Channel 7.
Big shame if it is accurate.

Oh god surely not?! What a bloody disaster for him. Just got a new contract too.

 

[stevebbb]

Aish in for Greenwood

 

[unplugged]

Out: De Goey, Greenwood
In: Varcoe, Scharenberg

Roughead back up forward Scharenberg and Mayne to cover Greenwood and Roughead down back, Varcoe up forward Sidey to the wing.

I like it.

That said, hopefully JDG is OK and plays. He's the type you'd take a risk on.

 

[shizzle]

Obviously the injured 2 are out. Varcoe and Shaz/Aish would come in. Of those not injured Noble had zero impact, he literally had 0 rating points, 7 clangers will do that. I'd hope Shaz or Aish replaces him.

Can't see anyone else being dropped, Thomas was poor, but he won't be dropped.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Out: Greenwood (inj.)
In: Aish

That is all. Self-fulfilling prophecy 1.01

 

[barrackers]

Need another tall forward as a get out option. No way Geelong take so many marks in our 50 with an extra tall.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Tough to drop players but looks as if Levi is out injured.

Also the player on the melting ice is Callum Brown.

De Goey until confirmation obviously stays.

In: M Scharenberg, T Varcoe

Out: L Greenwood (injured), C Brown.

If we feel Wells is good enough I’d play him over Varcoe. But a big if.
Interested in practice seconds game information.

 

[whiskeytown]

Out: De Goey, Greenwood
In: Reid, Scharenberg

Hopefully no more injuries come to light

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Need another tall forward as a get out option. No way Geelong take so many marks in our 50 with an extra tall.

Reid might be that option. Not sure we have another.