Teammates that didn't like each other

[Warpspeedo]

Lake. Did noooooooot get along with Buddoir at all.

Lakey gave him a few decent ear massages in the '14 GF

 

[Slats]

Wayne Carey at North Melbourne circa 2002.

 

[Baird]

Also Beams and Barham have a storied history

What happened there

 

[NonPhixion]

We May have had a player like that.

Well played sir

 

[JoeyPBLUES]

Cameron Cloke when he was at Carlton.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Cameron Cloke when he was at Carlton.

Sultana really hated him

 

[TheGreatBambino]

Teammates that didn't like each other

That's Carlton's issues for a significant time distilled to two pictures pretty well. Carlton are not the only club to have two players have a biff at training......richard taylor and phil matera ring any bells?

www.bigfooty.com

 

[Maurice Mitchell]

View attachment 761108

Not nominated by his teammates two years in a row for the MVP award. Says a lot

 

[NYRB]

Jason Akermanis anyone?

 

[StillAtLarge]

Not nominated by his teammates two years in a row for the MVP award. Says a lot

Yawn. Dangerfield is the aflpa president, he can't be nominated

 

[sosos]

Already 81 pages ......https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/teammates-that-didnt-like-each-other.452097/

 

[SickQwon]

Blaine Boekhorst

 

[Ambrose Burnside]

Nic Nat and Redden

What's the story there?

 

[ShadeyP]

Probably been mentioned as old ongoing thread.

Leigh Matthews and Don Scott went about their business, played well together but they didn’t speak to each other.

As Leigh once said, we didn’t have anything to say to each other so we didn’t.... didn’t affect their games.

Punching different clocks those 2 .

 

[blackcat]

Punching different clocks those 2 .

L for Leather: Leadership and life on the footy field and beyond

Three generations of football legends, Don Scott, Simon Madden and Luke Ball.

www.abc.net.au

 

[Two Planks]

We May have had a player like that.

Yet was nominated by the players to be captain.

 

[Lord_Flashheart]

Yet was nominated by the players to be captain.

Before he was caught with his dick where it didn’t belong.

 

[Post padding]

That was just the straw that broke the camels back.

All year he was sooky, whiny, disloyal, two-faced and a troublemaker around the club, and it all came to a head after that game (and on Mad Monday).

In usual Justin Murphy form, he turned up at Mad Monday (after being told he wasn't welcome) and tried to act like everyone's mate (all the while he was trying to get traded back to Carlton).
He was told numerous times to ____ off, and wouldn't take the hint, so Scarlett took him outside and gave him a hiding.

It's a shame really because Murphy was a gifted footballer, but he was just soft and a pretty poor bloke (hence why he was traded 4 times)

Scarlett should have been charged with assault to be honest.

Dog act

 

[The Plowking]

Scarlett should have been charged with assault to be honest.

Dog act

The way he carried on about Nick Maxwell when he retired shows the class of the bloke.

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

The way he carried on about Nick Maxwell when he retired shows the class of the bloke.

Would suggest that six All Australians and three premierships probably shows his class a bit more.

Scarlett's an abrasive personality, everyone knows that. But how did he "carry on" about Maxwell? It wasn't like he was holding press conferences or hijacking interviews: he put a bit of context through his biography to some of his actions during the 2011 grand final and why he and others felt there was a score to settle with Maxwell in particular. Who's buying the book? Geelong supporters. What do they want? Well from Scarlett, some clarity and his perspective on incidents like this and considering his pull no punches personality, some appraisals of his former teammates and opponents would be good too. Who he rated, who he didn't.

Then people in the media buy the book, look for anything which could be considered slightly juicy, contact the other party and his current and past teammates for a comment and perhaps milk another story or two out of it.

I can't remember Scarlett saying anything besides what's in the book about Maxwell or their interactions in the 2010-11 finals since then. I haven't read the book in a long time, but I remember being a bit disappointed really. It wasn't particularly interesting.

 

[Post padding]

Would suggest that six All Australians and three premierships probably shows his class a bit more.

Scarlett's an abrasive personality, everyone knows that. But how did he "carry on" about Maxwell? It wasn't like he was holding press conferences or hijacking interviews: he put a bit of context through his biography to some of his actions during the 2011 grand final and why he and others felt there was a score to settle with Maxwell in particular. Who's buying the book? Geelong supporters. What do they want? Well from Scarlett, some clarity and his perspective on incidents like this and considering his pull no punches personality, some appraisals of his former teammates and opponents would be good too. Who he rated, who he didn't.

Then people in the media buy the book, look for anything which could be considered slightly juicy, contact the other party and his current and past teammates for a comment and perhaps milk another story or two out of it.

I can't remember Scarlett saying anything besides what's in the book about Maxwell or their interactions in the 2010-11 finals since then. I haven't read the book in a long time, but I remember being a bit disappointed really. It wasn't particularly interesting.

Oh. So 6 x AA 3x Premiership player gives you the right to assault a guy.

Ok

 

[Xtreme]

Joel Selwood and Tim Kelly

 

[queensberryrules]

Sheedy and Hart.

Sheeds famously and with physical presence told Hart to stop whining about having to attend a footy kids event. He stopped whining and attended.


On SM-G955F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[MC Extra Dollop]

Oh. So 6 x AA 3x Premiership player gives you the right to assault a guy.

Ok

Of course not. I was responding to a completely different incident.

The version that I've heard from the Mad Monday incident is that it was a follow on from Murphy's open displeasure at the Milburn incident in the last game of the season. For what it's worth, my mood was pretty much the same as Murphy's at the time. It was understandable. But... you burn bridges doing that publicly, you're not part of the club.

Murphy was told not to come to the end of season function, he showed up anyway, he was told repeatedly to leave and ignored those requests and ultimately Scarlett took him outside and the rest is history. Hardly heroic from Scarlett, but not exactly a coward punch either. Perhaps if Scarlett had been a female and Murphy had a blowtorch handy, he would have given a better account of himself.

 

[Post padding]

Of course not. I was responding to a completely different incident.

The version that I've heard from the Mad Monday incident is that it was a follow on from Murphy's open displeasure at the Milburn incident in the last game of the season. For what it's worth, my mood was pretty much the same as Murphy's at the time. It was understandable. But... you burn bridges doing that publicly, you're not part of the club.

Murphy was told not to come to the end of season function, he showed up anyway, he was told repeatedly to leave and ignored those requests and ultimately Scarlett took him outside and the rest is history. Hardly heroic from Scarlett, but not exactly a coward punch either. Perhaps if Scarlett had been a female and Murphy had a blowtorch handy, he would have given a better account of himself.

You defended a bloke by his playing record .

And bashing a guy unconscious is not ok. Even if the guy wasn’t welcome.

And by the way. I’ve never defended Murphy. He’s a grub too. But to defend Scarlett is interesting