If the leak has come from us and we have therefore caused this story to linger for him next year, is it possible we have blown our chance to nab him next year
Bluemour Melting Pot XXI - Like seriously, the polar ice caps have got nothing on us
- Thread starter Blue Bloods
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
This is the most logical explanationAs I understand we are splitting Pick 9 and distributing the result to Sydney and Gold Coast for Papley and Martin respectively.
Casboult is staying.
That's really smart to have an agreement in place for two options.
Very well done....Very smart.
- Sep 5, 2011
- 8,248
- 15,913
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Dallas Cowboys, STL Blues
C4[2]Yo`DooR called it on the Port board in August this year, so it wasnt necessarily hidden...more a question of where the journalist got their information.
SOS knows what he’s doing
you’re the good mail mate - I trust this 100%
are you also confident we keep at least one of our first rounders (most likely next seasons?)
It's having two viable and acceptable options in place that makes it very smart
Smart and not easy to do. Hard enough getting an agreement on one trade scenario, let alone two.
Skull Face
Premiership Player
Basically tells us, if Martin gets done 1st we don't get Papley.
Wines isn't a Curnow replacement
If the proposed splitting of 9 lands both Papley and Martin.
That means that pick 4 this year has netted Carlton, a kid (Stoker, that they rated highly), a top 3 small forward in the comp (Papley) & a 100 game player who could be anything (Martin)
That is the definition of having your cake and eating it too
That means that pick 4 this year has netted Carlton, a kid (Stoker, that they rated highly), a top 3 small forward in the comp (Papley) & a 100 game player who could be anything (Martin)
That is the definition of having your cake and eating it too
Wily trout
All Australian
- Apr 19, 2017
- 877
- 2,894
- AFL Club
- Carlton
So in effect if things pan out, SOS will have converted our first pick this year into these possible scenarios:
A) Stocker and Papley (straight up #9)
B) Stocker and Papley and Martin (and a third rounder?) splitting #9 with Hawks
C) Stocker, Papley and Pittonet, again involving Hawks
D) Stocker, Papley, and Martin ( with a future second? ) and Pittonett , Hawks again to help out
I’m so
Lockatronicus
Team Captain
I say don't worry about Ollie wines. Let's keep next year's first and hunt down another young gun midfielder that can help Cripps and be good for years to come. We gotta play good footy this year and become more of a destination club!
What's Cam Raynors story?!?!
What's Cam Raynors story?!?!
- Sep 5, 2011
- 8,248
- 15,913
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Dallas Cowboys, STL Blues
I know theyre not like for like. Ed can run all day and tag, whereas Wines is a bit more inside and bash & crash. But I think our team will continue to evolve, and the role Curnow plays may be moved to someone like Dow, whilst we use Wines as an additional big body at the contest.
I didn’t read it like that.
All shall be revealed by tomorrow 7:30pm.
Not long now ladies and gentlemen
Popcorn time!
- Oct 23, 2016
- 718
- 2,222
- AFL Club
- Carlton
If we do manage to get papley and Martin while retaining next years first, what’s the chances we walk to port and offer it for wines.
He and we know it’s unders but if it means not putting up with 12 months speculation?????
He and we know it’s unders but if it means not putting up with 12 months speculation?????
myblueroan
Premium Gold
Eddie on SEN:
Kade texted me and it's great to know I'm not the oldest on the list.
Jeffy Garlett texted and asked me to put a good word in with the coach.
he speaks so well doesn't he!
Kade texted me and it's great to know I'm not the oldest on the list.
Jeffy Garlett texted and asked me to put a good word in with the coach.
he speaks so well doesn't he!
Skull Face
Premiership Player
Does this s**t really finish at 7:30pm? Almost lock in the 3 way Daniher, Papley, Phillips trade will be saved for the last 5mins to make a circus like last year.
You don't always have to replace like for like and Wines would be that mature and senior body that would replace ECurnow in the team.
If Wines is so desperate to get out, why wouldn't Essendon be after him? They should have the currency to get that deal done, should they get the deal done.
Extra exposure.
Extra $.
Gil needs a weekend yacht when the weekday one is getting a service.
These are the problems
It would be nice, but think the AFL rules for that to be even possible Carlton need to somehow get a future 4th back.
The rule is;
If a club trades a future first-round selection, it may not trade any other future selection from that same draft. But if a club keeps its future first-round selection, it can trade any of its future selections from other rounds.
The AFL can allow give you permission & Carlton could argue that they have taken so many kids and 1st rounders over the last 3-4 years. But your relying on the AFL.
So from the Papley, Martin, Philips or Pittonet deal Carlton would need a future fourth our way without touching any other picks from next year.
If suddenly one of these trades pop up and Carlton have a future 4th, then get excited
I see Stocker being a better version of Wines, we also have Dow who will be a burst bull type
Wines would be a great, but I would prefer players to be in/out mids
SPS with more speed
Same for us I reckon.
- Status
