List Mgmt. Carlton's 2019 Draft Thread

[murphster]

I am a realist, well, at least in my world

I was hoping for Rivers at 20 Arrow I know you wanted him.

 

[Bobmonkey]

45K views · 330 reactions | They were the busiest club on night one of the draft. Now hear from the man making all the big calls, SOS! Read up on the Blues' draft haul: https://bit.ly/35GHVNw | SuperCoach AFL

They were the busiest club on night one of the draft. Now hear from the man making all the big calls, SOS! Read up on the Blues' draft haul: https://bit.ly/35GHVNw

www.facebook.com

 

[HBF]

Philp is a 187cm balanced mid with extreme speed and acceleration that allows him to erupt out of stoppages and into clear air.

Whats his kicking like TSG?

 

[FlowersByIrene]

If we wanted Kemp at 9, picking him up at 17 and then a free hit at 20 for a very late pick (52) is definitely worth it.

If those who are unneasy think of it as if we got Kemp at 9 and Philp at 52 would they be happier?

 

[murphster]

Excellent pick. Pace. Developed more during the year. Skills solid. Hands solid. I’m happy. Btw I picked him for Swans in the Phantom.

We got the pace you wanted Windows just not Stephens but you would have to be happy with SOS work tonight.

 

[passmark]

oh man - how good is it? did not like us bidding on henry the poor loves!

Terrific Thy,

Fortunately I can read this at work.

 

[Aphrodite]

Inb4 the media focus on our 2 "failed bids"

It didn't take long.

 

[Kleenex Crew]

On face value, very happy with how night one has turned out. You don’t win premierships as the outstanding club in the competition by being common. He’s got quite a set on him does our SoS. Bold and brazen.

 

[Pafloyul]

A bloke with a bung knee and a mid nobody rated remotely close to the first round (wasn't even good enough for a mediocre Metro team).

Seems Carlton enough.

Finbar II tomorrow.

The last part, I can well imagine, unfortunately.

 

[Arr0w]

and pre-knee??

2

 

[TheRedPill]

We were going to trade up for Adelaide’s pick and had a deal agreed...but surprise, they reneged.

We rated Kemp over Flanders so trading down was a no-brainer.

 

[Les Bleus]

Can you imagine SOS's xmas tree?

Underneath are three envelopes, with his boys' names on them. Each has a message inside.

Jack: You can have your standard present this year. OR you can have an extra present. But then you have to swap presents with Ben next year. You are expected to get a better present than Ben next year.

Ben: You can have a $100 present. OR you can have a $200 toy that is broken. There is no guarantee the toy can be fixed.

Tom: You can have four presents instead of one this year. BUT in exchange you need to subsidise Jack and Ben's pocket money next year.

You’re too twisted ferrisb but I love it!


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Arr0w]

I was hoping for Rivers at 20 Arrow I know you wanted him.

Still do, damn it!!

 

[La Dispute]

Wonder where we see Philp developing. Plays similar to Dow in his draft year, and we seem pretty set for inside/outside mids with Setters and Stocker also in the mix. And we’d also just taken Kemp.

Just don’t really see an obvious position or role in the team for him, unless some more serious draft watchers can enlighten me?

 

[Mr_Plow]

We were going to trade up for Adelaide’s pick and had a deal agreed...but surprise, they reneged.

We rated Kemp over Flanders so trading down was a no-brainer.

We were planning to take Young?

 

[The Smoking Gun]

Whats his kicking like TSG?

He's not on the same level as Ash, Young or Rivers, but more than competent and gets decent penetration. Certainly much more reliable than Dow.

 

[Ollo]

We were going to trade up for Adelaide’s pick and had a deal agreed...but surprise, they reneged.

We rated Kemp over Flanders so trading down was a no-brainer.

Any idea why Robertson keeps sliding?

 

[Jimmae]

I mean pick 22... wasn't hoping for much at 55

I can't even remember the last draft where there wasn't value on the board at 50-70. We need a ruck, we need role players. I wonder if we'll target Nick Bryan at our next pick?

Additionally, I would have been happy to trade down into a range for Jeremy Sharp and boosted our 4th pick up the order.

 

[Pafloyul]

We can probably get Ned Cahill at 43 or whatever it is after bids.

Nope, I hope SOS continues not to recognise what a small forward looks like.

 

[tencentpiece]

We were going to trade up for Adelaide’s pick and had a deal agreed...but surprise, they reneged.

We rated Kemp over Flanders so trading down was a no-brainer.

They didn't reneg, it was based on their player not being there and he was.

 

[Mr_Plow]

Wonder where we see Philp developing. Plays similar to Dow in his draft year, and we seem pretty set for inside/outside mids with Setters and Stocker also in the mix. And we’d also just taken Kemp.

Just don’t really see an obvious position or role in the team for him, unless some more serious draft watchers can enlighten me?

Midfield depth, at this stage. Will breath down Dow's neck, which is a good thing.

Cripps (mid), Walsh (mid), Setterfield (mid), Kemp (mid/fwd/def), Stocker (mid/def), SPS (mid/def/fwd), Dow (mid/fwd), Cuningham (mid/fwd), LOB (mid/def), Fisher (mid/fwd), Williamson (mid/def), Kennedy (mid/fwd), Philp (mid).

It's a good mix of players with multi-positional ability. Deep midfields are the way to go.

 

[La Dispute]

They didn't reneg, it was based on their player not being there and he was.

Was there any doubt McAnsey would be available at 6?

 

[branedotorg]

Oh god...



Why am I reminded of Hide the Pain Harold??!

View attachment 785766

Off topic but:

Experience: my face became a meme

My wife hated Hide the Pain Harold – until I got paid for a Hungarian TV commercial

www.theguardian.com

 

[happydude]

Midfield depth, at this stage. Will breath down Dow's neck, which is a good thing.

Cripps (mid), Walsh (mid), Setterfield (mid), Kemp (mid/fwd/def), Stocker (mid/def), SPS (mid/def), Dow (mid/fwd), Cuningham (mid/fwd), LOB (mid/def), Fisher (mid/fwd), Williamson (mid/def), Kennedy (mid/fwd), Philp (mid).

It's a good mix of players with multi-positional ability. Deep midfields are the way to go.

First time in god knows when I am happy with the list we have built.

If we can have a crack at Paps again next year we will be all but set and ready to fine tune.

 

[rog1995]

Stocker, Kemp & Philp for Mcasey.