List Mgmt. Carlton's 2019 Draft Thread
- Thread starter Arr0w
- Start date
- Tagged users None
He’s not wrong there I was shocked they once again didn’t take a big bodied inside mid, dodo is a crap list manager with no concept of how to build a decent list.Hitler is not impressed with Dodo's latest effort. Made by a Bombers fan:
Hitler reacts to Adrian Dodoro's list strategy
Hitler is upset that we didn't draft any inside mids, especially since we have nonewww.captiongenerator.com
Blues-Crows draft night shenanigans revealed
Carlton thought they had a deal. Adelaide thought they had an agreement, but says it was no deal. It was enough that they both shook hands on shall we say an arrangement.
- Sep 25, 2013
- 14,910
- 29,017
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Interesting Knightmare gave about 6 clubs an A+ in his review yet managed to give us a C.
Picked Kemp at 17 who he rated top 5.
Called Philp a reach at 20 despite having him in his own top 30.
Called Ramsey a low production production player despite having multiple 30+ games when moving into the midfield.
Selected for needs in the rookie draft where other clubs recycled players (we have been smashed for this over the years).
Failed to mention one Jack Martin in the PSD.
We/SOS have really rustled some feathers this off season. Couldn’t be happier with how it’s worked out.
Picked Kemp at 17 who he rated top 5.
Called Philp a reach at 20 despite having him in his own top 30.
Called Ramsey a low production production player despite having multiple 30+ games when moving into the midfield.
Selected for needs in the rookie draft where other clubs recycled players (we have been smashed for this over the years).
Failed to mention one Jack Martin in the PSD.
We/SOS have really rustled some feathers this off season. Couldn’t be happier with how it’s worked out.
That doesn't sit in line with what you put forward though.
Of course we're after talent but it was clear to me for the reasons we targeted certain players, I mentioned.
Let's agree to disagree that we took on Betts, prioritised Papley, hunted Martin and got him to bolster our forward line..
Hell, even Coniglio is a goal-kicking mid and which is why I wanted him above Wines and many others, although there were other reasons involved.
On another note:
This is what you just said - "So speed and footskills as a priority? That was our glaring needs after all"
So you sort of agree that needs to play out no matter whether one doesn't want to say.
I think needs always play a part in the draft because I've seen it over and again and we saw it again in recent days.
All in all, the CFC did very well. That's all that matters
- Sep 25, 2013
- 14,910
- 29,017
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Good point
- Moderator
- #4,259
Hitler is not impressed with Dodo's latest effort. Made by a Bombers fan:
Hitler reacts to Adrian Dodoro's list strategy
Hitler is upset that we didn't draft any inside mids, especially since we have none
Of course the Nazis support *
I think we did well here. Nice blend of types and allows a lot more options for match committee to make sure we don't lose games as a result of leg speed. Nice job 
- Moderator
- #4,262
JuddgementDay
Brownlow Medallist
I'm excited to see how Philp performs
We know what to expect from Kemp and Martin
But, Philp technically is the only player that we traded up for
So SOS and Co must really rate him - especially if you compare to all the players that are left outstanding
SOS has also given up a prime tactical draft position for this, i.e. the start of RD2, which comes with a premium - heck, we could have got GC pick #11 next year
We know what to expect from Kemp and Martin
But, Philp technically is the only player that we traded up for
So SOS and Co must really rate him - especially if you compare to all the players that are left outstanding
SOS has also given up a prime tactical draft position for this, i.e. the start of RD2, which comes with a premium - heck, we could have got GC pick #11 next year
Wickzki
Definitely Sam MacLure.
- Oct 1, 2010
- 24,033
- 56,233
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Ophidians Old Boys, Blazers, MCFC
Josh Honey, too sweet to be sour, oohhhh yeah, diggit
Yeah I agree on Sharp and as I posted earlier I think Ramsay is actually an upgrade on Sharp as he has an inside and contested game that is near on non existent in Sharps game as well as having the speed and I think he is a better kick as well, a much better choice for a lot less.
Jeremias
Moderator
- Sep 26, 2004
- 46,176
- 62,548
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Moderator
- #4,268
Not interesting at all. In fact not even worth noting.
KM does a sensational job with draft profiles but his draft ratings are, and always have been, completely laughable.
The ratings are when he removes his scout hat and replaces it with his Collingwood fanboi one.
I haven't read his piece but I'll bet everything I own that he had Collingwood near the top of his ratings, and Carlton near the bottom. Am I right?
Last edited:
Wickzki
Definitely Sam MacLure.
- Oct 1, 2010
- 24,033
- 56,233
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Ophidians Old Boys, Blazers, MCFC
Far too generous. Christopher Durrrrrrr
- Banned
- #4,270
Also doesnt make the players we chose any better or worse - should just form your own opinion if we did well or not (not aimed at you Jeremias but in general)
This is the bloke that thought Charlie Curnow was a terrible pick
zeggie
You can't kick goals when you're unconscious.
KM seems to really rate Flanders, yet he was a massive slider and multiple clubs overlooked him. Interesting.
In fairness to KM, for example he had Philp going at #24 to Brisbane, but much lower in his own rankings as there was talk that they were keen on him
Therefore, rightly or wrongly, he is grading clubs based on his own power ratings rather than those that are actually in the know.
Anyway, I've taken no notice of "grades" since we according to many won the 2010 draft by landing all of Watson, McCarthy and Mitchell.
Therefore, rightly or wrongly, he is grading clubs based on his own power ratings rather than those that are actually in the know.
Anyway, I've taken no notice of "grades" since we according to many won the 2010 draft by landing all of Watson, McCarthy and Mitchell.
Your being very generous Aph.
