Catters 070911
Club Legend
- Oct 13, 2017
- 2,270
- 2,101
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Banned
- #1
I still don't understand why GCS would let Jack Martin go to the PSD.
They might have not got what they wanted, but it is better getting even a fifth round pick then nothing at all.
The Suns say that they were making a stance, but what did it prove, when Martin got to the club he wanted regardless?
Where was this thread to re-draft him, and make him an example?
Also, it shows the lack of consistency of their whole draft policy. Last season, GCS traded Steven May out, even though he never said that he was leaving. He just didn't sign a new contract, even though he still had a year of his contract remaining.
Stewart Dew said that he took this stance because he only wanted to coach players who wanted to be there, but Jack Martin wanted to leave, and didn't want to be there, and yet they played games with him.
So they traded out a contracted player in May a year early to get something for him, even though he never expressed any wish to leave, yet let go of an uncontracted player, who did want to leave, and didn't even try to get something for him. Either the club massively overrates Martin, to not accept whatever deal Carlton made to them, or they continue to be a shambles, who can't stick to a consistent policy when it comes to players leaving.
They might have not got what they wanted, but it is better getting even a fifth round pick then nothing at all.
The Suns say that they were making a stance, but what did it prove, when Martin got to the club he wanted regardless?
Where was this thread to re-draft him, and make him an example?
Also, it shows the lack of consistency of their whole draft policy. Last season, GCS traded Steven May out, even though he never said that he was leaving. He just didn't sign a new contract, even though he still had a year of his contract remaining.
Stewart Dew said that he took this stance because he only wanted to coach players who wanted to be there, but Jack Martin wanted to leave, and didn't want to be there, and yet they played games with him.
So they traded out a contracted player in May a year early to get something for him, even though he never expressed any wish to leave, yet let go of an uncontracted player, who did want to leave, and didn't even try to get something for him. Either the club massively overrates Martin, to not accept whatever deal Carlton made to them, or they continue to be a shambles, who can't stick to a consistent policy when it comes to players leaving.