Autopsy Roast : Bevo’s stubborn match day selections and the loss to St.Kilda

[D Mitchell]

Anyone saying we needed to rebuild one of the youngest premiership teams in history is simply an excuse and not the reality

Stringer, Dalhaus, Roughhead got ahead of themselves. 2016 was built on the 'all in' principle. Bev inherited a team, wants his own, can't blame him for that, he wants a dynasty, not just a Flag. He sees the Stringer-Dalhaus cancer, cuts it out. The team was young enough anyway. Defendable decisions.

 

[Yojimbo]

Anyone saying we needed to rebuild one of the youngest premiership teams in history is simply an excuse and not the reality

Yet to see anyone say that or use the word rebuild, adjust because of injury, form, retirements and rule changes yes definitely,
but as I said in the other thread had Dickson and Stringer kept returning 106 Goals a season I doubt Bevo changes anything.

 

[Mattdougie]

Yet to see anyone say that or use the word rebuild, adjust because of injury, form, retirements and rule changes yes definitely,
but as I said in the other thread had Dickson and Stringer kept returning 106 Goals a season I doubt Bevo changes anything.

And as I said you are wrong and assuming

I showed you as a team we had next to no change in points scored for or against on 15 and 16 UNTIL we changed and ruined that.

but you keep making it about two blokes not the entire team

 

[Mattdougie]

Stringer, Dalhaus, Roughhead got ahead of themselves. 2016 was built on the 'all in' principle. Bev inherited a team, wants his own, can't blame him for that, he wants a dynasty, not just a Flag. He sees the Stringer-Dalhaus cancer, cuts it out. The team was young enough anyway. Defendable decisions.

Garbage

Show me a coach in any sport in history that had systematically pulled apart both Personal and system as much as we did in one off season?

clearly changes could have been made but not a Complete overhaul on a winning system

And how is that dynasty going?
One of the most ridiculous arguments is that Bev inherited the team and wanted his own!!!! Really? He is that arrogant he can’t accept winning unless it’s “his” team??? So for Bevs ego we have been shite for 4 years and you can’t blame him for that? Okay

 

[D Mitchell]

Garbage

Show me a coach in any sport in history that had systematically pulled apart both Personal and system as much as we did in one off season?

clearly changes could have been made but not a Complete overhaul on a winning system

And how is that dynasty going?

Garbage is a bit strong. Who knows what's happening in Bev's mind. I think he was intending a dynasty, who wouldn't have been after that GF with such a young team ? It's one thing to translate a magical September into the Premiership, another to found a Hawthornesque dynasty. Not yet but don't give up hope.

 

[Yojimbo]

And as I said you are wrong and assuming

I showed you as a team we had next to no change in points scored for or against on 15 and 16 UNTIL we changed and ruined that.

but you keep making it about two blokes not the entire team

Actually you included finals into calculations for Points For and Points Against to which I said "Take your crayons and go away if
you can't handle the truth". Thanks for destroying my Luck Beveridge tribute thread by the way and I used Dickson and Stringer
because they were examples of the few pure forwards we had on our list at that point in time.

 

[Mattdougie]

Actually you included finals into calculations for Points For and Points Against to which I said "Take your crayons and go away if
you can't handle the truth". Thanks for destroying my Luck Beveridge tribute thread by the way and I used Dickson and Stringer
because they were examples of the few pure forwards we had on our list at that point in time.

sorry I wasn’t aware kicking more points than the opposition regardless how it was done wasnt important, Braun’s must have confused me that the bigger score wins

My error

 

[Cadillac]

Very disappointing so far, and I reckon you are right in scrutinizing the coach.

Hey, I get it, you have the shits at the moment, and so would I.

I can't see the point in bringing in big blokes and not significantly changing up the game plan though, and I reckon that has you in your current predicament.

Hey snake, We miss you around here mate. when can we get you back to offer some more words of wisdom? What do you think we will need to do to turn things around?

2 months ago you were 2-0 and had the courage to come to our board and critique our 0-2 start, our premiership coach and game plan. Since then you’re 1-12, sitting 17th on the ladder. Been forced to abandon your VFL program because of financial difficulties and the dogs are sitting in the 8.



Life comes at you fast.

 

[Snake_Baker]

Hey snake, We miss you around here mate. when can we get you back to offer some more words of wisdom? What do you think we will need to do to turn things around?

Sack the coach and strengthen the spine.

 

[Cadillac]

Sack the coach and strengthen the spine.

A good thing the dogs are getting the best key position player in the draft then. But let’s not pretend like you haha any idea about footy anyway. Didn’t you say last week that Naughton doesn’t kick goals against good teams?

 

[Snake_Baker]

A good thing the dogs are getting the best key position player in the draft then. But let’s not pretend like you haha any idea about footy anyway.

Indeed. You can't rely on Josh Bruce just to show up against North once a year.

Didn’t you say last week that Naughton doesn’t kick goals against good teams?

He hasn't this year. He's a 2nd string KPF. A very talented player though.

 

[Cadillac]

Indeed. You can't rely on Josh Bruce just to show up against North once a year.



He hasn't this year. He's a 2nd string KPF. A very talented player though.

He had two off season surgeries including one a week out from round 1. And missed a chunk of footy after round 4. But of course that’s clouded your judgement enough to forget how many big games he had against top 4 sides last year lol.

 

[Snake_Baker]

He had two off season surgeries including one a week out from round 1. And missed a chunk of footy after round 4. But of course that’s clouded your judgement enough to forget how many big games he had against top 4 sides last year lol.

Yeah righto mate, I'm not spoiling for a fight and you dragged me in here.

He's a good player.

 

[Boristown]

He hasn't this year. He's a 2nd string KPF. A very talented player though.

Dogs are lucky they have a gun KPF falling into their laps in Ugle-Hagan. A combo of JUH and Naughton will be tough to beat in 3-4 years.