-
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Is GWS's premiership window about to close?
- Thread starter GC2015
- Start date
- Tagged users None
I've never seen a team with so many problems that can be attributed back to the coach. Poor game plan, soft game style, seemingly a lack of motivation. I can't work out why Leon Cameron is still employed.
If you look at a guy like Jeremy Cameron, he is simply not worth a million dollars in that team. In another team, absolutely.
If you look at a guy like Jeremy Cameron, he is simply not worth a million dollars in that team. In another team, absolutely.
From last night's team, they still had seven players who have made the AA squad of 40: Kelly, Cameron, Whitfield, Shaw, Haynes, Coniglio and Ward. Ward and Shaw are past their best but the other five I'd say are elite players. Then there's Taranto and Hopper who are close to if not elite mids based on 2019 form and the way they've developed. Add Greene to the mix, although as you say if often injured.
I'd say that's seven/eight top liners in their team. Williams is a rung below but also a terrrific player.
- Thread starter
- #155
Anything other than a finals appearance will be deemed a failure of a year for the Giants. Here are their remaining 2020 fixtures:
R13 v West Coast @ Optus Oval
R14 v Fremantle @ Optus Oval
R15 v Carlton @ Metricon Stadium
R16 v Adelaide @ Adelaide Oval
R17 v Melbourne @ The Gabba
R18 v St Kilda @ TBA
In this shortened season, teams will likely need 8.5/9 wins (with a healthy percentage) to qualify for the finals and the Giants currently have 6 wins and 5 losses with a percentage of 98.2%. So, the question is, can GWS win at least 3 of their remaining 6 games this year and build enough percentage to hold off other teams? If the answer is yes then their premiership window may not be shut. Don't forget, this is a team that qualified for the Grand Final from 6th position last year.
R13 v West Coast @ Optus Oval
R14 v Fremantle @ Optus Oval
R15 v Carlton @ Metricon Stadium
R16 v Adelaide @ Adelaide Oval
R17 v Melbourne @ The Gabba
R18 v St Kilda @ TBA
In this shortened season, teams will likely need 8.5/9 wins (with a healthy percentage) to qualify for the finals and the Giants currently have 6 wins and 5 losses with a percentage of 98.2%. So, the question is, can GWS win at least 3 of their remaining 6 games this year and build enough percentage to hold off other teams? If the answer is yes then their premiership window may not be shut. Don't forget, this is a team that qualified for the Grand Final from 6th position last year.
Kapow!!!
Brownlow Medallist
I'd say 5 of those 6 games are winnable for GWS.
- Apr 26, 2011
- 10,420
- 12,319
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Wimbledon AFC
Ross Lyon to kick their asses next year to a cup.
Only the 8th-oldest team this year. They're still in the sweet spot if Clarko decides to jump ship.
- Oct 3, 2009
- 2,280
- 3,460
- AFL Club
- Richmond
They'll be lucky to win one if they play the way they did last night.
- Apr 13, 2015
- 1,953
- 2,668
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Ive always considered them flakey and they’ve never really done anything to disprove that over a consistent period of time. Mentally and physically fragile.
- Jan 17, 2013
- 7,585
- 8,270
- AFL Club
- GWS
Deserve everything they are copping at the moment. Absolutely terrible. Won’t get near it this year. Might be time to find a new coach.
- Jun 22, 2008
- 24,580
- 21,275
- AFL Club
- Geelong
Yes.
In previous years they've had key injuries at bad times. 2016 was their best chance.
Coach is no good either.
In previous years they've had key injuries at bad times. 2016 was their best chance.
Coach is no good either.
GWS Goose
Brownlow Medallist
They did play in the GF last year with a stack of players out. Not exactly soft stuff
They have such a potent forward line and they don’t seem to take advantage of it. I don’t know, I look at their team and on paper they look like they could be so dominant. I don’t understand why they play this slow defensive style.
- Sep 18, 2014
- 22,036
- 19,896
- AFL Club
- Geelong
- Other Teams
- Man United, San Antonio Spurs
GWS should throw the kitchen sink at getting Clarko. Cameron is not upto it, if they can get Clarko in, probably convinces Jeremy Cameron and Kelly to stay.
I also think it’s time the Hawks/Clarko separates as well, everyone wins.
I also think it’s time the Hawks/Clarko separates as well, everyone wins.
- Oct 5, 2004
- 12,329
- 12,888
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Richmond
Wouldn’t be surprised to see GWS win this week. They are the sort of team that reacts well to getting a rocket.
Regardless, they will still sneak into the eight and from there anything can happen.
Regardless, they will still sneak into the eight and from there anything can happen.
GWS Goose
Brownlow Medallist
Exactly. How many coaches get sacked after making 4 finals series in a row. Is there a better coach around sure. But no one gets sacked with the record LC has
Sure. But if Clarkson is avaliable (a big if) you go for him. And it isn't quite the same, but Grant Thomas got replaced after three seasons of making finals. For similiar reasons actually that are being suggested in here; an extremely talented side that he wasn't able to get the best out of. GWS have one of themost potent teams in the competition on paper and sometimes they play like they just entered the season again.
If Clarko had this list he would get rid of 25% of the players as they are not a team but a group of individuals that all want to be the player that does it all which really is not their fault.
If you look at my team Richmond players like Graham , Broad , Short , Castagna , Vlastuon , Astbury etc etc know what their roles are and are not expecting to be the 'Champion' that wins the game themself's but there is cohesion and synergy.
When i look at GWS its like a showroom but none of the cars get to be driven when it rains
Clarkson would drill that out of them , Could you just imagine Josh Kelly getting told to tag Macrae or Cameron to play a defensive foward role on Grimes
they just wouldn't know how because all throughout their careers from under 14's they have been free wheeling with talent
If you look at my team Richmond players like Graham , Broad , Short , Castagna , Vlastuon , Astbury etc etc know what their roles are and are not expecting to be the 'Champion' that wins the game themself's but there is cohesion and synergy.
When i look at GWS its like a showroom but none of the cars get to be driven when it rains
Clarkson would drill that out of them , Could you just imagine Josh Kelly getting told to tag Macrae or Cameron to play a defensive foward role on Grimes
they just wouldn't know how because all throughout their careers from under 14's they have been free wheeling with talent
- Thread starter
- #171
Maybe the AFL will step in and make sure Clarko ends up at GWS next year? Otherwise the league potentially faces multiple years without NSW participation in the finals. A lot of the hard work in regards to expansion will be undone if both NSW teams are stuck outside the top 8 for the next 2-5 years.
blckcaviar
Team Captain
- Jul 21, 2018
- 484
- 1,259
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Has a club ever bounced back well from a really bad GF loss?
GWS Goose
Brownlow Medallist
They haven't even missed the finals once since 2015 yet.
This is the oddest year ever, and they are out of the 8 only on percentage. Before the weekend had won 3 in a row. With the run home, they'll probably make the 8 this year.
Yet you are suggesting the situation is so dire the AFL step in and place a coach in place because the hard work of expansion will be undone.
They were diabolical on the weekend and overall aren't playing well this year, it is unbelievable the overreaction here. They beat Richmond like 3 weeks ago.
The squad is actually fairly young, it isn't aging out, and there is loads of young talent in the development side. It is a younger side than Carlton which everyone describes as developing.
Dr Awkward
Norm Smith Medallist
- Mar 23, 2009
- 5,296
- 4,946
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- San Antonio Spurs
Serious question - isn't there some link between teams getting belted on grand final day and then having a terrible year the next year?
West Coast.
Similar threads
