Lore
Moderator ❀
- Dec 14, 2015
- 44,904
- 66,335
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Jye Caldwell & Georgia Clarke
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Don't go there.
I'd say it's questionable Dodoro or anyone paid by the club spent any time specifically watching any of Z. Clarke, Snelling and Cutler (the big body). It wouldn't be hard for me to accept Phillips arrived as no more than Sheedy's recommendation. Sheedy's recommendation was definitely mentioned by Dodoro.
I include Snelling, not because he's bad, but because AD's post mid-season draft comment was "he arrives as the best athlete on our list". Yes Adrian, 10 kgs ago when he tested at the AFL combine his numbers were very impressive. If Snelling was capable of any of that testing from 2019...
Well if he watched Cutler and Snelling and his comments are anything to go by he is such a bad judge that he should be sacked immediately and we should look at some sort of recovery of all of the money he has made in property deals using his connections only made due to his position.
Anyone who has watched Cutler version 2018 and the few games in 2019 before he got injured would know the current version is playing at about a quarter of what he was.
Cutler did suck at so much though that it didn't seem like a justifiable pick up, to me anyway. I was never going to lie to myself and say I liked him getting on-board. I never liked it. The positivity around it was irrational to me.I think he should be gone, but when we pick someone up, why would you go out and say "well he sucks at this and this" instead of being positive?
I watched plenty of Brisbane games and thought he was pretty solid with a few flaws. But if you're a list manager and you've just recruited a player you're hardly going to come out and say he sucks, are you?Cutler did suck at so much though that it didn't seem like a justifiable pick up, to me anyway. I was never going to lie to myself and say I liked him getting on-board. I never liked it. The positivity around it was irrational to me.
Rather, I mean the positivity from some on this board. It seemed like a lot of supporters just threw their lot behind Dodoro and Cutler the instant he was traded in. At that point I was still supporting Dodo, but I couldn't see the sense in recruiting Cutler.I watched plenty of Brisbane games and thought he was pretty solid with a few flaws. But if you're a list manager and you've just recruited a player you're hardly going to come out and say he sucks, are you?
We didn't.Soft as butter, to think we wasted a 2nd rounder for this useless campaigner!
Wasn't it a future second? Either way still a wasteWe didn't.
Nope. A future 3rd which would have ended up as points.Wasn't it a future second? Either way still a waste
Ok, Yep correct.Nope. A future 3rd which would have ended up as points.
I see what you did there.Never have I seen a player his size do soft at the footy.
Cut him loose, he brings nothing
The fact that he gets selected ahead of anyone tells me that A- the selectors/coaches have no idea B- Dodoro has no idea C- we are that bad.......Never have I seen a player his size do soft at the footy.
Cut him loose, he brings nothing
Would not want to be betting the farm on it at our club.It’s just about a career ender for whoever’s idea it was to recruit this bloke.