Discussion 2021 Player X v Y v Z

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Wines v Gaff

campaigner Ive deleted accounts for less

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

OK campaigners Im well drunk and uits 4am butr here goes

Cripps vs Walsh vs Gaff

Lots of upside with Cripps although he looked slow last year.

With fewer rotations, a return to longer quarters and sheer gut running endurance i think Gaff could be a sensational POD.

Having spent a couple of years away from SC I don't know much about Walsh.

Thoughts?

Gaff **** off

Taranto + 50k vs Rowell for M5

Taranto is a proven 100 scorer over a season with a couple extra preseasons but had a down year. Rowell's scoring ability is off the charts but the dude has played in 4 AFL games.

Leaning Rowell for upside but it's a tough one.

Bold now **** off. Plus GWS suck so Tara will kill it

Dusty v Butters

lol Should I risk it for the biscuit. Ive only been playing this game for 10 years.

A: Stewart, Harmes, Green, Heppell
B: Lloyd, Webster, Taranto, rookie

Cumming vs Young or (someone in that price bracket ~$290K max)

B

Taranto and Macrae

Vs

Rowell and Jelly

First option you spledid puppy loving west coast campaigner

Atkins v Hately v Heppell

Had Heppell this whole time seems a safer bet

Get ****ed you wanna be

A few more from me:

1. Fyfe vs Danger
2. Dusty vs Short
3. Heppell vs Caldwell

Danger
Short
Caldwell

Wines v Gaff

lol campaigner

Hunter Clark vs Liam Duggan

Duggan Maybe

Really battling with the MPM v GNR strategy

A: Dow, Heppell, Harmes, Stewart
B: Rookie, Taranto, Lloyd, Rookie

A but only because covid BS

Langford vs Parish

Parish

Bont v Merrett

lol Bont
merret cant recieve CD because it as too small

A: Oliver, Docherty
B: Petracca, Stewart

A by all the country miles

 

[Flandersss]

Laird v Stewart v Daniel
Taranto v LDU
Dow v Campbell

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Laird v Stewart v Daniel

all with a different bye - which bye suits?

 

[zoomba23]

campaigner Ive deleted accounts for less

Sorry campaigner. Just that I still don’t know my ass from my elbow despite playing this prick of a game for umpteen years. I’m sure it’s a feeling you’re familiar with

 

[stevebbb]

Laird v Stewart v Daniel
Taranto v LDU
Dow v Campbell

Can't split them myself, currently have them. Stewart seems like the safest pick of the lot.

Taranto.

Campbell looks good there's no Lloyd today. Dow probably safer right now.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Sorry campaigner. Just that I still don’t know my ass from my elbow despite playing this prick of a game for umpteen years. I’m sure it’s a feeling you’re familiar with

**** I hate that turncoat Wines

 

[stevebbb]

Laird vs Dusty vs MID premo for a similar price

 

[Flandersss]

Laird vs Dusty vs MID premo for a similar price

Laird

 

[Flandersss]

Oliver v Petracca v Fyfe

 

[ImissFrosty]

Oliver v Petracca v Fyfe

Big dawg tracc. Another level to go.

 

[Juzzomac]

Oliver v Petracca v Fyfe

In terms of safety, it's in the order you listed.

On Petracca, would lock him in if he didn't play for Melbourne but I can just see him getting burnt by role, even though I think he's their best mid. Could go anywhere between 105-130 and that scares me.

 

[stevebbb]

Oliver v Petracca v Fyfe

Trac. Top 3 in the Brownlow again is guaranteed, might win it tbh

 

[Jiska]

Oliver v Petracca v Fyfe

Forget Fyfe. Love him. Gun. But too injury prone.

Find a way to have both Piggy and Trac. Scarily enough, both still have improvement in them.

Big dawg tracc. Another level to go.

So does Piggy.

 

[Jiska]

Daniher vs Tyson

 

[Flandersss]

Daniher vs Tyson

Daniher - Looks in unreal shape

Not sure Tyson has the JS with Cunnington to come back etc

 

[Jiska]

Oliver v Petracca v Fyfe

Also, here's my current M1-M5

 

[ImissFrosty]

Daniher vs Tyson

Daniher, the fact that people are even considering dom Tyson makes me wanna spew.

 

[AD03]

I’m stumped on this one...

DEF: seagull + L McDonald
&
MID: Walsh + Rowell

v.

DEF: Laird + T Stewart
MID: Piggy Oliver + LDU

 

[Flandersss]

I’m stumped on this one...

DEF: seagull + L McDonald
&
MID: Walsh + Rowell

v.

DEF: Laird + T Stewart
MID: Piggy Oliver + LDU

2nd one easily

Taranto over LDU

 

[pulpdriver]

Fyfe va Jelly
Assuming you probably only get 16 games out of either but who will score more?

 

[Flandersss]

Fyfe va Jelly
Assuming you probably only get 16 games out of either but who will score more?

Fyfe is lyfe

 

[Significant]

Lazzarro v Brockman

 

[Mt Isa Mustang]

Lazzarro v Brockman

Brockman guaranteed starter, Lazaro not so sure.

 

[Mt Isa Mustang]

I’m stumped on this one...

DEF: seagull + L McDonald
&
MID: Walsh + Rowell

v.

DEF: Laird + T Stewart
MID: Piggy Oliver + LDU

Option 2, choose someone other than ldu.
Caldwell or taranto