Prediction Changes: Round 3 Vs Cartlon + Pre-match discussion

[MrDanggazz]

Leave any changes and pre-match discussion below.

 

[_007_]

Out: Fyfe and Acres.

In: Treacy and Sturt.

Colyer for Walters if fit.
Logue for Cox if required.

 

[Bastyy]

Out: Fyfe, Acres
In: Treacy, Sturt

Walters I'm not overly hopeful for, but could be back.

 

[ImperialPurple]

When will Valente get a run? That’s my question...

 

[sherrif]

Out: Fyfe, Acres
In: Treacy, Sturt

Walters I'm not overly hopeful for, but could be back.

I can't see them omitting one player who plays mid and one player who play mid/forawrd for two pure forwards.
Blakely and Treacy in for Fyfe and Colyer would be my choice. Logue fo Cox if there is anything wrong with his hip.

 

[SHill Shall]

Out: Fyfe, Acres, Colyer
In: Treacy, Sturt, Walters

Colyer was much better today but still managed to have me cursing in the last. And we know he can go full dunderhead at any time. If Walters is not 100% ready, then Henry (who the coach has already said will be back)

Then the following week Fyfe comes in for one of the rucks (Treacy can ruck in F50). Makes us a little more mobile.

 

[ImperialPurple]

Tabs, Treacy, Darcy, Meek is a lot of tall! Then Schultz, Switta and add in Walters is a lot of small.
Not much in between by way of medium forwards, except Frederick.

I don’t think Blakely automatically gets a game just because he was sub today.

I only saw the second half - how did Giro go?

 

[wayToGo_]

In: Walters, Sturt, Treacy, Logue

Out: nah cbf thinking about that yet - just enjoying the win.

 

[FreoRicci]

Carlton have a tall back and forward line. Could we throw Treacy in for a debut?
Interesting times.

 

[FreoRicci]

In: Walters, Sturt, Treacy, Logue

Out: nah cbf thinking about that yet - just enjoying the win.

Out: Colyer, Blakely, Fyfe and Giro. Can do it

 

[Quazar]

Tabs, Treacy, Darcy, Meek is a lot of tall! Then Schultz, Switta and add in Walters is a lot of small.
Not much in between by way of medium forwards, except Frederick.

I don’t think Blakely automatically gets a game just because he was sub today.

I only saw the second half - how did Giro go?

I thought Giro was mostly underwhelming, he didn't do a lot wrong - he just didn't impact the game in any noticeable way. Tugged the wing a fair bit and chipped the ball around a few times. He's easily replaceable for me, dependant on personnel. To be honest I thought Colyer was better. Never thought I'd be typing that before the game!

 

[wayToGo_]

Out: Colyer, Blakely, Fyfe and Giro. Can do it

Reckon that'd be tough on Colyer. What was his kicking efficiency today? Did a 180 from last week.

edit - it was 83.3%.

 

[FreoRicci]

Reckon that'd be tough on Colyer. What was his kicking efficiency today? Did a 180 from last week.

That’s true. But you have Schulz and Switkowski kicking goals. With Walters and Sturt as quality. Something has to give

 

[Quazar]

Can't see there being too many changes based upon a winning result. Maybe depends on Fyfe's concussion situation and if Conca is injured

IN: Sturt, Treacy

Might be too soon for Walters and Logue, depending on how conservative we decide to be. All 4 in would be handy, hard to drop too many after today

 

[wayToGo_]

That’s true. But you have Schulz and Switkowski kicking goals. With Walters and Sturt as quality. Something has to give

Yeah I agree can't drop Switta, Schultz or Freddy off that game. Make Walters earn his spot via the WAFL? lol

 

[Quazar]

Yeah I agree can't drop Switta, Schultz or Freddy off that game. Make Walters earn his spot via the WAFL? lol

Oooooooooooh, you naughty boy

 

[Mr Cheese]

I thought Giro was mostly underwhelming, he didn't do a lot wrong - he just didn't impact the game in any noticeable way. Tugged the wing a fair bit and chipped the ball around a few times. He's easily replaceable for me, dependant on personnel. To be honest I thought Colyer was better. Never thought I'd be typing that before the game!

Thought Giro was slow to play on. Quick player but slow decision maker based on today's showing. Could just be rusty though, played well enough to keep his spot over Acres.

 

[Quazar]

Thought Giro was slow to play on. Quick player but slow decision maker based on today's showing. Could just be rusty though, played well enough to keep his spot over Acres.

Yes agree, he's missed a lot of football. Good to see him out there getting an opportunity. Could be making way next for a Walters though

 

[Heart Of Purple]

Treacy —> Fyfe (logical & easy choice)

Could also see:
Sturt —> Colyer (he was good today but of the small forwards he’s the weakest - he does play a bit higher but Frederick could play that role)
Logue —> Chapman (his kicking was great today but his work in tight wasn’t great and got caught out of position defensively a few times)


Think Walters comes back a week later.
Henry comes back via the WAFL.
They’ll probably change the sub over too, I’d look at any of the guys dropped or Thomas/Western


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Dockeroo]

The whole “ya can’t drop anyone after a win” theory is stupid. If Walters is fit he comes straight in, simple as. He’s an AA for gods sake. What are we going to do - play him at Peel in WAFL round 1 just because Colyer hit a few targets today?
Sturt is also too good for WAFL and needs to come in and add some goal scoring power if available.

 

[Quazar]

remember when we we linked with Casbolt a few trade periods ago (or probably more)...?! Even with our talls "crisis" I think we dodged a bullet there, watched him the 2 times they've been on 7 and he's absolutely dog poo

 

[Freo Big Fella]

OUT: Fyfe (inj), Blakely
IN: Treacy, Walters/Sturt/Valente (fitness pending)

 

[wakojako]

My only two ins are Treacy and Blakely.

Sturt and Logue need some time in the wafl. Walters is still 50/50 on his injury. Henry also needs some wafl game time because he thinks he is better than what he is. Carlton are going to throw everything they have at us. We have a winning side so no point making too many changes.

And yes before you all kill me sturt and logue can come in against N Melb the next week.

 

[Sweetback]

Sounds like Sonny is in next week going by JL’s presser

 

[trenton wave]

Sturt and Walters in
Fyfe and giro out

blakely is perfect medical sub to play in multiple roles